User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
This story seems to get better with time.
Sleepin_Dragon30 July 2015
I remember watching it during the original transmission and not being massively impressed with it, but after re-watching some years later i'd say it's actually a really good story, what seemed like a confusing plot is actually well conceived and intelligent.

The Turkish bad guys are a bit stereotypical, they perhaps didn't work too well, but are well acted.

The major disappointment here is the way that Stella's character exits I thought it was totally underwhelming, she had tough shoes to fill after Mel, and she did an amazing job, she deserved a more dramatic exit. Her scene with Grace however is touching.

the negatives apart, the story was very impressive, although I'm not sure the Catholic Church would have been overly impressed at how the Nuns of the 1960's were portrayed.

Trevor Eve's Boyd is even more obstinate and ignorant in this one, although I did enjoy the scene where he interviews Samuel Knight, you can see he's totally irritated by him.

Sharon Maughan does put in a fantastic performance, and in my humble opinion makes the episode. For the time that Lynda Rooke is on screen, she is great as the awful Sister Margaret.

Clever 8/10
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Builds o the previous Part One and delivers an outcome
hindsonevansmike22 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
If you ever want to see how a woman's face changes with makeup then without a scrap of makeup, Sharon Maughan provides an object lesson.

The Cold Case team do what they do well, tying the strands together (OK, suspend disbelief about poorly-kept samples having viable DNA after 40 years by - hey! it's TV Drama!).

The stereotype Turkish gangsters get their come-uppance (nice shooting!) and Boyd gets to deliver some stunning lines (in the category of "I wish that the police officer running an interrogation could say exactly that to a suspect").

A couple of hours of workable, enjoyable hokum which ties up all the loose ends and presents it with a bow.

I suspect that this 2009 episode was filmed with some knowledge of - but before the full horror was revealed about - the horrendous treatment of the victims (mainly pregnant teenagers) imprisoned in the nun-run Catholic "Magdelene Laundries" network within the Republic of Ireland.

Farewell Stella.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed