Guest stars galore pop up as Linkara celebrates his 200th episode by reviewing the one comic he swore he would never review: The infamous Spider-Man comic "One More Day."
While Holokara reviews an Elseworlds comic about what Gotham City would be like if Catwoman were the defender and Batman were a homicidal maniac, Linkara learns a shocking truth about himself.
Holokara reviews Psychoman #1, a bad comic written by a man who ended up murdered shortly after the comic was written. Meanwhile, Linkara has a heart-to-heart talk with Margaret, the spirit of his magic gun.
In honor of AT4W's fourth anniversary, Linkara revisits the Spider-Man Clone Saga with the four-part story that started it all: Power and Responsibility.
Linkara heads back to the Golden Age to review a Superman Christmas comic featuring cartoonish villains, an absurd plot to destroy Christmas and questions the Man of Steel's ethics.
Harvey gets a visit from the Nostalgia Critic as his past is recalled, which ironically includes Linkara's review of an Archie Christmas comic. Guest starring Doug Walker.
For Christmas Eve, Linkara reviews a really good Christmas Carol comic adaptation: the Batman graphic novel Noel. Also Harvey encounters the ghost of Christmas Future who turns out to be Linkara Prime and we learn the real reason for the tension between Harvey and Linkara.