1 user

The Oscar Nominated Short Films: Animation (2011)

Not Rated | | Animation | 11 February 2011 (USA)
Collective screening of the Academy Award nominated short films from the Animation category for 2011.


Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Collective screening of the Academy Award nominated short films from the Animation category for 2011.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis




Not Rated




Release Date:

11 February 2011 (USA)  »

Box Office

Opening Weekend:

$300,706 (USA) (11 February 2011)


$1,350,640 (USA) (8 April 2011)

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


See  »

Did You Know?


Edited from Day & Night (2010) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Geez, These Are the BEST They Could Find?
19 February 2011 | by (United States) – See all my reviews

The Oscar-Nominated Short Films: Animation (1:27, NR) — other: miscellaneous, bargain basement, original

These are the 7 short features (not properly "cartoons", since none of them is funny) in this compendium, in order of appearance:

(1) Madagascar, Carnet de Voyage (Travel Journal), Sacrebleu Prod., France, 11 min.

(2) Let's Pollute, no company listed, USA, 6 min.

(3) The Gruffalo, Magic Light Pic., UK/Germany, 27 min.

(4) The Lost Thing, Passion Pic., Australia/UK, 15 min.

(5) Day & Night, Pixar, USA, 6 min.

(6) Urs, Filmakademie Baden-Württemburg, Germany, 10 min.

(7) The Cow That Wanted To Be a Hamburger, Bill Plympton Studios, USA, 6 min.

The 1st 5 are the Oscar nominees; the latter 2 are bonus features thrown in by distributor Shorts International as "highly commended". The last 3 have no dialog; neither does #1, but it does have on-screen wordage rendered in English subtitles. #3 is sparsely narrated in rhyme. Most are hand-drawn, except #1 seems to have been largely rotoscoped, while #5 (which you may have seen preceding Toy Story 3) is of course the most slickly produced, using Pixar's state-of-the-art computer animation tech. #7 is merely produced by Plympton; it does not feature his distinctive hand-drawn style.

It's the inherent nature of anthologies — even themed anthologies, which this most certainly is not, aside from the Oscar thing — to be a mixed bag. That's true here in spades, as there is a wide range of animation styles on display. But you'd think that at least the quality would be high, since these were deemed to be award-worthy. Alas, not so. #1 and #6 in particular were utterly pointless, #1 seeming to be random incidents during the writer's vacation trip in Madagascar, while #6 was a drudgerous journey of a peasant from his valley hut to the far side of the barrier mountain range, hauling his aged mother in a wooden chair strapped to his back. #4, with its giant orange tentacled teapot (the eponymous lost thing), had a certain endearing whimsy largely offset by its gloomily gray visual spectrum. #2 uses really primitive crayon drawings to beat to death its counter-intuitive theme about pollution being the cornerstone of Western civilization; as satire goes, this is one of the most heavy-handed pieces of propaganda I've seen outside any 6-minute slice of Faux News.

The highlights for me were #3 (in which a mama squirrel regales her 2 squirrelets with a tale of a clever mouse who outwits potential predators with made-up descriptions of his big buddy the gruffalo, until he meets an ACTUAL gruffalo) and #5 (in which 2 transparent homuncublobs cavort and marvel at the scenes visible inside each other, 1 by day, 1 by night, until at the end the sun goes down inside one while rising inside the other, and they switch places). But #3 was longer than it needed to be for such a minimal tale, and I'd already seen #5, so some of its original magic had worn off.

All in all, then, a kind of disappointed "poor" rating from me. I fret that good hand-drawn animation may be becoming a lost art, but maybe it's just a down year; that was certainly the case with 2010's science-fiction feature-length films. I guess they can't all be winners.

We're certainly not ready yet to hand out a "no award", but it may be time to cut the category down to only 3 nominees, which was sadly necessary for "best original song" a couple of years back when they couldn't find a full slate worthy of nomination.

1 of 4 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Contribute to This Page