Happiness (2013) Poster

(II) (2013)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Brilliantly Filmed Representation of Changing Ways of Life
l_rawjalaurence6 November 2014
In 1999, King Jigme Wangchuck approved the use of television and Internet throughout the largely undeveloped nation of Bhutan, assuring the masses that rapid development was synonymous with the "gross national happiness" of his country, a term he himself coined. THE HIMALAYAN BOY AND THE TELEVISION SET show how Laya, a remote village buried in the Himalayas, is gradually being dug up as new cables are installed to permit the technologies to flourish.

The process of change between a rural and mechanized way of life is observed through the eyes of Peyangki, an eight-year-old boy, whose mother has sent him to a monastery in the hope that he will learn a contemplative way of life and thereby become pure in spirit as well as body. Peyangki resents the decision; he is shown returning to his mother, and pleading that he might go with a family friend to visit his sister, now working in the regional capital of Thimphu. After a grueling three-day journey, Peyangki discovers just how different the modern urban way of life actually is.

Thomas Balmés' film quite brilliantly captures the contrasts between different ways of life. Peyangki is accustomed to simpler ways; his mother spends her time looking after her flock of yaks, and trying to shoo him away. In the monastery - where there are only two other worshipers - he is instructed in the virtues of the contemplative way of life, but he is more interested in talking about worldly matters. The camera vividly captures the contrast between the wild, untamed mountains and the primitive mountain shack that houses the monastery, in which dim butter lamps-flicker to illuminate the Buddhist shrine.

The film transforms Thimphu into a gaudy city of the mind, in which bright lights flash, cars whiz by day and night, and the thronged sidewalks drive little Peyangki almost giddy with wonder. He re- encounters his sister at night, in a place where he (and his mother) would least expect - although admiring the person-made lights, there is a trace of wistfulness in his manner, as if yearning for the less pressurized existence of his rural home.

However that existence is threatened by the inevitable march of progress. In a series of brilliant shots, contrasting the red- cloaked Peyangki with the anonymous-looking workers, director Balmés suggests that progress is not quite as desirable as the King of Bhutan might have assumed; it leads to standardization as well as conformity. The film ends with a shot of Peyangki running away from the camera, his monastic cloak fluttering in the breeze, almost as if he were a small red bird; this is contrasted with a series of static shots showing a Bhutanese family watching WWF wrestling on the television, understanding not one word of the English commentary. It is left to the viewers to draw their conclusions.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A troubling subtext
wolfstar_imdb9 April 2022
This is an interesting snapshot of life in rural Bhutan as television and internet are about to be introduced for the first time. Notable is the subtext of abuse - it's clear the protagonist's sister is being sexually exploited at her workplace, a club where she's employed as a dancing girl, and where the girls also have to live and aren't allowed to leave the building. The dance shows the girls are forced to put on are so rudimentary that it's clear they're just a means for male punters to inspect the wares.

Even more troublingly, a lot of evidence also suggests Peyangki is being abused at the monastery. As well as telling his mother that the Lama beats him, he's also shown sharing a bed with an older novice who tells Peyangki he isn't interested in women and seems to really enjoy sharing a bed with him. A couple of scenes later we see an uncharacteristically sullen Peyangki ask his mother if he can leave the monastery or at least transfer to a different monastery, and he becomes very distressed when she says no. He's especially keen not to spend the night at the monastery.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed