Cassidy (Devon Werkheiser) finds himself stuck in a world where no one remembers him. Not even his girlfriend, Madison (Molly McCook). Along with the mysterious Natalie (Randi Borden), Cassidy will start a journey to uncover the truth, and in turn, find more than he ever bargained for. Justin Deeley, Taylor Spreitler, James Rustin, Savannah Mills, Drew Garrett, Dewar McNamara, and Katie Wallace also star. Jozef Fahey directed this episode written by Jordan Ross.
Cassidy is forced to search for answers alone when Natalie is abducted by The Other, while Bryce balances playing the hero and covering up his personal life. As the new world begins to take shape, Cassidy discovers what was and what should never be.
Cassidy comes to Duncan's rescue after he finds himself in a tricky spot. Zoe tosses with the idea of helping Trish. Natalie, free from The Other, runs into college roommate Olivia at Ethan's open mic night.