Vicky and Sam (2010) Poster

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Nice concept and technically well delivered, but the material peters out somewhat and ends up being a little disappointing
bob the moo8 April 2014
A young man and woman catches eyes across a video store and immediately there seems to be a chemistry there and all just by chance. Or maybe he was there only because he had already seen it and was looking for a way to make his first move? Hey, maybe the whole reason he is hiring films at all is to make an impression on her and maybe he doesn't even watch them? Three aspiring writers site in a diner and bounce ideas around the lives of their characters before finding their story going in a weird direction.

This is both a nice film and a disappointing one and the two aspects are directly connected. The nice part comes early on because we start the film as a regular Hollywood romance, with nice footage, beautiful young people having "awkward easy connection" type love that doesn't happen too often in real life. This establishes the genre and then we move into another world where the story is now just ideas and our characters are the three writers behind the ideas (good or bad). This is clever and it offered potential that this would go somewhere interesting.

It does this again later in the film, where the ground rules are changed again for the viewer (although more importantly also changed for the characters). Oddly though, the film doesn't really go anywhere from here. We spend a few minutes treading water with the same basic ideas and then when the narrative calls for the film to step it or deliver, it doesn't and instead seems more about delivering a line that is a good "jobbing writer" line but really doesn't work in the context of the film.

It is nicely made and filmed, whether it is as a rom-com with all the gloss or a regular diner. The performances are OK and generally it looks good and sounds good, but it is just the material where it lets itself down because as it ramps up it just seems to plateau with no clear direction before it glides to a conclusion. A shame because it is a nice film in concept and general delivery, but the material doesn't make the most of the idea and it ultimately ends up feeling disappointing on that level.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Lovely Romance-Comedy in the Fashion of Magical Realism
BuddyBoy6019 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
ABOUT: Vicky and Sam are budding lovers in a romantic story being conceived by three persons in a diner. While being completely absorbed in the creative process, the proceeding events they encounter become seemingly hard to believe and understand.

REVIEW: I love this short film mainly because it is romantic, funny and it attempts to tell a story that is out of the box. It has a story which consists of a fantastical phenomenon that is set and transpiring in the real world and which real people try to deal with. Those who are familiar with the works of Federico Fellini, Woody Allen and Emir Kusturica (to name a few) would likely label this as magical realism. This way, in which the story is told, tickled my imagination and would most likely also have the same effect to others, probably more so to those who haven't encounter such a film and are looking for something creatively thoughtful and refreshing.

The music is also a highlight. The use of "The Splendour of Love" by Piero Piccioni is splendid, it added so much to the romantic mood the short film is aiming at.

The actors are great considering the movie only runs for less than 12 minutes. They deliver their parts with such liveliness and proper expression of emotions, especially humor. Simply put, they were able to supply what was required by the film.

And did I already mention how gorgeous the movie looks?

FINAL WORD: Truly, a short review can't say all the things that are good in this short film. Vicky and Sam is something special. If you are fan of romantic comedies and magical realism, I highly recommend this short film. It's posted somewhere online, try Youtube or Vimeo. So go watch it and have your own say.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed