Focuses on Homo Erectus, which appears about 2 million years ago. Tells us that Homo immediately populated Eurasia, including Spain and Indonesia.
Shows us a human family tree--but never so we can read it.
Makes many absurd statements of human "uniqueness"--
Claims that homo's use of technology (stone tools) is unique. (Spiders' webs and beaver dams are far more impressive; bower-bird nests and crows' and raptors' use of bombing to break nuts and bones are as impressive. David Attenborough's "Challenges of Life" shows Capuchin monkeys using stone tools. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1535233/combined)
Claims that "symbolic communication" is uniquely human. No: prairie dogs' distinct warning calls for flying predators and ground predators; the two calls of chickadees and the four calls of loons with their separate meanings; flight patterns of bees at the hive, and step patterns on the comb, symbolically telling their sisters what direction and how far the flowers are.
Supposes that homo erectus may have been the first animal to care about what others thought of him. (My pet cat clearly does so.)
Tells us that fire was likely the defining innovation that permitted the evolution of genus homo: fire would've softened some foods, which may have enabled a smaller jaw; plausibly fire enabled our ancestors to keep predators at bay so they could sleep on the ground at night. But this show goes beyond such plausible claims, overreaching to claim that it was "around the campfire" that we became social creatures. To the contrary, baboons, chimps, bonobos are intensely social. The claim that we weren't social until we burnt something sounds like a fantasy of "major funders" ExxonMobil and mining and oil billionaire David Koch.
Claims that humans are uniquely gifted long-distance runners! (We sure can't hold a candle to dogs and wolves, bison and horses.) Shows Bushmen in southern Africa, saying in four hours in the heat of the day they can run to exhaustion an antelope that evolved to outdistance the short sprint of a big cat. Praises humans' ability to hunt in such heat furry animals that need rest. Again: "global warming is good for humans! Brought to you by ExxonMobil and extractive industries billionaire David Koch."
Supposes that a homo erectus-vintage specimen in Indonesia had caretakers chew his food for him, as he had no teeth. (He had stone knives and fire: with these you can make food soft, and mash or cut it small enough to swallow.)
Part of the show has an odd, annoying techno percussion beat, as if to say, "we know this is boring, so listen to this to kill the time."
So, if you want a program to downplay the catastrophic effects of climate change, downplay the similarities between humans and other animals, and exaggerate the importance of burning, go for one presented by the fuel industry.
2 of 4 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?