"Bones" The Doctor in the Photo (TV Episode 2010) Poster

(TV Series)

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The Most Sublime And Exquisite Episode * SPOILERS *
anderbilt16 August 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I'm the perfect target for television creators. I watch lots of things, and if it's really good, I'm not sure if there's a limit to how many times I can watch a thing over and over again.

There isn't that much on television that rises above a consistent and comfortable plateau that grows from that joint effort of creative intentions and fan response, even with the best of prime time broadcast television drama. Most good tv rises to the level of pretty good, and hits occasional flashes of outstanding brilliance.

I've seen most of this series, except for the final couple of seasons, most of it via a Netflix binge between the 7th and 8th seasons. I became quite caught up in the characters, and the romantic impasse between the two lead characters that concluded the first five seasons.

The sixth season of this show, of which this episode is number nine, builds an off-balance foundation drawn from the characters' choice to scatter and do other things with their lives in the season five finale after Bones rejects the offer of romantic involvement from Booth. It's months later and Cam's problem with a forensics job pulls everyone back to the Jeffersonian in the season six opener. What's new: Booth HAS moved on and is involved with a news reporter named Hannah. In a series of moments in the early episodes there's a subtle onset of a growing instability in Brennan, the growing visibility of inner yearnings, and we gradually see that Booth's moving on with Hannah DOES not sit well, and has started a process which Brennan has little ability to understand much less control.

By the time "Doctor In The Photo" begins, Brennan is in denial, and must confront a victim whose death directly exposes the inner longings and fears she has been carrying about her own life. A brilliant surgeon, a loner, missing for nearly a year when her corpse is discovered in the roots of a storm-toppled tree, isn't missed or mourned by anyone except the coworker whose romantic offer she rejected. Brennan over identifies with the victim and doesn't understand until its almost too late that what she's solving is her own mystery.

There's nothing to match the mental rush of stumbling upon an unexpected dramatic gem, a piece of drama so expertly and masterfully written and performed that it knocks you down every time you watch it. This is one of those rare tv episodes for me. I just watched it again as a matter of fact. Is it the near-perfect soundtrack with quiet swells of disoriented sadness? Is it the near-perfect performance of the regular and guest cast members? Is it Carla Kettner's near-perfect screenplay the actors work from? It is all of this and more, a good show hitting an unexpected moment of transcendent excellence, and saying things about the nature of loneliness and friendship in ways that few other works of art achieve.

I can choose at any moment to resume my binge and finally watch the final few seasons of this show that I have not seen yet. Yet every few months I return to watch one episode, THIS episode, and be deeply touched by it one more time. Thanks.
43 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fantastic Episode...
kitano012 December 2010
This was one of the finest episodes of Bones ever, if not the best-ever.

I disagree with the other reviewer that the transformation of Brennan was too rapid. I feel this episode solidified in many ways how Brennan has been portrayed this season. For instance, she has been trying (in many painful, awkward ways) to loosen up and develop a sense of humor. We have seen her relating to Jersey Shore types and children-show hosts, really trying to stretch her personality. When a person is ripe for a melt-down or just receiving little hints from the universe, it happens.

It also helps to have a guide. Enter Micah. "When the student is ready,the teacher appears". The great Enrico Colantoni just might have a new semi-regular spot on this show! The scenes between him and Deschanel were fantastic.

This was one of those stand-alone episodes we will remember for a long time. Nearly perfect.

I could go about the philosophical and psychological aspects of this episode for hours, it was that beautifully written.
51 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Micah
kols30 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Was Micah real or a projection of Bones' imagination? He was real and here's how I know.

He first appears in the dead of night as Bones is spiraling deeper and deeper into her breakdown, addressing The Doctor as though she were there. Micah walks in on her and helps bring her back to reality, a little. A perfect scenario for a ghost, or an echo of projected rationality - an imaginary friend. And his appearances continue in this vein as Brennan works through the resonances of her similarities with the Doctor, to her heartbreaking realization that she'd blown it with Booth, signaling her return to, and acceptance of, reality. Herein lies the answer - Micah's last appearance takes place after she awakes from her nightmare and once again has her feet firmly planted in the here and now, a country unfriendly to imaginary figments.

