"Supergirl" Alex (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Who's the Big Bad?
ThomasDrufke1 May 2017
One of the things that has really hurt this season of Supergirl, and just downright confused me, is the lack of a "big-bad". At one point it could have been Lillian Luthor, then they toyed with the idea of having Lena Luthor turn evil, and now perhaps it could be Rhea, Mon-El's mother. I understand there isn't one right way to do things, but it always helps to have a through-line of storytelling.

This week provided us with yet another filler episode in terms of its villain of the week structure, but it did have some of the best character drama of the season. Alex was kidnapped by a former classmate of hers and Kara's who "knows everything about her" and has been stalking the Danvers family for a year now. If you can get passed that ridiculous nonsense, I thought the episode played out nicely.

I've said from the beginning that the strength of this show lies on the shoulders of Melissa Benoist' performance. And this year in particular, Chyler Leigh and Floriana Lima have been written incredibly well to give us a nice trio of strong female characters. That more than anything, was put to the test tonight. You can say all you want about the goofy villain, but pitting Maggie & Kara's morals up against each other was a real joy to watch. Both had their own agendas for rescuing Alex from a random warehouse. Though you pretty much knew the ending would have both of them compromising for the greater safety of Alex, it was an interesting dynamic to tackle.

Meanwhile, Rhea was seen recruiting Lena for her plan to likely put an end to Kara or some sort of terrorizing the city event. As I've made clear, I'm not a fan of bringing Lena to the dark side. It's okay if she's tempted and its "teased" a few times here and there, but making her a full-fledged villain still seems desperate to me. Of course, that could change when I see it come to pass, but that's where I stand now. Overall, this episode was an interesting one purely for the performances of the main 3 strong females. Other than that, there's not a whole lot to discuss. Hopefully the last 3 episodes will make the entire year worth it.

+Sanvers

+Kara & Maggie spending quality time

-Still no movement on the "big bad"

8.0/10
15 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Supergirl – S02E19 Alex
j_forbesy2 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Like last week's episode, this is a really hard episode to judge. I'll start by saying if this was within the first 5 or so episodes, I would of really enjoyed it, but it wasn't. This is the pointy end of the season and I still have no idea who is meant to be the big bad of this season. Is it Cadmas or the Daxamites, I have not idea and with 3 or so episodes to go, we need to know this stuff.

Starting with the villain this episode, I did really enjoy him. Not often do we get a psychological villain on Supergirl so it is great to have a really good one show up. I thought the actor did a great job portraying him and the emotion around his motivation.

I've really enjoy the Maggie and Alex relationship this season and I thought it was a great positive again this episode. This episode of course was focused a lot around Alex and I think they did a great job at setting up Maggie's emotions towards possibly losing Alex.

Into some negatives and I have to start with some general writing. At points of this episode, some things the characters said or did was unlike what they usually do. Of all the CW superhero shows, I feel as though Supergirl is the one that has the most inconsistencies in their writing and it really stands out as a black mark against the show.

The biggest problem I had with this episode however is a problem I have had for a while and that is Kara. This ties a bit into the writing but in the second half of this season, they have painted Kara as this egotistical superhero that has a rotten attitude and needs to be knocked down a few pegs. In recent episodes they had back that off a big but she was back to it again this episode. I really liked the concept they were taking of questioning when the city needs superheroes and when don't they, but the way they wrote Kara really spoiled this episode from being a nice episode that questions superheroes as a whole.

Overall, it wasn't the worst episode of Supergirl however it's misplacing in the season and it's writing of key characters really stands out as problems we shouldn't be having at this point in the season. There are still a few episodes left before this season wraps up, but unfortunately for me, I've all but written this season off.

7/10
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Scary Warning: Spoilers
Man I was so scared for Alex. Wow Maggie worng choice.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Good Episode But...
sandra_mihaela0829 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I really liked the idea of a human villan, but after they have tried everything, why didn't they tell Jo'on to use his mojo and read his mind to find Where Alex is?

It's like sometimes they use all they have But sometimes feels like they forget they have powers and they can use them.

Is What I'm thinking wrong?
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed