Late Autumn (2010) Poster

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
19 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Curiously Original Experience About Love and Life, that is both Poignant and Genuine
totalovrdose13 April 2016
The film opens with a severely beaten Anna (the always beautiful Wang Tei) desperately struggling to come to terms with what led to the death of an, as of yet, unidentified male. Much of the film operates in this fashion, providing the viewer with enough of a taste to comprehend what may have happened, however, rarely definitively illustrating an exact answer, allowing the audience's imagination to fill in the blanks. On one hand, this has the unique feel of independent cinema, and allows viewers much freedom, though at the same time, can become frustrating, considering we, the viewers, long for completeness to quench our thirst for knowledge.

Seven years later, in the midst of a prison sentence, Anna is given a three day furlough to visit her mother's funeral. On the way to Seattle, she bumps into Hoon (Hyun-Bin), who asks her to lend him money for bus fare, and though he promises to pay her back, Anna shows little interest. Ms. Tei convincingly plays a woman who has become disillusioned and pessimistic from her time in prison, while exhibiting melancholy in a city which has changed since she was last there.

By chance, she meets Hoon once more, who offers to take her around Seattle. Hoon is, for lack of a better term, a gigolo, however, his explanation sounds far more advertising, though at the same time, he seems painfully romantic, garnering feelings for some of the women he meets, despite being required to maintain his professionalism.

On the run from the jealous husband of a woman who fell in love with him two years earlier, Hoon is a man whose life has taken a turn for the worse, much like Anna's, yet continues to maintain optimism and confidence, that attracts her to him. Surrounded by judgemental relatives, Hoon is the one man who accepts Anna for who she is.

The chemistry between the leads is especially great, there being a number of equally dramatic and humorous moments to behold. Moreover, a number of scenes are very memorable, including a moment when Hoon and Anna break into an amusement park, alongside another time when Anna discusses some of her past.

The multiple locations are brilliantly brought to life by the cinematography, which further draws us into the experience, while the use of sound and music is just as effective.

By the conclusion of the film, I was left feeling a little empty, for unlike other features, that serenade us with fantastical plots of everlasting love, director Kim Tae-Yong never tries to force anything. Instead, he creates a feature that feels very genuine, right down to the painful reality that not everything is destined to end happily ever after, despite our wishful thinking.

(Half of the film is in English, while the other half is sub-titled).
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Unusual
phd_travel10 March 2020
What a strange but engrossing movie. In English Korean and Chinese. Set in Seattle the story is a about a woman in prison for killing her abusive husband when out on release for a funeral she meets a gigolo and they bond. An unusual romance ensues with a good scene after the funeral. It's interesting to see Hyun Bin as a rascally character. Tang Wei acts a bit too sullen and sometimes the dialogue is strained and out of place. Still worth a watch.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Light candles in a bright room
w-7147426 May 2020
This movie reminds me of a story told in "Days in the Cloud". A boy fell in love with a demure and beautiful girl at first sight. He expressed love to her and asked if he could continue to communicate in the future. The girl turned back and her eyes were as clear as water. She said, I will enter the monastery tomorrow. "What if I fall in love with you?" The boy asked. "That's like lighting a candle in a bright room." The girl replied. So the boy left in amazement.

"Light a candle in a bright room", what a futile thing. You shine, but you can't shine, you are warm, but you don't snuggle, you slowly exhaust yourself, the red tears drop, the wax torch becomes gray, but no one takes care of you. It doesn't matter if you are more or less, the world will not change at all, and it will still be brightly lit and bustling. You are like an invisible clown with open teeth and dancing claws, but you can't make everyone smile, bored, boring, stupid, in vain, vain, and hot, you work hard, there is no place for you.

Lighting candles in a bright room is like hopeless love. No return, no results, no future, would you like to make such a stupid candle? The boy who fell in love with the nun must have been unwilling. Although he was sad, he left rationally.

Although Tang Wei has no makeup in the movie, his clothes are bleak, and his expressions rarely change. Although Xuan Bin 's handsomeness is very naive and the skills of coaxing women are quite old-fashioned, although the autumn wind in Seattle is lingering, the street scene is sluggish Knowing that their ending is bleak and gradually approaching the end, but I still feel that this is a warm story. Calm but not cold, looking at each other without despair, just like autumn, the sky is cold and the trees are full of dead branches and leaves, but there is a warm autumn sun spilling from the gaps, spotted, and touching.

The scammer and the female prisoner met in strange ways, but secretly fell in love. They are clearly "lighting candles in a bright room." After three days, one is going back to prison and the other is desperate. They ca n't change each other 's destiny, but in the end, they still change something, a gentle sorrow. Zhong rose slightly, which makes the relationship between the two people have a "doom warm" meaning.

Who said shining love must make this world magnificent? They didn't light up the room, but they light up each other's hearts.

At the end of the movie, she was finally released from prison and waited for him in the agreed cafe. He gave her a little hope, like a thin candlelight. He probably won't come, they probably don't kiss next time. But I don't think this is the vain of love.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"Hi. It's been a long time."
hudsonwa24 May 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Man chu | Late Autumn Director: Kim Tae-Yong Republic of Korea (South Korea), Hong Kong, China, USA 2010 English, Korean, Mandarin Cast includes Tang Wei (Anna), Hyun Bin (Hoon).

A young woman waits in an empty diner outside a lonely bus stop. Pie and a cup of coffee. She touches neither. Every sound of footsteps, she turns. She smiles. "Hi. It's been a long time."

Man chu opens with Anna staggering down a suburban street, bloodied, face bruised, clothes torn. We learn that she has killed her abusive husband. Seven years later, serving out the sentence for her crime, Anna is given two days' compassionate leave to attend her mother's funeral in Seattle, tied to prison by a cell phone that rings periodically and which she must answer, giving her location.

As Anna's bus pulls out of a station, Hoon, a young dandy and rent boy, jumps aboard. He doesn't have enough money to pay for his ticket and asks to borrow money from Anna. He is Korean, Anna is Chinese – he seems to assume a bond? Deciding whether to give a stranger 30 bucks.

Thus two unlikely misfits meet and fall in love, despite all odds.

Man chu, a remake of a 1966 Korean film of the same name, is ravishingly filmed with a RED camera transferred to D-Cinema Cinemascope, featuring deeply affecting lead performances by the Chinese actress Tang Wei and South Korean actor Hyun Bin and strong supporting performances, including two white dancers who silently act out a beautifully composed break-up scene choreographed by Dayna Hanson and dubbed by Anna and Hoon in a brilliant sequence filmed in a derelict amusement park.

Anna and Hoon speak to each other in English, when Anna decides to speak at all. (Tang Wei achieves the lion's share of her unforgettable performance in silence.) In one emotionally devastating scene, Anna tells Hoon her story step by step in Chinese. He interprets by her face and responds to each sentence "Hao" (good) or "Huai" (bad). Though it is evident he does not understand, his responses reveal deep empathy, which Anna recognizes in an extended sequence of acting without words – one among many in this profoundly actorly film.

One slow dissolve on Anna's beautiful face is destined for the annals of film history, I think.
19 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beautiful, if you have an eye for it..
asthab1 November 2014
If you are looking for one of those happy and feel-good movies, then this one is not for you. However, if you are up for a different experience, knowing it might not end well(who knows!), then you are in for a beautiful ride. Its a simple story. No complications there. Its just the chemistry between the lead guy and the girl is precious. It just goes on to prove that all you need are few dedicated minutes with a person to know if you like them. And sometimes, it helps not to look too far down in the future. Live today - for all you have. The movie is a treat if you want to watch a relaxing movie on a lazy Saturday night. I loved it!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An unconventional and beautiful romance
wickedmikehampton16 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Tang Wei immediately became one of my favourite actresses with 'Late Autumn'. I'd previously seen her in the stylishly slowcore 'Long Days Journey into Night', but this simple movie captivated me.

It's an unconventional romance set over two days, shot in the USA but in English, Chinese and a smidgeon of Korean.

On the first day, Tang is given a pass to leave prison after having been there for 7 years for murder. She's to attend her mother's funeral in Seattle. Her bottled up emotions are challenged by an irritating dandy who proves he's more than that.

It's a beautiful story, and I admire directors who don't aim for generic success that they're obviously capable of obtaining.

I also appreciated the way the credits were shown at the end.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Raw. Deep. Beautiful.
xeniamd-3521010 April 2020
It's good to have company. Life does not belong to just beautiful and perfect people. Everyone deserves a chance at life.

This film tells a love story of two strangers who do not use a lot of words to share their innermost feelings. Some may find it boring or confusing with the abstract concepts, weaving the intricacies of life into each and every scene, but it made my brain cells work. Melancholic mood, slow paced, gloomy Seattle, trilingual(English, Korean, Chinese). Raw. It's deep and beautiful. I love it! Binnie and Tang Wei were perfect for the roles as Hoon and Anna.

I loved watching their 2 minutes and 27seconds kissing scene. Oohhlala! The longest in Korean film history!

Released on February 2011. #HyunBin #TangWei #LateAutumn
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Two strangers met. He help her by letting her talk but not to hear
freetogo7 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Two strangers met in a bus trip. Anna has been in jail for 7 years and is on a 3day bail to attend her mom's funeral. Hyunbin is at large and hiding from Police. Anna is a Chinese while Hyunbin is a Korean. In the movie, their only language to communicate is English. Hyunbin see in Anna's eyes knowing that she has numerous unresolved feeling to say but don't want anyone to hear. He encourages her to dub words for passersby and to talk with him in Chinese.

In this movie, you can't see any dramatic story. Neither is there sexy love scenes nor violent. All these details are skipped. Instead, it is about how to live para hoy while failing to forget the past.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Like a poem ❤
XzingLawliet4 May 2020
The kind of film, which like a sad song or a poem lingers in your heart for days after it ends. It's like a poem; melancholic beauty at its purest which can be depicted on screen. Simply amazing..
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
So slow
weamKYF13 January 2022
I am a very big fan of korean drama, but here in this film,there are TOO many slow scenes , i was waiting for any climax or happy moments.. just nothing.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Captivating, Whimsical and Unpredictable Romance
Blue-Grotto2 May 2020
Anna and Hoon sit in a restaurant and observe other couples talking to each other. Since they cannot hear what the others are saying, Anna and Hoon fill in the words for themselves and laugh at what they come up with. It is just one of the fantastic scenes in this captivating, whimsical and unpredictable romance and drama.

Anna is on leave from prison to attend her mother's funeral. Hoon is a charmer, con and gigolo on the run from the angry husband of one of his clients. They meet on a bus headed to Seattle. Anna is cold, depressed and lifeless. She has suffered much abuse in her life and is in no mood for more of the same, but Hoon is so charming and persistent that he begins to draw her out of her shell. As Hoon confronts those who treat Anna badly, she begins to see these negative people in a new light and realize what is holding her back. In helping Anna, Hoon may even break free from the same demons.

The chemistry between Wei Tang (Anna) and Bin Hyeon (Hoon) is definite and palpable. In answering questions after this world premiere Kim Tae-Yong claimed, with laughter, that this was because both actors do not speak English very well, and neither speaks the native tongue of the other (Chinese and Korean). "They were more perceptive this way" he said. There is evident truth to the claim. The acting is superb. There were abrupt changes in pace, sound and scenery, and I was captivated by the effect of each switch. I was surprised by the ending. Spoken languages include English primarily, Mandarin and Korean. Seen at the Toronto international film festival.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Trying to stuff 3 different movies into 1 film
rainonmebi27 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This movie was pretty bad. I hadn't planned on writing a review for this ever because there was just too much to say but I guess I'll write it anyway. I usually love Korean movies and watch them all the time so I know the format.. they can be overly long and overly sentimental. I digress.

The movie started out interesting. However quickly got WTF when Anna was let out of jail on so-called "compassionate leave" WITHOUT an escort OR ankle bracelet not to mention she was in jail for a VIOLENT CRIME. All they gave her was a cell phone to keep track of her (which they only called her twice). so that bothered me.

why did they get such bad actors for Americans? all of them sounded like English wasn't their first language... that scene at the bumper cars.omg such bad acting... the scene went on WAYY too long and then that random dance that they did?! it was beautiful, and how it was edited but it had NO place in that movie and made NO sense what so ever! so they ran and were in some meat shop where it was bothering me that they had left the meat sitting out like that and the doors open?!

and then, when anna was telling her story to hyunbin, he kept saying hao and hwey and was TOTALLY making everything she said "unserious" and i didn't feel bad for character. everyone in this movie fell flat... that kiss in the end WAS TOO LONG OMG. WTF was that! It was LITERALLY, over a minute long kiss scene. i kept looking at my watch waiting for that movie to be over.

i could say more but who will read it? anyway. they tried to shove a comedy a drama and an indie art film into one movie and it DID NOT work.
9 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
How an unlikely love story acquires a soul
harry_tk_yung7 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
The prologue opens with a dishevelled and somewhat stunned looking women (later known as Anna Chan), a lost soul wandering in a suburban area of a city (later known to be Seattle). Then, as if suddenly snapped back into her senses, she returns to what must be scene of crime and fumbles around a dead man lying on the floor. Police sirens, then an abrupt cut to the title on a black screen "Late Autumn".

Seven years later, we see Anna getting a three day pass from prison to attend her mother's funeral, with a cell phone by which her whereabouts is monitored. Failure to answer and report will constitute prison-breaking, immediately triggering a manhunt (or womanhunt, if you wish). On the bus home to Seattle, she encounters Hoon, a Korean young man who claims to have his wallet stolen and borrows 30 dollars from her to make up for his bus fare. Noticing the reluctance in her compliance, he leaves her his watch for custodianship until he pays her back. The rest of the movie is about the development of a subtle relationship between Anna and Hoon.

The persona of the two protagonists cannot be more polarized. Hoon is flippant, happy-go-lucky but not without charm. This soon all makes sense as it is revealed that his is a male escort (a less flattering term would be gigolo). While phone calls Anna gets are from the prison authorities, Hoon gets his share of phone calls from a friend warning him that one of his favourite client's husband is furious and coming after him. Anna, serving a sentence for killing (not specified if it is murder or lesser charge) is understandably taciturn and guarding. Hoon seems quite sincere in his attentive and gentle attempt to make friends, but to no avail.

Upon arrival in Seattle, Hoon goes off to meet his client, said wife of the angry husband, makes himself obviously very welcome, receives a handsome fee, and even an invitation to elope. Anna is less fortunate, finding herself almost like a stranger to her family after 7 years of imprisonment. After some agonizing, she decides to spend the time before the funeral in solitude. When Anna and Hoon chance to meet again, each with a day ahead with no clear purpose, it is where the mesmerizing movie really begins. On an impulse, she suggests sex ("Do you want me?") which does not work out as she has been so emotionally damaged in the last 7 years in prison. In good humour, he suggests taking this "first unsatisfied customer" on a relaxing tour of Seattle.

One situation in movies always fascinates me – how two complete strangers finally click. My top favourite has always been, and still is, "The bridges of Madison County" (1995)(except for Before Sunrise/Sunset, which is beyond being mere "top favourite"). What "Late Autumn" offers is ingenious and, as already mentioned, mesmerizing. The day has gone relaxing enough, despite her taciturn irresponsiveness to his considerate attention. Then at dawn, in a deserted amusement park, something magical happens. At a distance, they see a couple (purportedly Greek, he darkish and she blonde and fair) on an animated exchange. He is trying to end their relationship while she implores him to reconsider. In his customary flippant style, Hoon starts to dub the conversation in amusement, in both voices. The magical moment starts when Anna, quite unexpectedly, picks up the woman's part. The scene ends with a surreal dance sequence beautifully executed by the distant couple. From this point on, there may not appear to have been any apparent change in the relationship between Anna and Hoon, the audience sense that somewhere, there souls are beginning to find each other.

Two ensuing and equally ingenious scenes cement this development. Anna tells her story – an adolescent infatuation, an unhappy marriage, re-entering into her life of the irresponsible man she adored, jealous husband and physical abuse, and finally killing (legal technicalities omitted) and imprisonment. While Anna and Hoon have been conversing in English (with amply adequate fluency), this self-revelation sequence is in Chinese, with Hoon responding in the only two Chinese words he knows – "good" and "bad". Despite that fact that these two words are sometimes used incorrectly (almost farcically), one somehow gets the feeling that Hoon understands most of what Anna tells him. Or does it really matter? The other scene is a social gathering after the funeral, ending in a brawl between Hoon and this irresponsible ex-boy friend of Anna, now happily married. The whole scene is a charade and again at times almost farcical – the reason given by Hoon for his physical attack is that this man has used his fork, and didn't even apologize. The more farcical the scene, the more poignant is the entirely over-blown emotional reaction of both Hoon and Anna, standing up for each other.

I fear this piece is already approaching IMDb's word limits. There is a lot more to be discovered, enjoyed and appreciated in this movie which is filmed in Seattle, in the city's usual melancholy rain and mist, but not without a break of sunshine that is particularly significant. Music is put to the best use, as is complete silence. TANG Wei's superb, nuanced performance won her a dozen well deserved awards. HYUN Bin's role is not as easy as it appears. To play a flippant gigolo is not difficult but to play one that convincingly capture the audience empathy requires much work, which he delivers almost effortlessly.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Between prison, long-haul bus, Seattle tour duck, a funeral, other people's fork, Hao / Huai
joshuay-212 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Picture: Anna gets out of prison for 2 days after 7 years on falsely charged crime of killing her husband, because her mother passed away. She returned home to her brother asking for her signature to sell the house; she sees young nephews and nieces that she has never seen before. As family members argue with each other over logistics of the funeral, she walks to the backyard and attempts to make friend with a cat, who led her to see her lover - a man who grew up with her, left her, came back to ask her to divorce her husband, and later killed her husband and never left Anna in prison, with his new wife and a baby. He said, how are you doing, it's good to see you, you still look like a child, and squeezes her cheeks.

The film then shows Anna shopping, buying and putting on a dress, earrings, make-up. Throughout the movie Tang Wei does not say much, except in a few outbursts where her emotions accumulates (she did this before in Lust, Caution). You think in this scene, she want something, just a little bit, for herself now.

This is a movie where if you put in enough empathy, you might shift uncomfortably in your chair during a few scenes. I walked away thinking, how long will that one kiss, or the one promise, lasts for her in prison? With her understated and unspoken acting, Wei's character appears to be of almost limitless will - and I think she will wait in that cafe for forever.

It's a superb script, with brilliant surprises that make emotional sense that superb script has. I think it asks: stripped of all the superficial necessities and orders that make our lives make sense, what happen to us? What would you do if you are Chinese American on a Portland to Seattle bus attending your mother's funeral and need to go back to prison in two days, with the persons you loved leaving you in prison, bumping into a handsome Korean gigolo, who might be the only person in the world that cares about you?
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good movie for autumn
kimeastlight-6660219 September 2016
Whenever the autumn comes in South Korea, I am reminded of the movie , The Late Autumn(Man-Choo). When I watched this movie for the first time, I only focused on the main actress's pure face. I think Tang-Wei is a great actress. I have never met an angel in my life, but I guess that a beautiful angel's face is very similar to hers. After a while, I watched this movie again, and I realized that Seattle is a very important aspect of this movie. Seattle is notorious for gloomy, foggy, and humid weather. On the contrary, we can know that the sunshine is very valuable even if we only enjoy it for a short time. To avoid spoilers, I cannot reveal too much thing here, but I am sure that if you watch this movie, you will fantasize about a trip to Washington State. I watched this movie again yesterday. It's my third time watching this movie. I found out that all the characters of this movie really want to love and be loved. And sometimes aggressive love can bring us disaster and unhappiness. Anyway, I decided yesterday that I would watch this movie every autumn with bitter coffee because Seattle is famous for coffee. It should be watched again and again...
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Three day worth
mnutnichae11 April 2020
You have to watch this movie. If you are hyun bin fans, it has a scene that full of love restraint.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Grey toned coloured movie & honest love
dilansketch17 July 2021
It suprise me they way they found each other in their hardest time of their life but with honest and pure heart they accepted each other. The fact life has dull and not bright colour...they met in halfway....

This movie has the right colour tone to bring the emotion. I enjoyed the process of Anna and Hoon being closer each time..love it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful and raw
sagaguilar-3743827 December 2020
You have to slow down to watch this but it's worth it. I took one star off because I want more.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cheking out your internal barometer
petresti9619 January 2013
You will find inside you the answer to all the questions that might arise during the 115 min of beautiful "Korean cinema - now- ". You could confirm your internal GPS and uncover lost feelings and/or emotions that you were never sure about.A movie that offers an affirmation about your internal GPS,maybe gives away a technique to discover different information about your true self.You might find a subtle,lingering something that repeatedly remains unemployed inside you that keeps you ignorant about profound experiences.If things suggested in the movie make sense for your own self you will end up weeping or laughing - that would represent an affirmation that the statements do resonate with you.I wish that you step out of the movie theatre a truer version of yourself!!!!!!Enjoy.
9 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed