"The Metropolitan Opera HD Live" Opening Night Gala Starring Renée Fleming (TV Episode 2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Not so much a concert, more a coronation...
Gyran8 September 2009
Renée Fleming gets to appear in segments from three of her favourite operas in one evening. Well, if ever the post of Queen of England becomes vacant, she would certainly get my vote. The format is a bit like Readers' Digest condensed operas.The only thing that comes near to upstaging Queen Renée is the stage itself. Both Act II of La Traviata and Act III of Manon consist of two contrasting scenes so first we witness the effortless transformation of Violetta's country retreat into a Paris ballroom, then we see a Paris street scene transformed into the chapel of Saint-Suplice. The choice of repertoire gives ample scope to show off the Met's chorus and dancers as well as an array of guest principals.

The evening gets off to a slow start with a lacklustre performance of Zeffirelli's dated Traviata. Thomas Hampson is most to blame here as a wooden Germont. Things pick up with the Manon section. This is one of Renée Fleming's signature roles and she deliciously depicts the coquette who deserts Des Grieux only to seduce him again, years later, the night before his ordination, just because she can. I particularly liked the religious groupies discussing Des Grieux's sermon as if it were a pop concert. Ramon Vargos plays both Germont Fils and Des Grieux in these two excerpts.

After all this spectacle, the musical highlight of the evening is Renée Fleming's solo performance of the end of Strauss's Capriccio. Her rich voice is wonderfully suited to Strauss's soaring vocal line. She dispenses with the elaborate wigs of the previous two sections in favour of a more natural hairstyle and she wears a breathtaking costume by John Galliano. Long live Queen Renée.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Renee Fleming steals the show in three of her best and most favourite roles
TheLittleSongbird31 January 2012
I saw Opening Night Gala Starring Renee Fleming as a life-long fan of opera, someone who generally enjoys the productions and concerts from the Met and who likes Renee Fleming and her creamy voice. Opening Night Gala... is really a magical night, the music is sublime, it looks wonderful and while she is supported solidly by all involved Fleming is the one who steals the show in three of her best and most favourite roles, Violetta from Verdi's La Traviata, Manon from Massenet's Manon and the Countess from Richard Strauss' Capriccio. The telecast looks fantastic for starters. The costumes are sumptuous especially Fleming's black dress performing the final scene of Capriccio, and the settings are truly beautiful though Zeffirelli's Traviata set could be seen as dated, very reminiscent of the look of his 1982 film, one of my favourites just for the record. The High Definition is consistently very good, with clear sound and picture quality and the camera work doing everybody and everything favours.

Susan Graham and Deborah Voight host with interest and clarity, while I cannot fault Opening Night Gala... musically. The orchestra are superb throughout, I think they are at their best during Capriccio. The chorus are excellent in Act 2 Scene 2 of La Traviata, and the staging likewise with the most impressive being in the Cours-La-Raine scene from Manon, which is nothing short of spectacular. The three conductors, James Levine, Marco Armiliato and Patrick Summers keep things afloat. Armiliato's conducting for Manon is for me the most consistent, and Levine with Traviata keeps things brisk but the surprise was Summers for Capriccio, I found with his reading of the Met production of Madama Butterfly that his conducting should've had more subtlety, subtlety here there is which is perfect for the long phrasing and soaring melodic lines that are so typical of Strauss.

Opening Night Gala... starts off with two scenes from act 2 of La Traviata, my personal favourite overall of the operas featured. Zeffirelli makes a seamless transition from Violetta's country house to the Parisian mansion, and while the production may look slightly dated it still has a very sumptuous look to it. Fleming looks lovely in her two costumes, and this is the perfect act from the opera to show off her creamy voice and sincere acting. The support cast are good too. Ramon Vargas is dashing and very believable as Alfredo, though Thomas Hampson isn't quite so good as Germont. His singing is very good with a nice timbre and good musicality and phrasing, perhaps the Verdi baritone role that suits his voice the most, but his acting is wooden with not much of the stern and sympathetic quality of the role coming through.

Next are two scenes from Act 3 of Massenet's Manon, as much as I love Puccini's Manon Lescaut I find Massenet's more plausible in terms of the story. The better of the two is the Cours-La-Raine scene, which is spectacular both in music and performance. It also features Fleming's wonderful and agile rendition of Manon's Gavotte. This said, the intense and dramatic in a searing sense St Sulpice scene is every bit as great. The costume and set designs are a little better than that of the Traviata segment, still sumptuous but more up to date without meaning contemporary. Fleming is superb in one of her signature roles, it is a moving performance and the singing is beautiful and musical. Vargas assumes the role of Des Grieux and he sings with ringing tone and he is ardent. Dwayne Croft is an amusing and nuanced Lescaut, and while his singing is not as powerful as it once was Robert Lloyd makes for a sympathetic Comte Des Grieux.

Finishing the telecast is the final scene of Capriccio, and while I did really liked Traviata and loved Manon, the Capriccio segment was in the best of the three. It looks beautiful, and Strauss' transcendent music is performed in a controlled and subtle manner. Fleming takes centre stage and this is one of my favourite ever performances of hers. She looks stunning in her best costume of the telecast where she is clad entirely in black, and her voice positively soars above the orchestra, which is exactly what should happen singing Strauss. Overall, while looking beautiful, as good the support cast is and as magnificent the music is, Opening Night Gala Starring Renee Fleming is Fleming's show. She really throws herself into all three roles and as always sings absolutely beautifully. The telecast itself is a must see and is almost perfect. 9/10 Bethany Cox
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed