- Spencer confronts Caleb regarding Hanna's issues; Aria opens up to Ella and questions her marriage to Zack; Emily and Spencer close in on Noel's motives and a call from detective Tanner has Alison perplexed.
- Open with the girls talking to Alison about her plan with Noel. Alison thinks she had no choice with Tanner asking so many questions. Spencer's eye seems to be getting worse. Spencer admits to having been spying on Alison. Hanna continues to be getting out of control with the drinking.
On her way home Emily hears a recording of Alison and Shana coming out of a car. It's Noel and she sees him put something in his glove.
Hanna tells Ashley she's not going to Ella's party. Her flask falls out of her bag and Ashley spots it. She warns her daughter she can't afford to be out of control with so much going on.
Tanner questions Aria and Ella about the incident at Hanna's place and brings up Ezra. Ella thinks this is unusual but agrees to continue. Tanner wants to know if it's possible Ezra dated other students and Aria is bothered by the question.
Alison tells Spencer she's worried that Tanner is back at their school and one of them is going to crack. She warns Spencer that if one of them falls "A wins." Alison also thinks Spencer should be following Hanna, if anybody.
Emily interviews for the swimming assistant coach job and gets the gig. Afterwards she returns to the office and takes a picture of Noel's locker combination.
Ella tells Aria shed needs to be more relaxed when it comes to questions like the ones they were getting from Tanner.
Emily goes into Noel's locker and gets his keys.
Spencer visits Caleb at his place and tells him she's worried about Hanna and thinks he's enabling her drinking problem. Spencer lets slip that Hanna might have something against Zach.
Alison apologizes to Hanna for her stunt. Hanna yells at her that all she wants is to be left alone. She suggests Alison stay with somebody else. Jenna walks in the room and Hanna leaves. Alison asks how Jenna was about to "turn" Shana and Jenna responds that Alison was the reason.
Hanna spots Aria in the quad and Aria gives her the cold shoulder, leaving without a word.
At the eye doctor's office Spencer is given some drops that make her vision blurry. While waiting she sees what appear to be two girls that look an awful lot like Jenna. She can't make them out and tries to take a picture.
In Noel's car Emily finds pictures of Alison over the past few years, along with what looks like a recording device of some kind. Spencer calls Emily and they share their revelations. On the eye chart Spencer sees the phrase: "CAN UCME YET, A"
Ella has to go to a hair appointment, which leaves Zach and Aria alone. She mentions that Hanna can't make the party and carefully watches Zach's reaction.
Emily arrives at the doctor's office in time to see the "Two Jennas walk out of the office." One of them turns out to be Sidney and Emily asks when she and Jenna became friends. Jenna doesn't let her answer and they leave.
Caleb asks Hanna about not going to the party. Hanna tells him about Zach giving her his number and nobody believing her story. She tells him she feels terrible about the whole thing and doesn't want to talk about it. Caleb leaves, telling her he's going to pick up some food.
Aria asks her mother whether or not she should wait. She says she has concerns about Zach and tells Ella he may have been inappropriate with Hanna. Ella doesn't seem shocked by this and tells Aria there had been a previous incident.
Caleb goes to the party and confronts Zach about hitting on Hanna. Zach says he was joking and Hanna took him too seriously. Zach pulls out a letter, supposedly from Hanna that reads "Sorry if I acted shy before. I promise I'll make up for it." Zach says it was slipped into his pocket and Caleb punches him in the face.
Caleb returns home and tells Hanna he hit Zach. He shows her the note and wonders if perhaps A wrote him the letter.
Spencer is going to the lake house to bring Noel's pictures of Alison to a safe place.
Sidney shows up on Emily's street and tells her she met Jenna few years earlier. When Jenna heard Alison was alive she reached out to Sidney for emotional support. Sidney says she never expected to like Emily so much and Emily tells her she's going to repay the favor as her coach, watching her carefully.
At the lake house Spencer locks the pictures in a cabinet. While she's there we see something move on a chair covered by a sheet. Spencer spots it to and pulls the sheet back to reveal Noel. He wants his pictures back, pointing out that his car was broken into. Noel says Alison doesn't know he has the pictures. He has them for insurance in case Alison turns on him. Shana sent the pictures to Jenna. When Spencer won't give him the keys she hits him in the hand with a fireplace tool. He leaves.
Aria drops by to see Hanna. She tells her what Ella told her and apologizes for not believing her about Zach. Hanna tells her that A stoked the fire, but Aria doesn't think that matters. Hanna says she'll forgive Aria and they embrace.
While home alone with Alison, Ashley gets a call from the Tanner. They caught the person who broke in and think he's ready to talk.
Byron stops by the house and Ella tells him the engagement is off. She's crying and doesn't want to talk about it. Byron's makes her feel better by reminiscing on their past and tells her how special she is. She cries on his shoulder.
At the station Ashley and Hanna are brought into a room where they can view the interrogation area. Tanner is talking to a guy who claims he hit her with a rock in the back of her head and took her took Philly. He says he kept her locked up in his basement the entire time. Ashley asks her if that's the man who kidnapped her as the episode ends.
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content