In one scene, a newspaper is seen with a headline containing the phrase "Serial Killer." While the film is set in 1849, the term "Serial Killer" did not exist until well into the 20th century. Various sources state that the term was coined in either the 1960s or 1970s.
Both Emily and Poe used the phrase, "Ok" several times. "Ok" in the 1800's was a colloquial phrase meaning "oll korrect" (all correct), not an indication of assent (as used by Emily) or reassurance (as used by Poe.)
At the end, Ivan says he is off to do the same to Jules Verne. However, in 1849, when the film is set, Verne had not published any writing and was absolutely un-heard of. Verne's first published work was 'Cinq Semaines en ballon' in 1863, 14 years after Poe's death. His first well, known work 'Voyage au centre de la Terre' was not published until 1864.
The dance that begins the ballroom scene is Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's "Waltz", from his "Children's Album", (Opus 39 no. 8). It is incorrectly identified as "No. 9" in the film's credits; and, (dating from 1878), it hadn't been written at the time of Poe's death.
Detective Fields reads 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue' story from the book 'Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque'. 'Grotesque and Arabesque' was published in 1840, one year before 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue' was first published.
The Baltimore City Police badges worn by the uniformed officers in the film were not issued until late 1851. Also, the revolvers in the opening scene look to be later (even if they were indeed 1847 Colt Walkers, this would be rare for a police dept. like Baltimore to have in 1849).
The pistol that is carried by Inspector Fields, and also by many of the Baltimore Police Officers, appears to be a Colt Navy, which was not introduced until 1851, two years after the movie takes place. Some people are saying the pistols being used are Walker Colts, which look similar, but if know what to look for you can tell that the pistols in the movie are not Walkers. The Walker Colt had a larger frame and a longer barrel then the Colt Navy. Also the most distinctive feature of the Colt Navy is its octagon shaped barrel, which the Walker Colt does not have. Plus it is unlikely that police officers of the time would be using Walker Colts since they were a very large, heavy pistol meant to be used as a cavalry pistol.
When Poe is punched in the face by Captain Hamilton, Poe slowly brings a handkerchief to his face. After a few seconds of screen time with Detective Fields and Captain Hamilton, Poe is once again shown raising the handkerchief to his face. It looked exactly as he had been doing it the first time (same motion as before, same blood position as before).
Edgar, after kicking over the table in order to hammer and claw at the floorboards to further gain access to stairs leading down into the room where Emily is buried, carries with him the oil lantern from upstairs to provide light to see in the dark basement, yet, on the table in the back of the room is an oil lantern already burning. How can this be if the room had been sealed off, and the floorboards had been hammered shut? Unless we are to believe the lantern was inadvertently left behind, and the room was sealed off shortly before Edgar's arrival, and the amount of time to consume the poison and write the story, took little time?
Poe is asked if he had written anything about a sailor, and responds "No." In truth, Poe had written quite a few stories about sailors, including "MS. Found in a Bottle," "A Descent into the Maelstrom," "The Murders in the Rue Morgue," and "The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym," among others (including "King Pest" and a brief sequence in "The Premature Burial").
In the opening scene of the movie, it says Edgar Allan Poe was found near death on a park bench in Baltimore, Maryland on October 7, 1849. However, it is known he was hospitalized days before on October 3, 1849, and did not die until the seventh of October.