Add Full Plot
"American Idol" - Top Four Performance - May 11, 2010
Theme: Songs from the movies
Mentor: Jamie Foxx
In the audience: Taye Diggs and Idina Menzel;
Video Package: A look at Jamie Foxx. He's in the audience with shirts that say "contestant" and "artist" and says he told them he challenged them to rise above and he'd award the proper shirt.
Contestant #1: Lee Dewyze He gets in his face like he did with Danny Gokey and tells him to take it from inside to outside. Jamie gives him an artist shirt.
Song: "Kiss From a Rose," Seal ("Batman")
Performance: There are some pitch problems, some presence issues, and a strong karaoke vibe but it's fine in general.
Randy: He thinks it was just okay, he did nothing with it and it's pitchy in spot. He calls it a bad choice.
Ellen: Agrees he could've done more but says he's so good.
Kara: Says he had a great week last week and that the song was too wide in range and he was buried by the arrangement.
Simon: Agrees with Randy that he didn't choose a brilliant ...