Add Full Plot
"American Idol" - Top Five Performance Show - May 4, 2011 Theme: Now and Then In the audience: Anthony Hopkins; Kelly Preston; Video Package: We get a rundown on tonight's guest mentor Sheryl Crow... See full synopsis »
Did You Know?
Haley Reinhart (season 10) was the first American Idol contestant to sing an unreleased song. She preformed Lady Gaga
's You and I (it was unreleased at that time). See more
Written by Pete Ham
and Tom Evans
Sung by James Durbin See more