Gabi and Will take a look at the security footage and Gabi appears to recognize the man pawning her earrings. The man runs into Melanie on the pier and tries to steal her necklace. Melanie catches him and demands it back. Brady appears and the man is brought into the police station. The man clearly knows Rafe but impostor Rafe doesn't know who he is until Gabi arrives and calls him Dario. Lexie is surprised when Nicole tells her Taylor moved into the mansion.