In an effort to move on with her relationship with Spencer, Teddy dates a boy who turns out to look exactly like him. Meanwhile, Bob and Gabe buy an extremely sophisticated couch, and PJ is struggling at cooking school.
When Teddy gets accepted into a college in New York City, she goes to New York, alongside P.J. P.J stays at a hot dog cart and gets back together with Skyler. Meanwhile Teddy misses her tour on the subway and meets up with Jessie and Zuri. When a blizzard traps Teddy and P.J in New York City, they decide to stay with Jessie and Zuri.