3 out of 16 people found the following review useful:
Decent production quality, boring story, bad acting and disastrous characters but some creative ideas, underground but anecdotic elements, convincing and malicious Linda Hunt
igoatabase from France
12 December 2009
I had never seen the show before and decided to watch this episode for
two reasons. First because of a Gothic-punk featurette with Abby
Sciuto, a character from NCIS. Moreover on Wikipedia she's described as
"a paradox wrapped in an oxymoron smothered in contradictions in terms"
so I thought her profile could be interesting. Second the episode
summary I read mentioned patterns and a serial killer which instantly
reminded me of Dexter. These elements intrigued me but now that I've
seen Random on Purpose I wish I had done something else.
The production quality was correct even if I noticed some bad lighting.
The major issues were the story and acting. The investigation was
boring and following the male characters running all around wasn't even
entertaining. However I admit that the filming and editing were dynamic
and original at times. I specially liked how the scenes with the
motorbike falling was "first person" filmed. The dual interview was
original even if I found it too hasty. As for the acting Linda Hunt did
a great job as Henrietta "Hetty" Lange, some sort of mini James Bond's
M. But the other performers didn't convince me at all and I was
specially disappointed by Pauley Perrette who played Abby.
It leads us to the characters. In general I found their chemistry
didn't work but as I didn't know them I probably just couldn't relate.
However I'm sure of something, that Abby is silly, antipathic and
boring. She's some sort of dark geek, ecstasy powered. She was just too
excited and jumpy. It's cute with a little girl but watching a woman
acting like that was just painful to watch. So she wasn't the smart and
funny babe I hope she would be. The only scene with her I liked was at
the "Steampunk" club because I thought its underground universe was
believable and refreshing. I specially enjoyed how the clubbers
nicknamed the others. "Muggles" if I understood correctly. It reminded
me of Harry Potter but I was probably hallucinating. In fact I don't
get why the writers didn't focus more on the relationship between the
dark scene and the killer. It would have definitely brought some
contrast and depth to that too shiny story.
So overall once I'm done with this review I'll quickly forget about it.
There were some high-end technology to appeal the geeks, like the large
touch screens, but it was nothing like in CSI: NY because it felt like
the characters were just showing off. They just didn't look like
special agents and in general I wish the show had less muscle and more
brain. Moreover Hetty's role was far too anecdotic when she's the only
character I really liked.
Add another review