In Ravenswood Miranda and Caleb find a tombstone with their names and pictures on. Caleb meets Remy, who helps him investigate, and siblings Olivia and Luke, who recently lost their father in mysterious circumstances.
After Miranda's funeral, Caleb tells Remy, Luke and Olivia that he has seen her. The four decide to stick together for their safety. Caleb moves into Miranda's uncle's guest house. After a dangerous séance, all the five teens see Miranda.
Caleb believes Miranda is in danger, and that the little girl in a red coat is a threat to them. In an old building the gang finds a couple who buried themselves behind a wall in hopes of resurrecting the original Caleb and Miranda.