Largely filmed at a house in Woodland Hills used for actual porn shoots, complete with stripper pole and condom vending machine.
Director Robert Nathan stated that he was inspired to create the movie after his writing and producing partner showed him a porn website that would invite its members to have sex on camera. Nathan found it difficult to believe that the participants, who were portrayed as ordinary, were as normal as they appeared and wondered what it would be like if the "wrong guy" was hired.
In a 2014 interview about the film, when asked if she's always been comfortable with nudity and sexuality, actress Betsy Rue said "I've always been like that, I've always been open. I never expect too much or be thinking too much about it. The first time I did (in 2009's My Bloody Valentine 3D full nude motel parking lot scene) that was just part of the character. My goal in acting, no matter what, is that I'll pour everything into it, and I can't have any fear about it. I have conversations with myself 'ya know what, if I have to do this, so go out there and do it and give it your all!'"
The filmmakers were given recommendations on how to edit the short film in order to earn an R rating instead of NC-17, but they declined saying "if we recut it there won't be any movie left."
In keeping with the "found footage" conceit of the film, the closing credits list the fictional character Ashley Saint as one of the producers.