After a paperwork mix up the guys are selected to be part of the school's gifted program. While they love the perk of getting out of school early, they are soon in over their heads when they are assigned a difficult assignment.
Bucket is jealous when he learns that Kelly is going to the school dance with a senior he thinks is a jerk. As he and Skinner try to sabotage her date, they start to wonder if he's not as bad as they thought.
Kelly is cast as the lead in the school musical, and when Bucket learns that she has a kissing scene he auditions for the play. But Bucket doesn't take it well when Aloe swoops in and steals Bucket's role.
Kelly has won concert tickets and offers to take Bucket & Skinner, under the condition they babysit for Piper. The boys agree to babysit but quickly realize this job is way more than they bargained for.
Aloe offers Bucket a spot on the varsity surf team, but in exchange he wants to borrow Bobo, Three Piece's prized surfboard. After Aloe accidentally breaks Bobo, Bucket along with the guys, must get rid of the evidence.
While watching the surf shop Bucket causes the lease to lapse. Aloe quickly swoops in and takes over the space for his own store, and the only way Bucket and Skinner can get the shop back is through a surf competition.
Talent show rehearsal for their magic act goes awry when Bucket and Skinner accidentally handcuff themselves to Kelly. Unable to free themselves, the three do their best to make it through Kelly's stuffy dinner party.
Skinner falls for a rich heiress after the boys sneak into an elite yacht club, and while Bucket helps him act wealthy and cultured so she doesn't learn the truth about him, Aloe is determined to expose Skinner.
After Bucket is disappointed that Kelly is going to prom with Blake, Skinner cheers up his friend with tickets to the rock festival. Piper destroys Kelly's expensive prom dress, and devises a way to get herself and Three Pieces on a TV game show.
Bucket and Skinner head to a rock festival on the wrong bus and accidentally enter a military facility. Elsewhere, Kelly's prom plans go astray when her old childhood pal shows up and Piper ruins her dress.
It's Christmas Eve and Bucket is depressed that his family's annual Christmas trip to the mountains has been canceled. Despite Skinner's efforts to raise his best friend's spirits, Bucket wants nothing to do with the holidays.
Bucket's crippling fear of chickens embarrasses him when one gets loose at school and he totally loses his cool in front of Kelley. In an attempt to prove he isn't a wimp, he and Skinner stage a fake robbery at the surf shop.
Bucket and Skinner join Kelly's cheerleading squad when they learn the team is competing for a trip to Regionals in Hawaii. But when they accidentally get most of the squad sick they must convince rival Aloe to help and fill in
Piper teaches Bucket and Skinner martial arts, and makes them think they are better than they actually are. But after the now-confident guys accept a challenge to fight the school bully, Piper and Kelly must set them straight.
Bucket and Skinner accidentally lose the school's seal mascot, and enlist the help of Skinner's animal-loving cousin Patty, a blogger visiting from Australia who is excited to record the missing-animal drama for her web series.