Criminal Minds: Season 5, Episode 6

The Eyes Have It (4 Nov. 2009)

TV Episode  |  TV-14  |   |  Crime, Drama, Mystery
Your rating:
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 -/10 X  
Ratings: 7.1/10 from 594 users  
Reviews: 1 user

The BAU team tracks a serial killer who keeps the eyes of his victims as souvenirs.



(created by), , 1 more credit »
0Check in

Watch Now

From $1.99 on Amazon Video

« Previous Episode | 96 of 247 Episodes | Next Episode »


1 video »


Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Lt. Brantley
Dr. Ruiz
Cheryl Dooley ...
Lani Sukarto
Bina Sukarto


Morgan is stepping tentatively into his new role as Chief of the BAU, a role he has agreed to take temporarily in Hotch's forced removal from that position by Section Chief Strauss. Morgan has decided to relinquish the position and hand it back to Hotch after George Foyet, aka the Boston Reaper, is caught, Foyet who is still foremost on Hotch's mind. Rossi is concerned about this change of the guard if only because he sees Morgan as a natural leader who may not want to give up the authority after a taste of it. Regardless, J.J. and Garcia take some measures to make Morgan feel more welcome in the position. The first case the team work on under Morgan's leadership is in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, where three people in two separate incidents have been murdered, the only connection between the two incidents being that the victims' eyes were removed. The victimologies and the M.O. of the killings were totally different. It isn't until there are more victims that the BAU begin to understand ... Written by Huggo

Plot Summary | Plot Synopsis






Release Date:

4 November 2009 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs



Sound Mix:



Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


During the scene where Prentiss breaks the glass window with her elbow, Paget Brewster actually cut herself. She got excited by this and was showing her "war wound" to everyone. See more »


The car park scene at beginning is clearly Canada and not US as a sign behind the victims read 'Theatres' Canadian/British spelling rather than US 'Theaters' spelling. Vancouver is one of the known filming locations. See more »


Derek Morgan: [closing quotation, voiceover] "Dwell in peace in the home of your own being, and the messenger of death will not be able to touch you." - Guru Nanak.
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Eye of the Beholder
20 July 2011 | by (Finland) – See all my reviews

After seeing five of the first six episodes of season 5 (missed #5.2 thanks to broadcaster's "creative" 2-episodes-in-a-week-instead-of-1 scheduling), it is safe to say that the great season opener was no fluke. Criminal Minds proved to be a late bloomer, but better late than never. The series has had a clear re-design with season 5 - a new episode is now something to look forward to, instead of being unsure whether it will turn out to be a gem like, for example, "The Fisher King: Part 1", "3rd Life", "Lo-Fi", "Omnivore", the criminally under-rated "The Big Wheel", and "Roadkill" - or a turd like "The Popular Kids", "Scared to Death", "Children of the Dark", "Mayhem" and the ironically named "Masterpiece".

So, the foremost change is the shift from stand-alone episodes to a more continual narrative. Hotch probably has one for the whole season with the hell The Reaper is putting him through, but Morgan has been having one also so far. Even better, as Rossi points out, Hotch and Morgan's character arcs seem destined to collide during the season. Other characters seem so far to be placed in a supporting role - an understandable decision: after all, you can't jump from what was practically stand-alone episodes to seven overlapping ongoing character arcs. So, Prentiss remains The Lady Males Imagine Sexed Up (See Paget Brewster's appearances in late night talk shows where she gets to shed the Fed look), Spencer is now The One With Injury, while Rossi remains The Wise Mentor and Garcia, well, Garcia. The one character that exudes network-suit involvement is JJ, who's suddenly been turned into Hot JJ. Not that I am complaining, but I can almost hear a suit demanding, "We need more sex appeal on this show! Why does NCIS have Abby and Ziva, but our JJ is introverted? Send that woman to makeup!" Plus, character-wise, JJ's makeover makes little sense. Isn't she the one with a family? If someone should sex up, it's Prentiss, since she's the single one. As Homer Simpson would no doubt say, "Mmm... Hot Prentiss..." (Watch or re-watch #4.9, "52 Pickup", to see Hot Prentiss, if needed.)

There are other changes. The sickness level has been amped up, plausible reason being the success of the Saw franchise and the fact that the much more successful NCIS has been gorier from the start. It's all done gradually, of course, with the gore in, for example, "Hopeless" being there for just a few frames - not long enough to scare away the viewers not accustomed to sustained gore shots. Elsewhere, in "Reckoner" and this very episode, the gore is mostly implied or the aftermath (severed limbs or eyes) is shown. Nevertheless, the sickness level has risen. The thing is, on episodes like the sickeningly twisted "Cradle to Grave", the disgusting premise works in favor of the episode, whereas in "Reckoner" the plot justifies the gore, but in this episode it feels like it's there just for the shock value.

Finally, and most crucially of all, the level of writing seems finally to have stopped fluctuating, with all five episodes I've seen being at least 7/10 or better. No more 4/10s. Hopefully, this continues. It is also worth pointing out that the BAU no longer *seem* unerring - in the past 70 episodes I *remember* their Unsub profile to have erred *once*. Here, in "Hopless", the group is completely baffled by the Unsubs. It's *good* to see that the BAU are humans, who err.

This episode is no classic, but it's good, *solid*, riveting stuff with no elephant-sized plot holes or delusions of grandeur. There's nothing wrong with this being a 7/10. If this level is maintained, this would actually be the first season I'd like to own as a box set.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
How rude mggluver-69730
Reid won't be in the next 2 episodes? moviemania513
Uh oh! maceparkerfbi
It feels like season 12 will be the last marinersguy
what happened to the Gary Sinise led spin off? bezant76
JJ's second son dorkyqueen
Discuss The Eyes Have It (2009) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: