42 reviews in total
12 out of 41 people found the following review useful:
Barely coherent comedy from a hugely overrated personality
Kalifire from UK
24 November 2011
For month prior to this being broadcast, Gervais was busy
congratulating himself about this on his marketing reel, sorry, blog.
We were told this was the funniest thing he'd done, so expectations
were high; this was the man who co-created The Office, after all.
As it turns out, pre-declaring his own brilliance was a misjudgment,
because this isn't very good. No, worse than that, this is terrible.
It's not that it's offensive (though it tries to be), and it's not that
it's badly acted (though nobody is going to win any BAFTAs for this),
it's just badly written.
The entire premise is that a documentary crew is filming Warwick Davis,
quite inexplicably. That tenuous premise is then stretched beyond
breaking point to allow a series of interactions between celebrities
and Gervais, and put Davis in a sequence of set-pieces that essentially
invite the audience to laugh at a dwarf in compromising situations.
There's literally no more to it than that.
Life's Too Short gets the odd chuckle, but by episode three, where we
plum the depths of try-hard television by engineering awkward
situations for the sake of it, at the expense of any laughter
whatsoever, it's clear this has become a car-crash event for the
writers. Fortunately for them, they have an army of sycophants who'd
rather tell each other that a wheel-bound child being called gay and
being unable to get up stairs is HILARIOUS rather than use their
discernment to consider that it's not remotely funny; rather just an
attempt to raise eyebrows in a distinctly witless fashion.
For the discerning comedy fan who wants to believe that Gervais and
Merchant are as good as we all hoped they'd be ten years ago, avoid
this like the plague.
14 out of 59 people found the following review useful:
comedy a precious commodity
jules (ronansdad) from Cardiff Wales United Kingdom
17 November 2011
Great comedy is a rarity, it's precious in the same way gems are but
this is no gem. It is awful in its laziness.
The irony of the plot is that we get to laugh at a dwarf, the gags are
predictable when it comes to height and the comic value of an over
inflated ego are tired, worn and laboured. Where as Brent in the Office
had a character who wanted to be liked and sought acceptance the alter
ego of Warwick is shallow and two dimensional. He is an unbelievable
w@nker and that's the problem, he is unbelievable. Sadly so are the
Warwick's selfishness, self importance or blinding crassness is milked
in each situation being contrived and lacking grace or fluency. I
suppose my problem beyond the limited boundaries of the plot/situation
is that I am treated like an idiot lacking any ability to spot
subtleties that are the source of good comedy. Of course, the other
possibility is Gervais and Merchant can only deal in the blatant and
brutal comedy of sarcasm, shock and parody.
If I knew what great comedy was I would be writing it, but bad attempts
robs the audience. If the series had an bigger dimension, a plot, story
line, substance even, then it would not have to rest on it being a
comedy. Without being funny there is not much going for it.
Add another review