IMDb > "Mad Men" Shut the Door. Have a Seat (2009) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
"Mad Men" Shut the Door. Have a Seat (2009)

« Prev | 39 of 92 Episodes | Next »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 7 reviews in total 

16 out of 18 people found the following review useful:

The start of a new change!

Author: Red_Identity from United States
8 November 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Mad Men's season three finale was a start of something new. The new direction in which these characters and their business is going will be very interesting, and it opens the doors for a lot of new story lines. However, this meant the end of the iconic Bertram-Cooper building. I will miss it's desks, it's offices, it's employees who will also probably not be coming back next season. But it is a new start for Don Draper's business, but what about his personal life? Well, this episode marked the end of Betty and Don's relationship. Their scenes together were the best, and perfectly acted. The scene when Don confronts Betty in the night in their bedroom was sad to watch, simply because of how misguided these characters are. But in the end, they resolved their grudges against each other, and it seemed that this season finale was optimistic. Here's hoping for another great season of Mad Men, seeing as how Season Three was no disappointment after the amazing Season Two.

Was the above review useful to you?

14 out of 18 people found the following review useful:

Great finish is a new beginning.

10/10
Author: zhanup from United States
9 November 2009

A business deal that makes your heart race is something, only the creators of Mad Men are capable of. Hilton deal future? Don's marriage? Will Betty tell Don about Henry? Will Peggy defect? Will Pete defect? What does the future of the ever so charming Joan hold? Tension between Roger and Don? Duck Phillips, an outsider at Sterling Cooper? And the biggest question is will the company be sold again or will they buy it back? If you are waiting for answers, then you are in for a treat. Its not just the answers you will love, but the how each answer is a start for something new!! You see almost every side of Don here. Angry at Hilton, loving and caring towards his children, Drunk, Some childhood scenes (as Dick), Sad sometimes, and best of all is his professional look. You will be left stunned by the turn of events in this episode and you will be left wanting for more.

Was the above review useful to you?

10 out of 12 people found the following review useful:

The Twilight Zone

10/10
Author: ladyisjazz from United States
9 November 2009

Those very black days between the assassination of JFK and the arrival of the sixties with the Beatles in February. Sally & Bobby are my little sister & brother, & I'm glued to the set with them. Incredible time machine. People still are trying to understand that time, or why it continues to define a generation who grew up practicing air raid drills under desks. Watching "On the Beach". being told during the Cuban missile crisis that if I knew how to pray, this was the time to pray. "Mad Men" is a great show but its appeal is more than the story line. Sally playing with the dry-cleaning bag and Betty warns that if her clothes are all over the floor, she'll be in trouble. If you didn't live it, you can see it 100% accurately in this excellent, riveting, fabulous show.

Was the above review useful to you?

8 out of 9 people found the following review useful:

Season 3: Another engaging and enjoyable season that makes for sturdy drama with a good comic edge

Author: bob the moo from United Kingdom
17 October 2010

Season 3 of Mad Men picks up where season 2 left off. Betty and Don are together thanks mainly to her pregnancy, while the other new arrival in Don's world of the British management is also having an impact. Unlike when I started season 2, I was looking forward to season 3 simply because I had enjoyed the second season more than the first having found it to be more engaging and interesting. Season 3 covers a lot of ground with the main characters and also the secondary tier ones and again I found it to be enjoyable and engaging stuff.

It perhaps engineers a bit too much stuff to happen but generally it has a good narrative flow to it at both the Agency level of the story and the personal level of the main characters. Don is the key to all of it and the season makes good use of his identity while also not playing all of the cards at any point. The stuff with Conrad Hilton didn't always work for me because it did seem to come out of nowhere, likewise some other aspects seemed to happen very quickly – the fate of the Englishman's foot was funny but I felt it robbed me of some interesting competition with Don within minutes of introducing it. The period is not ever really forced upon us as it was in season 1 but rather it is shown in changes in the characters and in their situations. OK we have MLK's speech and JFK's assassination within this season but both of them are best played out through the characters rather than being something done to set a period for the viewer.

Beyond Don the degree of narrative spread among the second tier of characters is better again and I didn't feel the show was all on the shoulders of one or two characters. Betty may have finished being our "fresh eyes" as she was in bits of season 1, but she remains an important character. Her time is limited but her role as a progressive woman is solid but yet not pushed down our throats to make a judgement or to have others make a judgement on her. Likewise Sal's preferences are nicely revealed and are "dealt with" in a manner that unfortunately suits the period, without overdoing it. This is the way the season plays out – with the narrative making good use of the "second tier" characters through, filling the show with more energy and allowing social observations to be made without them being too obviously inserted.

The direction continues to be good, as are sets and costumes – the whole thing looks very of the period throughout. The cast benefit again from having stronger (in my opinion) material than they did at the start. Hamm is still a strong lead but the cracks and pressures spreading across Don's life are well shown. As with season 2 Jones improves by having material to do more with. Moss has a little less to do but she is still an engaging character and her upward struggle is neither forced on us nor allowed to fade into the background and be forgotten. Below these everyone else plays their part well, having moments of focus and background across the season. Hendricks, Kartheiser, Slattery, Sommer, Morse, Batt, Gladis and many others all stick in the mind.

Overall season 3 of Mad Men continues the standard I felt it achieved in season 2 over the worthy but rather less engaging first season. The narrative threads all engaged me whether they were business or personal and I thought it did them in a good mix while also balancing comedy and drama well too. Season 4 is just finishing on the BBC at the moment and I'll watch my recordings of it once I've left a gap from season 3 – however 4 will be the last season freely available as Sky, as usual, has come in and done what they did with 24, by outbidding for the remaining seasons and putting them into a channel bundle that you have to subscribe to all of even if you only want to watch Mad Men for 12 weeks out of the year. Essentially Sky will be holding the established audience to ransom to watch the show for however many more seasons they do; and yet this is the same Corporation that complains about the growth of online piracy / file-sharing without a hint of irony or self-awareness about their part in encouraging it.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

Don collects what he's been sowing for so long

10/10
Author: ciffou from El Salvador
14 June 2010

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

I think this is one of the best season finales ever. It is amazing how the creators make the pace grow and make you feel engaged in the quest for a solution for the whole team.

It's amazing how everybody is expecting some sort of affection and/or appreciation from Don Draper (Dick W) and even though we may find him extreme and completely compelling, one can only accept that he has coming. His marriage has been on the rocks since forever and he has repeatedly cheated on his wife, Peggy has been there for him always (as he once did) but she doesn't see opportunities to grow under his shadow and of course, she is looking for a father figure, and the latter is the same situation for Pete Campbell who needs to hear some praise from him. He keeps on doing that throughout the whole episode after being rejected by Hilton. The most impressive thing for me is all that it is not said with words. I love how Peggy and Pete are going to "share a space" and I loved Peggy's face when Trudy came by the new place with the cake. What's going to happen with this 3?

My only complain is the casting: Maxwell Huckabee was weird to look as the Drapers' son but Jared Gilmore doesn't make his job any better and he's nothing like them...but of course we have to deal with that ourselves.

Anyway, they didn't need a plain crash, an earthquake, a wedding or a funeral, they built the momentum and just by letting us see their lives and their emotions, we are already hooked to see what's next for all the characters.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Hangover Part 2

10/10
Author: getyourdander from United States
29 May 2011

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This is an outstanding episode. As I get ready to watch Season 4 which is now out on DVD, I am wondering if it can keep pace with this season 3 ending. In fact, this one wraps a lot plot lines up but then opens a whole bunch of new ones.

I think of this one as a second part of the Mad Men hangover because this is set at the end of 1963, just after the JFK murder which was in the previous episode. Where the previous show had it's downs plus the occupation with the Dallas events perfect, this show goes beyond and brings us back up to a high never seen before in this series.

One great thing about this one is how the dry British wit is brought into this one. This humor in this episode is priceless. The amazing thing to me is how Don & Betts even though both are obviously mad at each other for different reasons, settle on a divorce they both can agree too. I have never seen this done in real life. She gets custody of their 3 kids but he will have visiting rights. This goes with the 1960's as back then the wife almost always got custody.

The only weak point but a point that I hope will be further explored is the business relationship between Draper & Olsen. There are some dynamics about their relationship developing though the conversation in this episode really just touches the surface.

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 10 people found the following review useful:

That was just about perfect

Author: toadwriter from United States
8 November 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

What a great episode. I loved the way it all came together and how everyone realized the importance of one-another.

The plan of attack and the way they chose to move forward was just great.

I loved when he said, I suppose gentlemen that you're all fired.

lol.

I don't know what else to say. I need to keep an eye out for encore's of that episode because I could watch it over and over. The Color Blue was another intriguing, captivating episode to look for.

gnite

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Plot synopsis Ratings
External reviews Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history