"American Experience" Triangle Fire (TV Episode 2011) Poster

(TV Series)

(2011)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
See THE FUTURE union-busters are taking us BACK TO
charlytully28 February 2011
Warning: Spoilers
The American Experience: TRIANGLE FIRE episode shows us exactly where the corporations that recently bought the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. House of Representatives, the government of Wisconsin, etc., etc. not only have yearned for years to return to, but to which they've now taken us 80 percent of the way (since only 20 percent of American non-millionaires are unionized, with the game plan being to only allow millionaires such as professional sports stars to retain the universal human right of unionization as defined by the United Nations: civilization regards de-unionization on par with a return to human slavery).

The women who worked in 1911 in the aptly-named Ash Building in New York City's Greenwich Village were thwarted in their earlier strike efforts by the local police, just as Wisconsin state troopers evicted the women teachers from the Wisconsin state Capitol building that their own tax dollars helped to erect in the wee hours of this morning, in an effort to thwart their right to strike ever again.

Meanwhile, in Washington, DC, the U.S. House of Representatives is reviewing all the legal regulatory progress ordinary Americans have made in the past 100 years--largely because of corporate crimes such as the 150 women turned into human torches in the Ash Building, which was the catalyst for laws against unpaid overtime (i.e., human slavery, which USA Today letters to the editor writer Terry McKenna of Ocean City, NJ demands from all public employees in today's newspaper), child labor, unsafe working environments, a-nickel-an-hour wage scales, etc. America's top 1% only owns one third of everything now, with the next 9% owning another third, and the ordinary 90% of us fighting over the final third despite our existing set of so-called "rights" and "protections."

Any viewer of TRIANGLE FIRE will soon conclude that once the final remnants of our Declaration-of-Independence rights are removed by the puppets doing the bidding of corporate lawyers, the entire country will become one big Ash Building, with millions of us plunging to our doom not unlike flaming marshmallows toasted too close for the fires of corporate greed.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Yet another exceptional PBS documentary.
planktonrules1 October 2011
This is the second documentary I've seen about the tragic fire at the Triangle Shirt Waist Factory in 1911. The first was shown on the History Channel and was a bit different from this PBS film. Unlike the PBS one, it was entirely about the fire and the factors that led to the massive loss of life. This PBS film, in contrast, was much more a film about the need to unionize, as the first half of the show was about failed efforts to unionize this factory and others in New York. Then, in an illustration of the need, the fire is discussed--which occurred a year later. Neither way of telling the story was better--they were just different.

Like so many PBS documentary is similar to others the network airs in that it consists of a narrator, actors acting out the events and narrating as well as the extensive use of vintage photos--as the cameras scanned about the pictures (a common technique used by Ken Burns--though he did not direct this film).

The film is very effective and when reports of eyewitnesses are being reenacted, you can't help but feel horrible for the poor ladies who burned to death, died from smoke inhalation or had chosen to jump to their deaths instead. It's hard to just watch it and not be affected by the tragedy. Well made, but a bit grisly (as they show some pretty nasty pictures of the victims)--it's a great example of filmmaking--which, amazingly, is par for the course for "The American Experience".
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Why is it people have to die before things change?..
AlsExGal8 March 2020
...That's the question I come away with after watching this documentary on the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire of 1911. The workers at Triangle and at other similar factories and sweatshops in New York City at the time were female, poor, largely from immigrant families. And nobody with the power to do anything about their plight really cared what happened to them. Until the day the 8th floor factory went ablaze, the firemen could not reach a story in a building of that height, the windows burst from the heat, and the bodies began to be thrown from those now open windows, still ablaze as they fell to the ground. 149 dead in all, mainly women.

This episode does not spend lots of time on the fire itself - maybe 15 minutes on the blaze and its aftermath. It does spend lots of time talking about the strike in 1909 that lasted into 1910 in which the Triangle employees held out for a union but in the end had to settle for better wages and circumstances. Nobody really cared about the workers then. The police and Triangle's owners' hired thugs beat the women regularly and nobody did anything. Some wealthy women marched with them until the cry began to be for a more equitable workplace rather than a tolerable one. Gosh, that sounded like socialism! It was one thing to be charitable to the workers, quite another for them to have rights. And basically, the wealthy did not like the idea of workers getting legal protections. They liked their Gilded Age just the way it was.

Over the next two years after the fire New York did put in place some basic protections for workers. However, the two owners of the Triangle who had really caused the disaster by locking a back door so no employee could escape a baggage inspection when they left, were acquitted of manslaughter charges, took their insurance - their "dead peasants" payout - and slinked into obscurity but probably not poverty.

There is lots of narration that appears to be of survivors of the fire, but one narration seems to be from the last person who died from the fire - she actually died in the hospital - but who initially survived by jumping from the window. I knock off one star because it is never said whether these narrations are of actual quotes or just a dramatization of events.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very Strong Documentary
Michael_Elliott5 March 2011
American Experience: Triangle Fire (2011)

*** 1/2 (out of 4)

Another terrific documentary from the American Experience series takes a look at the tragic fire that broke out at a sewing factory on March 25, 1911 that ended up killing 146 people with most of them being women. The previous year the group held a massive strike for better wages, hours and working conditions but they were only able to get the better pay and hours. A year later many would lose their lives, which would set loose new rules for the workplace. I wasn't overly familiar with this tragedy so I was learning quite a bit from the film. Not only is the fire covered but we also hear about all the events leading up to the fire and learn how bad the working conditions were. At first the women were forced to work 14-hour days and they were only making $2 a day. When they did go on strike they were beaten by police and thrown into jail without committing crimes. One thing about the owners of the factory is that they feared people stealing from them so they pretty much locked the doors to where the women couldn't sneak out with clothing material and this here would end up costing them their lives because that same door was locked when the fire broke out. The documentary does a terrific job at giving the viewer an idea what working conditions were like during this period and of course the aftermath. Those with weak stomachs should be warned that there are photos from the actual event with dead bodies on the ground as well as a morgue where family members had to come and try to identify the bodies.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a bit disturbing if you are sensitive but an excellent documentary and a clear reason why we need unions
Mcduff360113 April 2021
The one thing I didn't like about the documentary was the clips of voice actors talking about what they were seeing as things happened. It had an air of falseness to it that kept nagging at me. Which I understand is taking certain liberties to make the piece more interesting but that is my small gripe.

Overall though a well told story with good interviews with real world experts and disturbing content. It goes to show that ultimately the owners of a company won't make decisions that are in the best interests of people if it contradicts making money. Which is why unions are so important.

I will say the descriptions on some of the people's fates was a little much for me. Thank goodness they didn't show much in the way of actual footage the idea and narration were enough to turn my stomach.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed