"The Killing" A Soundless Echo (TV Episode 2011) Poster

(TV Series)

(2011)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Killing - A Soundless Echo
Scarecrow-884 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
"A Soundless Echo" is a key episode in the first season as it alerts us to a secret past for not only Stan but also Mitch, and Rosie most of all. Rosie was "seeing someone" and the person in the pink witch wig being shagged by Kris and Jasper wasn't her…it was a wasted Sterling! Sterling is really under a tumult as her friend had left her side, she felt like she was invisible when in the company of Rosie, and now Sterling is a punchline to kids in her school. While Stephen is stuck on bus rides to determine where Rosie was going after her breakup with Jasper to meet with that secret person, Sarah meets with the Larsens to discuss items found that belonged to Rosie, and while in the station, a door open reveals the crime scene photos of Rosie's badly beaten and bound body. This episode further parlays to us the cycle of preparing a daughter for her funeral and burial. The decision on a casket, for example, and what hymns to play for her…Mitch obviously questions why God would allow her Rosie to go out the way she does. Stan meets a man from his past, needing cash due to a house he had purchased as a surprise for Mitch, now burdened at getting rid of it. This man seems to be a family member that has been removed from his life for 17 years. Stan puts the money away, but a conversation with a work buddy seems to indicate he was involved in violence work for profit years before his legit moving/storage business.

This show is tough to watch due to its need to elaborate the grieving process of a family coping with loss. The aching wound is fresh and unhealed. Mitch is a big, meaty, showy part for Michelle Forbes. It requires her to be under an intense anguish that is not outwardly hysterical as much as quietly agonizing before our eyes. Tears come in patches while the gaping wound of torment is always visible on her tired, exhausted face. Stan is all seething hurt. He is unable to solve the problems burdened upon his family. Richmond's link to his daughter, however coincidental, is inexorably tied to Rosie's death, and this is a thorn in the flesh of Stan.

The show does not defy the ongoing political cat-and-mouse between Richmond and his rival, the egomaniacal mayor of the city. While the mayor continues to use the media to complicate matters for Richmond in regards to the Rosie case, Richmond tries to find donors so that his campaign doesn't tank. There's a twist involving Jamie's "exit" from Richmond's camp which identifies Richmond is cleverer and not so much a patsy as would be believed. Gwen continues to search for avenues that would benefit the Richmond campaign, even going to her father (a senator) for help, urging her city councilman lover to approach a wealthy local celebrity into offering money to them. The mayor tries to recruit Jamie, and he seems to consider it…until a revelation at the end, that is.

Sarah's beau returns to Seattle so they can share some time together and her son begins to develop a type of bonding moment over cake. It's a start but can they outlast the need to close a case? The episode follows Mitch's movements to connect with her daughter's importance in life...to the kids at school, to Sterling (a long hug, awkward yet warm for Sterling who needs such love, and seemingly therapeutic for Mitch, indicates the bond of a mother and her daughter's best friend), even the literature teacher who provides poetry to her.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
So Much Grief; So Much Pain
Hitchcoc16 January 2017
This episode is greatly focused on the Larsens and what a family must face at the death of a child. There are scenes at the funeral home where they must pick out a casket and plan the details of the internment. Soon after that, there is a meeting with a priest who says all the bromides. Mitch asks him questions about where God was in all of this. The priest is quiet. We also get to see Sterling develop as a character. Her role in this becomes even more dramatic when it comes to the Cage. The political stuff continues as betrayals begin to take place and maneuvering in the Mayor's race. One question is whether the planned wedding of Sarah will take place. This case is digging ditch that may not be filled. We will see if her guy has the patience to continue with her.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The secret lover
gedikreverdi6 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
It is her teacher who's a basketball player at the same time. The male detective went over to his neighborhood and the female detective found the letters hidden in the globe in her room. Jasper and Chris the meth addict seem to be innocent or are they? And Rosie's father seem to have dubious business going on with his employers.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed