IMDb on iPhone and iPod touch Learn more Learn more Download from the App Store
IMDb > "The Mentalist" Carnelian, Inc. (2009)
Prev | 17 of 36 Episodes | Next

"The Mentalist" Carnelian, Inc. (2009)


Photos (see all 4 | slideshow)

Overview

User Rating:
8.1/10   91 votes
Director:
Writers:
Bruno Heller (creator)
Bruno Heller (written by)
Contact:
View company contact information for Carnelian, Inc. on IMDbPro.
Original Air Date:
24 March 2009 (Season 1, Episode 17)
Genre:
Plot:
The Attorney General receives some strange email, CBI is ordered to investigate. They're soon investigating a high profile murder that involves a company's executive board. full summary | full synopsis
User Reviews:
Now this is more like it! (Than the previous one.) more (1 total)

Cast

  (Episode Cast overview, first billed only)

Simon Baker ... Patrick Jane

Robin Tunney ... Teresa Lisbon
Tim Kang ... Kimball Cho
Owain Yeoman ... Wayne Rigsby

Amanda Righetti ... Grace Van Pelt
Susan Chuang ... Joyce Tran

Myndy Crist ... Jessie Skelling

Rodney Eastman ... Lee Skelling

Patrick Fabian ... Rand Faulk

Scott Klace ... Mike Spruell
Scott Lawrence ... De Shaun Braemer

Adam Lieberman ... Bomb Squad Officer

Peter Mackenzie ... Holman Perry

Jaime Murray ... Nadia Sobell

Muse Watson ... Jake Cooby
more
Create a character page for: ?

Additional Details

Runtime:
Germany:41 min
Country:
Language:
Color:
Certification:

Fun Stuff

Quotes:
Teresa Lisbon: Like you don't know you have major trust issues.
Patrick Jane: I trust people. I trust you.
Teresa Lisbon: No you don't. I don't trust you either.
more

FAQ

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Now this is more like it! (Than the previous one.), 24 December 2009
8/10
Author: ttapola from Finland

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

After the mess that was the previous episode, comes one written by Bruno Heller himself. And the difference is remarkable. From the *brilliant* teaser (Who saw *that* coming? You're lying!) almost right to the end, this episode beats the previous one with one hand tied behind its back.

First of all: no illogical plot twists (only one slightly implausible, more on that later). Second: no handy "coincidences". Third: no characters stupid as rocks (only one of inconsistent intelligence, more on that also later). Then there are those brilliant character moments: Jane "throwing 'a blind cat' into the group" is hilarious as is him admitting that he just likes to know that he's right, being the smug bastard that he is. And that's why we love him. And then we are shown that even he can't figure everything out - at least not immediately. All this makes him more human.

Unfortunately this cannot be said of certain other characters. Faulk is a 2-dimensional character (there is *no* such thing as "1-dimensional character" as anything 1-dimensional is a straight line, whereas those industry-famous cardboard characters are 2-dimensional): he is a stereotypical profit-driven corporate head - he even has a sexual relationship with one of his underlings (pun intended).

Then there are the characters of Van Pelt and Rigsby. After what happened between them in the previous episode, it feels like a cop-out that they are conveniently separated in this episode, even if it is just an honest coincidence resulting from episodes not airing in the order they were shot (or written, for that matter). This kind of apparent Reset-Button Use brings back painful memories of all those old episodic TV shows where nothing that happened mattered in the next episode.

These and one last thing make me give this one "only" 8/10. Now who hasn't seen the "I'll expose the bomb-maker by forcing him to disarm his own bomb that is now harmless, just in case I'm wrong" plot device? That's another cliché that should have been left in the 1900s. Hasn't Faulk ever seen that ruse used in fiction? His own plot is ingenious, yet he is stupid enough to fall into Jane's trap. Sorry, not buying that.

Was the above review useful to you?
more (1 total)

Message Boards

Discuss this movie with other users on IMDb message board for "The Mentalist" (2008)

Related Links

Main series Episode guide Full cast and crew
Company credits IMDb TV section IMDb Crime section
IMDb USA section Add this title to MyMovies

You may report errors and omissions on this page to the IMDb database managers. They will be examined and if approved will be included in a future update. Clicking the 'Update' button will take you through a step-by-step process.