In the flashback, after young Shawn tapes his and Gus's legs together, he throws the tape to the side, but later in the flashback, the tape is gone. See more
All right. What happened?
I-I don't know. Shoot! One minute, I'm checking the stalls after they finished. Next thing I know, got a knot on my head, waking up in this-this closet.
Burton 'Gus' Guster
Dude, where's your gun?
Oh, they probably turned it in for some books at the local community center. Where you think it's at, man?