Lists by Egi_David_Perdana
And from now on at least a weekly, I'll add a comment from critics concerned about the films on my list expect rangking 1 & 2 by me
I will not provide a critique review from many critics for films who out from top 500 or even out of the list
Already 126 years since the discovery of the first film in the year 1888 through Roundhay Garden Scene although this includes a short film but this is the first film ever made in the historical records, within a period of 126 years that too many events like the bitter sweet sorrow in the film industry for example, began to distrust of the people on the speak film when the silent film era was victorious until competition with television industry many movies economy made in a difficult or made during the war at that time not a few directors and producers who fear and choose how to safely make the war film genre to support the dictator on it, it's no wonder a lot of 40s films like propoganda nazi or communist soviet but there is also a brave fight like Charles Chaplin's satire on Adolf Hitler through the work of satire war comedy, The Great Dictator.
When the movie is more developed in the presence of staining not a few who are still wearing black and white pattern due to the expensive cost of color film when it is considered superior but not a few critics and laymen consider black and white film is better because it has been accustomed.
In 1941 the boy genius Orson Welles also appears with his movie titled Citizen Kane a film inspire the next independent film for more work, Orson many changes including the cinematographyor lighting a peak into the movie Citizen Kane was named best film of all time by critics and Any layman, I mention this as a Welles film independent film because this is the first film made by Welles although the cost is not cheap, well from the film Welles is a link that is not always a movie madeby the director not named at that time meant that ugly mean time, Welles was not named as it is now.
While in another country for example in France during the year 50 to 60 large-scale changes in the industry that the era before the end of the 40s too bored with the movie genre Kingdom or the theme of nobility, although there is also apraised Les Enfants Du Paradis such as society at that time was more interested in seeing a beautiful woman and the scene shooting from Hollywood movies than seeing a movie by them are considered boring but in the era of the late 50s to 60s showdirectors who make major changes to the French cinema, one of them is Jean-Luc Godard.
While in Japan although its history is long but that marked the era of Japanese film revival is a 50s era began in 1950 starting with success film Rashomon by Akira Kurosawa in 1950 and followed by other films including Ugetsu Monogatari from Kenji Mizoguchi and Shichinin No Samurai Masterpiece from Akira Kurosawa.
Talking about movies, films can also be called a culture, yes the film is the culture it describes our current situation through celluloid, arguably yes film is a time machine that connects us with eras cultures before, even my feel if the culture of a nation is good then it will produce a good film too, then the long history I will release best films of all time in my view, it might be controversial but I know my choice because I've thought about this carefully, this is the best movie of all time in my view.
And my messages do not look at movies from one or two sides but look at it from the whole, I am also here trying to straighten misplaced that old movie is bad and movie today was good
I gave an assessment of some aspects that influence, stories, plots, cinematography, shot as well as virtual creative, beauty, witty dialogue and acting that are right on target, not contrived as natural and film are real events, wardrobe and makeup are excellent, the setting and the proper lighting, editing is not flawed and imperfect, complex scripts yet easy to understand precisely the film does not deviate too far from a script already written, as well as a reference list of best film by critics and media assessment survey as a list list AFI, BFI (Sight & Sound) or TSPDT, Village Voice, Films101 more often a film into list best critics and survey various media it will be increasingly high rangking.
But from it all there's also which has special conditions such as Ladri Di Biciclette because I consider that film to be the most beautiful films ever made and The Tree Of Life which I consider that film is best film with best cinematography ever created or Shichinin No Samurai as the most influential film in the face of the Earth according to me personally, and Casablanca with the best film with best screenplay ever writen version Writers Guild of America, the privilege of each of those movies give assessment plus than other films.
Top 10 21st Century who enter this list for 2015 revision:
2 Copy Shop (Short)
4 The Tale of The Princess Kaguya
5 Waltz with Bashir
6 In Vanda's Room
7 No Country for Old Men
8 Synecdoche, New York
9 The Gleaners & I
10 Holy Motors
Top 5 Documentary Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Olympia 1. Teil - Fest der Völker & Olympia 2. Teil - Fest der Schönheit (tie)
2 The Hour of the Furnaces
3 The Sorrow and the Pity
4 Hoop Dreams
5 Waltz with Bashir
Top 5 War Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Vals Im Bashir
2 Germany Year Zero
4 The Big Red One
5 The Thin Red Line
Top 5 Horror Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
3 Woman in the Dunes
5 Cat People
Top 5 Thriller Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 The Usual Suspects
3 No Country for Old Men
4 La Haine
Top 5 Animated Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Kaguyahime no monogatari
2 Waltz with Bashir
3 Watership Down
4 Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind
Top 5 Comedy Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Copy Shop
2 Bringing Up Baby
3 His Girl Friday
4 Swing Time
5 The Big Lebowski
Top 5 Sci-Fi Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
2 E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial
4 Close Encounters of the Third Kind
5 The Holy Mountain
Top 5 Fantasy Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Copy Shop
2 The Tale of The Princess Kaguya
5 The Holy Mountain
Top 5 Tv/Mini Series who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Scener ur ett äktenskap
2 Roots (1977 mini series)
3 Doomed Love (1979 mini series)
4 The Sopranos
5 Up (series)
Top 5 Short Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Copy Shop
2 Unsere Afrikareise
3 What's Opera, Doc?
5 Zvahlav Aneb Saticky Slameného Huberta
Top 25 Foreign Language Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
2 Olympia (part 1 & part 2) - Tie
4 Aleksandr Nevskiy
5 Scenes from a Marriage
6 Woman in the Dunes
7 Kaagaz Ke Phool
8 Le plaisir
9 The Tale of The Princess Kaguya
10 The Earrings of Madame de...
11 The Hour of the Furnaces
12 The Sorrow and the Pity
13 Doomed Love (1979 mini series)
14 La Terra Trema
15 Waltz with Bashir
16 Van Gogh (1991)
17 Early Summer
18 Germany Year Zero
19 Autumm Sonata
20 Red Sorghum
21 Ballad of Narayama (1958)
22 A Short Film About Love
23 An Autumm Afternoon
25 Life and Nothing More...
Top 25 All Time Greatest Films who enter this list for 2015 revision:
1 Boyhood - Top 100
2 Hour of the Wolf - Top 100
3 Olympia (part 1 & part 2) - Tie - Top 150
4 Kwaidan - Top 200
5 Mr. Smith Goes to Washington - Top 200
6 It Happened One Night - Top 200
7 Copy Shop (Short) - Top 200
8 Aleksandr Nevskiy - Top 250
9 Bringing Up Baby - Top 250
10 Scenes from a Marriage - Top 250
11 Melancholia - Top 250
12 Woman in the Dunes - Top 250
13 Roots (1977 mini series) - Top 250
14 Kaagaz Ke Phool - Top 250
15 Le Plaisir - Top 300
16 The Tale of The Princess Kaguya - Top 350
17 The Earrings of Madame de... - Top 350
18 The Hour of the Furnaces - Top 350
19 His Girl Friday - Top 350
20 The Sorrow and the Pity - Top 350
21 Wanda (1970) - Top 400
22 Doomed Love (1979 mini series) - Top 450
23 Swing Time - Top 450
24 The Last Picture Show - Top 450
25 Hoop Dreams - Top 450
Always up and growing
rank order only to the top 10, the rest does not sort
ps: actually I want to add Gengsi Dong (Warkop Prambors, indonesia, 1980) because that's one of the best comedy I've ever seen, but yet I don't find the profile on imdb
Ps: Top 71 is at my greatest films of all time (2015 revision) expect 20. 30, 34, 35, 51, 58, 62 & 67 but positive enter at 2016 revision
Ps: All films on list potential in at my greatest films of all time (2016 Revision)
Enter, Out, Fallers & Climbers:
Potential to enter:
35 Rhums (2008)
Once Upon a Time in Anatolia (2011)
The Man Without a Past (2002)
Infernal Affairs (2002) - re-entry -100
Evolution of Filipina Family (2004) - re-entry - 96
In the City of Sylvia (2007)
Zero Dark Thirty (2012)
Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives (2010) - Potential Climb at Best Film of All Time (2016 Revision)
Offside (2006) - Potential Fall at Best Film of All Time (2016 Revision)
Potential to Climbs:
Goodbye, Dragon Inn (2003) ---- Max Up at Top 50
Songs from the Second Floor (2000) ---- Max Up at Top 50
Potential to Falls:
Simon shares his life with Laurence. Both his parents were killed in a riot in Los Angeles by an group that was was run by none other than Simon. Both his mom and dad was shot in turn for fake accusation that they created the riot. The shooters are Simon's men who pretended to be the police. It was said that Mayor of Los Angeles has ordered on-the-spot execution to whoever involved in the riot.
And of course most of the victims are those who actually most loyal to the government. Laurence was attending a singing class when this happened, oblivious to the sinister scheme Simon played to murder his parents. He was eerily singing John Lennon's Working Class Hero when the shot silenced her parents.
But with his active involvement in left wing movement, Simon is now a taret for major American law enforcement. The FBI wants him, as does the CIA and the police. Thanks to a double agent named Paul Danke, the law enforcer found out about Simon and his whereabout. Danke, a swedish by origin, infiltrated Simon's organization for many years, attempting to gather information to be given to the government.
He used an alias by Sam Michel, a low-level member within the organization that preventa him from being able to access clasaified information on who runs the organization on its highest level. He almost run out of patience especially while being regularly pressured by the police about such information.
Order to watch over Simon comes directly from the American President Jacobs Huston, as he found out about Simon and his plot in many riots. Huston suspects Simon, the ex-boxer, to have many followers from the underworld, that caters to the business in murdering people by order. The victims are mostly those who have a pro-government stance, and although killing seems to be rampant so far no man has been successfully arrested on ground of murder for they are being protected by some mysterious figure.
President Hustons thought the figure would be a person highly involved in politics as well as the leading man of the left wing for the group of rioters had to be governed by a highly skilled and intelligent person while the movement of the left wing and the rioters are identicals.
Being highly intelligent himself, Simon knew that he was being closely watched. He moved between houses but his evil instinct made him a natural rule breaker for he rarely paid his apartment rent, leaving an apartment owner, Louis, furious. A CIA agent who saw Simon walked out of the apartment then approached Louis and offered him a deal. CIA promised to erasi of of Louis' s criminal record, including him being an illegal immigrant of France, plus a permanent job while in return Louis would talk Simon into being a campaigner for Democratic presidential candidate, Aldan Waldberg.
Waldberg will be running for presidency while the Democrat is in power. It is the top man at the CIA who ordered the scenario for Simon, a man who belongs to a group of anti-government.
Head of CIA is confinced that Simon wiould eventually take the bait for he will be tempted to spy on the government's ruling party, while at the same time they hope they'l be able to reveal the left's long term plan trough Simon. He will be brainwashed and intimidated as well as being slowly repressed in order to eventually nail the head of Simon's organization.
And Simon did take the bait. He went on clandestinely with his left wing position while also working as a campaign speaker for presidential hopeful Waldberg. He passed on every information to the organization including up to 8 confidential info on the government. Among them is a plan to fire Joshua Pernambucho the current Chief Justice of the country.
Very little people aware that it is actually Pernambucho who set up and run the organization to avenge Hustons for failing to reappoint him as ecretry of Defense under President Hustons' s second tenure. Pernambucho has all it takes to sit in such position having both military and police general credential in the past. Upon hearing n info about his sacking, the born-Mexican is committed to ruin Hustons government.
The justice has long been known as the most corrupt state institution, for 70 percent of 1250 corruption cases in the US comes from it under Pernambucho's lead. He argued the bad mark comes from rotten moral of his underlings, not from his leadership. In the end he built the Organization as more and more members of the Republican party, also under the leadership of Pernambucho, were being caught for both corruption and bribery. He insisted his party fellows are no dirtier than the Democrats, under the rule of Hustons.
Main activities of the left organization that Joshua created isto turn law-abiding citizen against government, usually by provoking them through issues that could make them hate the authorities. This is where Simon plays major role: he's really good at convincing people that the riots he provoked involved hundreds of thousand of people. The U S have never seen the chaos of this magnitude that eventually the country was declared under emergency.
Simon works on a personal provocation too, one Paul Cohen had been successfully being provoked to kill 17 members of parliament under allegation that they're guilty of masterminding the republican accused of corruption while only two were actually guilty. Others were killed under false pretense after a highlighted news on the media. Cohen killed all the MP to avenge for the death of his lover, a member of the republic an party. He's a bisexual who has promised would never change partner and only married his wife for fear she would tell people of his sexual orientation.
Paul son's is Jordan, happens to be Laurence's class mate. They get along well each telling proud stories of their father not knowing that Jordan's father was victim of Laurence's step father provocation. But Simon doesn't know that both Paul and Jordan are related despite of the shared last name.
When he was campaigning for Aldan in Washington Simon was kidnapped by the CIA and later being subjected to torture and interrogation. He was kept in a seemingly random old building wherehe saw with his own eyes how anti-Americans were being abused until near-dead. It was a technique meant to torture Simon's mind to force him talking. But he wouldn't budge. He was willing to die and but soon the CIA realized that he was their prized-hostage and CIA field chief Joseph Murdock changed tactics. He offered to finance Laurence education to a doctoral level, a secret ideal that Simon has kept for his adopted son.
Murdock asked Simon for names of the secret organization's top people accused of planning mutiny, but Simon refused. He said Laurence is very intelligent she wouldn't need any help getting the degree. Murdock changed course: he published pictures of massacres including towards Laurence's parents. The headline said: Simon the boxer and tomorrow we'll never know. Laurence was shocked and furious, she started to find ways to avenge. CIA used this to ask Laurence to find any documents that Simon might keep at their home. Laurence was also given a promise of financial help for her education up to a doctoral degree.
Simon and the headline made a very popular topic among members of the public until he was sentenced to death. But apparently for political reason, he was kept alive to force the disbanment of the leftist organization because he was seen as vital member of the organization. But they were wrong, for Simon was nothing but a busyboy.
Johsua has picked a replacement for Simon, Ron Hubert who received order to finish Aimon in jail. Stewart Johnson was sent to do the killing but after many attempts he failed. Meanwhile public has started to panic with rumor about left organization left them to be suspicious of one another for fear each was involved within the organization. Couple broke up, school students expelled, all for the same fear. Even Laurence became the victim of this mass suspicion especially because his step father was known to be a left wing leader. Laurence eventually find the place where Simon hidden his documents: under his own bed. he gave the document to Joseph. It revealed names of members of organization who mostly from eastern Europe, Middle East, and latin America.
Some are even member of the Taliban, or other underground organization such as the Illuminati and Freemason. A distinguished name surfaced: Mahmoud Farhad, a man who was suspected of trafficking arms for Taliban. Next was Lorenzo de Emmanuel, a marijuana dealer from Cuba. He served as organization's treasury with hundreds of million dollar money-per-week he made from marijuana business. Current President of Cuba is Bunuel Olivera who let everything goes on for he himself is a marijuana addict. He passed the law legalizing drugs which invited opposition from inside and outside the coountry, including criticism from the UN. But Olivera's party is very strong, he has no match in power. In the US the ruling Republican party always vetoed proposal to attack Cuba under the reason that attacking Cuba would only claim civilian lives with no tenable target achieved.
Another name that comes up was Zuran Yimak, very important figure for organization for his role in connecting external people to internal from the organization. He also recruited civilians for the organization the way MOSSAD recruits to civilian. One recruit will only be given one task, once it’s done the civilian will be expelled from the organization and ordered to shut up, with reward of some amount of money.
Zuran and Farhad were arrested while Lorenzo was surprisingly later released to the rumour that the source of massacre pictures was him. Lorence then went missing for 8 months to the rumor that he was given luxurious life by the CIA for his cooperation. The truth is although he did receive hundreds of thousand dollar from the CIA, Lorenzo lived fearfully hiding in a bunker and after for months he tried to find a job in a cruise ship as a waiter. But he was much into depression for betraying his best friend Simon for hundreds of thousand dollar and he eventually committed suicide. His body was found in the ship. The authorities concluded that he was killed by the organization while the organization thought the CIA killed Lorenzo.
Meanwhile Simon is about to be brought to court but hours before judge Stephen Wildmark who will preside over the court room was shot. Wildmark survived, but he has to be treated in a hospital under heavy security. Court was being adjourned. The shooter is Steve Qualis, one sympathizer to Simon. Qualis hates the government but he has no connection to the organization, but for his action the conflict between the organization and the government rages on.
As was mentioned before Peter Danke - under the disguised name Sam Michel inside the organization – is a double agent trying to inflitrate the organization for government. Peter is best friend of Luke Lewis, who is a friend of Jacobs. But since Luke chooses to rally for Nganko Sembene, an American of Nigerian descent, for presidential hopeful from the Republican party, relationship between Luke and Jacobs broken. Knowing this, Jacob’s enemy, Johsua, recruited Luke for the organization. Nganko also got support from Jacobs, both men has made some political deals. Luke later got a lot of support from Jacobs and CIA, the police and FBI. Sam Peter from inside the organization has compiled many informations especially with involvement of Luke in many cases against the law, but he can never process it because Luke was being protected by the three big institutions.
Several days before Simon is about to be executed, he received a new offer: if he’s willing to reval who the head of the organization he will be freed. Jacobs has some plans, but so does Johsua. He is very vengeful to Jacobs for he is the one who lethally injected his wife, Marlene, because Marlene was once known to be vey vocal against the government. From Marlene, the authorities soon suspect her brother Abraham Starley and Johsua, her husband. Abraham soon cleared from allegation of involvevement with the organization for he is a pro-government personality. However he is still under the authorities watch list for fear he disguised his action for the benefit of the organization.
Simon found out that Johsua wanted to kill him, via Stewart. Even some police officers have also been recruited to do the mission to kill Simon. Simon soon realized that both government and organization are playing nasty trick to finish him. In court he revealed all he know about the government and organization so that public knows that both are the roots of all the country’s problem. Soon public perceives Simon and several of arrested members of the organizations are just victims like them while the the conflict that fuels Jacobs and Johsua’s enmity is triggered by the political system. Hence people are protesting on the street for a demand to change the political system. A revolution was born.
The film ends with scenes of people power with demands to reform the whole governmental system and dibandment of the organization. Simon cries and smiles at the same tie watching all this from his court room.