That's my argument for Micah being real and I wish we'd see more of him. Perhaps he could even fix the disaster of this season's (2013) finale - Booth's forced rejection of Brennan's marriage proposal.

Whatever. And there's another element of Brennan's breakdown that, like Micah's reality, I only picked up on the third or forth viewing - Brennan's descent into Hell lasted three days, just like somebody else's. The analogy seems like a stretch until you think about it a little and realize that the reference is to death and rebirth, which is symbolically what both the Resurrection and Brennan's breakdown are all about.

Personally, I find this episode very hard to watch because of the tragic (in this case, tragic is the right word) fate of The Doctor and the turmoil of Brennan's three days in Hell, mollified only slightly by Brennan's final catharsis and acceptance of the consequences of her fears. Even so, I would rate this episode as transcendent, meaning it's off the scale by orders of magnitude. The more I watch it, the more Brennan's anguish touches me, the more I grieve for The Doctor and the stronger Bones' catharsis. Sophocles couldn't have done better.
26 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Bones get some past due introspective insight
pasnat15 December 2010
This was one of the best and most touching episodes I've yet seen. We've all wanted Bones to lighten up a little, (though not too much or there goes the show!) and give us a glimpse under the facade. And we wanted it to be more than surrendering to the teasing sexual flirtation she's been carrying on with Booth.

This was as good a payoff as we can expect until the series finale. In this episode, Bones got a deep look into herself, and realized that what she thought was her strength — her objectivity and ability to be dispassionate — was really a weakness that could cost her dearly.

I think one of the reviewers missed the boat badly. Was Bones acting out of character? Well, yes! THAT was the point of the episode. And as for her recognizing herself in the photo when no one else did... once again, that was a meaningful way to show how deeply she was personalizing the case. She saw in the dead doctor a glimpse of what could be in store for her. What rational person, no matter how dispassionate, would not act out of character? I half expected Micah to reveal himself as the Ghost of Christmas Past, Present and Future.

The scene where she finally confessed her love to Booth (somewhat indirectly, but effectively) was very moving. I so wanted to reach out and comfort her. Her eyes had been opened, and her world was turned upside down, and the man she loved was no longer in a position to return her love.

It was a life-changing event, though I still expect them to end up together. (Really together, not implied or assumptive like Luke and Lorelai.)

All in all, terrific insight into Bones' true feelings and Booth's nobility.
35 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
wonderful writing
ledwrite11 December 2010
I've never given 10/10--not on student papers, not on movie and book reviews, and definitely not on TV. I've never written a review here before. However, I disagree with Lor from NY so strongly, I must publish my argument.

I found the Bones episode The Doctor in the Photo fresh and exciting. After six seasons, most TV series become formula-ized, and I think in spite of Reich's fine lead and Hanson's terrific screen writing, Bones was no exception. IMDb lists no other writer on this episode, but Hanson's page doesn't credit him with S6E9--a peculiar discrepancy--but I say (to whomever did write it) Bravo!

The Doctor in the Photo gives all characters new ground--much needed-- and Brennan most of all. In a similar vein to the original Star Trek series, much as we all loved Spock, it's Amock Time (sp?) that we remember most: Nimoy had the opportunity to show emotion. So this hour does for Brennan--one can only hope that it's not an aberration, as it was for Spock, and that it indicates her growth as a human.

I also thank the writer for the fantastic new character of Micah--oh my I have already thought of six new plots involving him... many opportunities with a well-thought-out and beautifully played new guy.
43 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sad, Moving Episode
abbyrd8824 October 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This episode was full of emotion and conflict for Brennan. It was interesting to finally see her evaluate her life after years of strict rationality and realize how she has a tendency to push people away. As a previous reviewer said, Brennan realizes that her rationality is not necessarily a strength. However, I do believe that Bones is very different from the doctor in the photo because she has good friends who seriously care about her. As the episode goes on, we see Booth, Sweets, Cam, Hodgins, Angela, Micah, and even Hannah take serious concern for her when she behaves strangely. Brennan has a lot of people who love her in her life and would certainly care if she went missing (Aliens in a Spaceship anyone?) Nonetheless, the ending when she finally comes to terms with the fact that she shouldn't have rejected Booth was very moving. I was certainly in tears. I knew that when Brennan finally realized this that Booth would have moved on and it would be too late. (See my review of The Parts of the Sum of the Whole) Overall this episode was sad, but it definitely brought out necessary and long-due character development. On a side note, Brennan must have worn at least 7 different trench coats in this episode! Seriously, how many does she own! On another side note, Booth was looking at Brennan more than the road in the emotional car scene. Not that I blame him. But how did he not get in an accident?
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best episodes of Bones!!
brookielee-873993 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I absolutely love this episode of Bones! It's definitely one of my top ten favorite episodes.

Bones relates to the deceased more than she ever has before. The woman they found dead was a doctor, who was obsessed with her work, was hard on her interns, wore a dolphin ring (one exactly like the one Bones' mom gave to her and she wore very often), wasn't married, didn't have a boyfriend, had no children, and turned down the man who's in love with her, even though she's in love with him too.. remind you of anyone??! After feeling a strong relation and connection to the victim, Bones looks at a photo of the deceased doctor and sees herself, even though no one else does. And while examining the bones and listening to the victims medical tapes, she hears her own voice and feels like they have very much in common. She even begins talking to the recording trying to find answers to who killed the victim, what the murder weapon was, and what was the motive for her murder.

At the end, with a little help from Sweets, she realizes that she doesn't want to end up like the victim - alone with no meaningful relationship. Towards the end of the episode Bones tells Booth her true feelings for him and how it was a mistake turning him down when he told her he loved her. But even though Booth still has feelings for Bones, he had to turn her down because he's with Hannah now.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sad and Beautiful
Hitchcoc12 February 2023
This is not just the most moving episode in this entire series, but one of the most beautiful I've seen in any film production. Brennan is a human being, cast from an ugly childhood and a deep, subconscious need to figure out the world based on purely scientific facts. By investigating the death of a doctor who is nearly a carbon copy of her, she realizes that there is more to life than answering questions. This is one time where Emily Deschanel shows her acting chops, with those big eyes and furrowed brow, she works through the details that led to the death of the woman. While there are a couple interrogations with her impeding the process, it takes an aha moment to bring her around to the realities of being a person and being loved and making mistakes. When she finally spills her guts to Booth he knows exactly what she means. By the way, I really enjoyed the nighttime guy who is patient and down to earth (and not a scientist with a bunch of letters after his name). Outstanding. And someone actually rated this a one of ten. It shows evolution doesn't always work.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Really excellent episode
maddyjames-501-1725933 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I admit I am not a fan of Bones: I find the show generally grating for a variety of reasons (lack of creative stories, annoying characters, etc). My mum is a fan of this show and I have had the unfortunate experience of being forced to watch most of the episodes.

However, this is one episode I really do enjoy. This episode was removed enough from the show that it could have easily been a stand-alone 45 minute play. And it stands alone well.

The plot is simple: Brennan has a long, hard look in a mirror and doesn't like what she sees. There's no subplot, which for a show that relies on a two/three plot formula, is impressive. The writing is subtle: which, for a show that does not always handle story lines with delicacy - it is the subtlety that makes this episode work. The dialogue is not incredibly remarkable: for a show that so rarely has any dazzling dialogue between the characters, much of the episode actually consists of Brennan talking to herself in an empty room or to Micah (guest star Enrico Colantoni, who really should have been used for more than just one episode). Emily Deschanel was really fantastic in this episode - normally, I find Brennan absolutely grating (to clarify - I find the writing of Brennan grating as she's written like a robot that would infuriate even a Vulcan.

TL;DR: As someone who normally cannot stand this show, this is a very excellent episode with great writing, directing, producing and acting. To engage someone who actively dislikes most things about this show is not an easy task, but this episode manages to really make it work.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
FBI: gets no ID Hannah: finds the victim on BING
SlutforBones2 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Hey pod,

This episode is by far one of the most important in the entire series. Bones is forced into self-reflection when she sees herself in the victim, starting with the dolphin ring she and the victim wear. The writers did amazing with how they show Bones struggling to be her usual self while struggling with these feelings. The victim is an important Doctor who disappeared quietly and was single, childless, and had almost no relationships outside of work. Even her colleagues, including Booth, point out the "harsher" similarities (the squintern line). Emily's acting in the end makes the episode a 10/10 alone, I felt like my heart also was breaking. Bones finally realizing her full feelings for Booth, and his rejection due to being in a relationship truly affects her. Booth even sounds like he's sad because of the circumstances.

The case this week wasn't very dramatic as we focused on Brennan's character development. It was a slower case and ended up being fairly boring in the end since it was used to push the plotline. I liked the touch of showing the photo from Brennan's perspective in the beginning and at the end.

Overall I give this ep a 10/10 for plot development but the case I'd give about a 4. EP SPOILER* She was a thrill seeker in times of distress and her death was an accident. I'm glad they didn't have the pilot be the killer as I think it would've kept Bones from confronting her feelings and would make the idea of love sound meaningless to her again. The boys won't be thrilled about the accidental death lol.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This episode was so deep and real
barnwal-usa12 August 2019
The whole episode fell like a commentary on modern Urban life. So much depth and honestly felt very troubling in a genuine way. Such episodes are rare on crime shows. Just genuinely amazing and terrifying!
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Emily at her best!
gvollrath-3030416 April 2022
This episode is so powerful. More feels and pain and human need from Temperance in this episode more than any other episode throughout the entire series. This episode moved me to tears and I would question anyone who at least wasn't at bare minimum touched by this performance. With 240+ episodes in this series, this is the one that is always the 1st I think of. I also LOVE Enrico Colantoni (Micah) being in this episode. For his dialoque to be so silly, it is his philosophical view that really seems to make so much sense to Bones even though it is actually not Latin he speaks. Yeah Oreos!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Constructed and out of character
incrediball23 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This episode presents us an entirely new side to Bones, a side that is irrational and incompatible with the character that we have come to know. Simply put, her behaviour is out of character. It is well established that she is highly rational and does not believe in sentience after death. More than once we have seen her standing in front of her mother's grave and wondering why she should say anything to it. And yet here we see her having conversations with a dead woman via a tape recorder! At a stretch I could have accepted this as being a means for Bones to figure out what may have happened and indeed this was perhaps Bones's initial motivation for doing this. However when she plainly admits to Micha, the night watchman, that she is talking with the deceased woman, one can only assume that she has gone insane because there is no way that her character would ever find such embarrassing behaviour acceptable.

This was not acting out of character in the sense that she was not her usual self. This was acting out of character in the sense that she had developed a split personality.

Perhaps the writers wanted to show us that she was on a slippery slope towards insanity because she had always bottled up her emotions. Perhaps her objectivity and ability to be dispassionate was indeed part of this, however if this were the case, then her recovery back to her normal rational self was just too rapid. Something like this would have to be fleshed out over multiple episodes, perhaps even over much of the season.

Then we are expected to really believe that Booth follows Bones out in the middle of the night, when he has better things to do with his own girlfriend. Up to this point Booth wasn't showing a lot of interest in what Bones was feeling about this case. Despite his lack of interest and the fact that he has a personal life of his own, he still follows Bones around in order to save her from herself. This all seems contrived and constructed. In the scene where Booth saves Bones we have a Deus Ex Machina which is the car that comes out of nowhere at a ridiculous speed and yet for the rest of the scene not another car is seen.

Finally Bones spills the beans and admits what so many viewers have been waiting to hear for the last five or six years. However because I had basically switched off at this point (or I was too busy discussing with my wife about what was wrong with the previous scene), I don't remember what happened and what was said. I'm sure that other viewers would agree that this scene was over far too quickly. Possibly scenes in following episodes with her grappling with the realisation that she loves Booth before she finally manages to admit it?
11 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
For me, just the best episode.
angeliyo_200425 February 2021
One of the few times we can conect entirely with Brennan, this episode is an introspective exercise for the character and for the fan who followed her adventures.

The pacing, the music and the acting is top notch in "the doctor in the photo".

Everyone needs a "Mikah" sometime.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The world turned upside down
krahnnikki8 November 2022
Hi hones booth!

Ok if you allow yourself to look at this episode without all of the logic of how things really work and just accept it as a tv land episode it is SO enjoyable!

We know this isn't really bones in her normal character but it also leads itself to conclude that she is grappling with the understanding of her feelings and possibly making a big change by expressing those feelings. The whole car scene at the end CRUSHES me every single time. It's such good acting by both of them. You can tell booth looks crushed to have her hurting but he remains a faithful honest person to his current girlfriend which obviously we are all rooting for b & b but I also like him being a respectful person to Hannah - even clarifying she's not just a concelation.

I love the filing of this episode - so dark and eeery. Emily literally does SO amazing at displaying all her emotions in this episode. You really feel it's almost her pov the entire time.

Love the scene when Hannah says "I don't like when you two fight" lol. I also like the part when booth is like "ya I already know they aren't going to like this, we're bringing the whole tree back"!

Such a cool episode and I really really enjoy all of it even though it makes me feel all types of anxiety for bones the entire time!

It's heart breaking knowing she now has to live with acknowledging her feelings but obviously not getting to act on them.

PS I love Micah in this episode too! And obviously the case in itself is more about the parallels than anything else - not the best ending "killer" wise but that never bothers me in this one!
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bones's character is fleshed out, with mixed results.
lor_10 December 2010
I liked the attempt in this off-beat episode to go deeper into the character of Bones, with good thesping by Emily Deschanel providing the required stretch. Unfortunately, it falls short of classic status by cheating the audience in several ways.

The gimmick is to have Deschanel essentially play a dual role: the latest victim vaguely resembles her and she gradually becomes irrational (WAY out of character), identifying with the stiff in very self-destructive fashion. This permits the writers to cleverly comment on Bones' personality as developed over six seasons, and even delve explicitly into the series' basic premise, namely the unresolved sexual tension between Bones and co-star David Boreanz's character.

This all earns a big E for effort, but along the way too many corners are cut. We're presented with a photo of (I assume, correct me if I'm wrong) Deschanel as the victim, yet only she recognizes it as herself; the rest of the cast is bewildered at her "that's me!" reaction. A similar cheat is having the oft-played tape recordings (a phony gimmick) of the femme surgeon-victim spoken with Deschanel's voice and exact intonation.

Of course, we're supposed to assume that all this is taking place in Bones's head, though the episode is otherwise depicted realistically. At one point sleep deprivation is floated as a possible reason for her weird behavior. But I found it very difficult to sustain my natural willingness to believe the unbelievable (even with "Fringe" coming up next on the tube - a show which flaunts this!) given the episode's moving Bones so far (and so quickly) from her long-established personality.

No, this was not the fashionable "jump the shark" turning point in the series. But as intriguing as it was to watch, it represented a missed opportunity to actually delve into the depths of an all-too one-dimensional character (as usually presented week after week), falling back on gimmickry. Not surprising, because the most popular TV shows and movies of the last few years are all about gimmicks, not substance, and the fans eat it up.
16 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
BREAKING BONES
irishviking215 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Best episode I've ever seen. I loved seeing her emotional responses to every aspect of this episode. I thoroughly enjoyed the pain she experienced. It was a long time coming. This is one of the worst characters written ever! After the years of arrogance, oath to a life of logic, dismissal of that which can not be quantified, and internalization of emotion...it was so satisfying to see it all thrown in her face. It was like watching a computer short-circuit if it were able to cry. The worst and by far most irrational part of this episode (and show) is that every single other character treats this outbreak as so so sensitive that they should tread lightly, as if she is a delicate little flower (that hates talking to other flowers). This show is FAR FAR FAR from reality (Brennan is not a detective, why is she in the field where her experience isn't helpful and often only hurts the investigation??), but the most unrealistic aspect is how EVERY character bows down and befriends this type of person to such an intimate level. She doesn't express emotion, she's socially awkward (nothing in the subtypes of PDD, since her character arc looks like an EKG of ventricular fibrillation), and offers zero sympathy/empathy to any one of them. They base the comedy of the show around her "oops I'm naive that I didn't understand that joke and now I'm going to be silly and show you by resorting to pure logic...but don't worry I never learn anything and will continue to do this. Don't worry, no one will find it odd that I'm unable to adapt socially and continue to walk me into these silly jokes."

WORST CHARACTER EVER, but this episode was so so sooooo satisfactory seeing her own disbeliefs thrown into her face!!
5 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dreadful
nelvis-754-54265514 August 2022
There is nothing in this episode that resembles any other episode in the series. There's often a tendency for characters to act out of character to suit the writers mood but this episode is embarrassingly bad. They've even introduced a character for Brennan to talk to who has never been seen before and is never seen again.
5 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed