"Les petits meurtres d'Agatha Christie" Les meurtres ABC (TV Episode 2009) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The ABC Murders
TheLittleSongbird2 January 2019
Have been a huge fan of Agatha Christie for a very long time. Love her twisty mysteries, rich characterisation, meticulous atmosphere, her intelligent use of prose and ingenious final solutions. Her work has mostly been adapted well, the obvious examples being the best of the Joan Hickson Miss Marple and David Suchet Poirot adaptations. 'Les Petits Meutres D'Agatha Christie' is a French series that adapted loosely Christie's work and is essentially Agatha Christie with a French light comedy twist and a "spoonful of French flair". On its own terms it is fascinating and charming light-hearted entertainment with intriguing stories.

Something that is evident in this first episode "Les Meurtres ABC". While not mind-blowing, it sets up the series' tone very well and is a very interesting episode. Although one of the most faithful (parts remarkably very faithful) adaptations of 'Les Petits Meurtres D'Agatha Christie', "Les Meurtes ABC" uses one of Christie's most cleverly plotted works, featuring an ingenious final solution and one of her most memorable characters in Cust, as a framework and fares quite well. Some may question the point of it, but it was interesting to see something different and a worthy, if inferior, companion to the superb David Suchet adaptation (still one of the best of that series).

The pacing in "Les Meurtres ABC" could have been more consistent, parts drag a little. With more tension in some of the storytelling, with a little more freshness put into a few of the red herrings and tighter direction, this would already have been improved.

Likewise with some of the more comedic elements, could have calmed down more and been more subtle.

However, "Les Meurtres ABC" looks lovely, the period detail and scenery are lavish but a great job is also done evoking a sinister enough atmosphere when necessary. The vibrant but never over-saturated or garish colours, that could be quite atmospheric, and stylish photography complement beautifully. The music matches the light-hearted and at times very atmospheric tone very well. On the most part, the writing is thoughtful and intriguing with the right amount of entertainment value. As said, some of it needed to calm down but didn't feel much staleness here. The mystery is still clever and very sophisticated with some nice suspense, the denouement still ingenious even with some playing around but in a way that was fresh and still respectful. Furthermore, there are plenty of twists and turns to keep one on their toes and guessing. Any brutality is not overused, abused and gratuitous.

Mostly like the characterisation, with some interesting supporting characters, especially the suitably mysterious Custe, and a well matched and fascinating pairing in Larosiere and Lampion, it is only the first episode and it has already very well settled. Larosiere is the richer character and is very interesting here in "Les Meurtres ABC", thanks to some suspenseful conflict, but part of me endears to and roots for Lampion more. The direction is competent throughout and cannot fault the acting, Antoine Dulery and Marius Colucci being the standouts. Denis Lavant is very well cast as Custe, bringing a sinister touch to this memorable character.

On the whole, definitely well worth watching. 7/10 Bethany Cox
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Both faithful and surprising....but also a bit pedestrian
gridoon20242 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
The first episode of the French series "Les petits meurtres d'Agatha Christie" is a quite faithful adaptation of one of Christie's most clever and acclaimed novels, "The ABC Murders". It's so faithful for the most part, in fact, that it made me wonder about the necessity of yet another screen version of this story, after an episode of the David Suchet "Poirot" series AND the forgotten sixties spoof "The Alphabet Murders". For anyone who knows the story, the big red herring at the center of it will be just that - a big red herring. Luckily, the screenwriters have played around a little bit with the identity of the real culprit(s), giving the film a couple of welcome surprises at the end. But the direction is a little pedestrian, and the two lead detectives, Larosière and Lampion, are not quite as engaging as the pair they're standing in for, Poirot and Hastings, though they may grow on me on subsequent episodes. **1/2 out of 4.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Christie for the masses.
stuka242 June 2010
How can one fail yet another Christie Adaptations? They are always perfectly made, acted, the production tricks you into believing you woke up at that time, people are gorgeous, and yes, you feel a bit silly in the end, but only to recognize Agatha's mastery hasn't aged a bit.

This TV series doesn't respect the time-honoured formula. Sharing part of the stellar cast of "Petits meurtres en famille" (2006), it indulges in the same idiosyncrasies. Basically, by "adapting" the plot to the XXI century's sensibilities, making Poirot more "humane", Lampion gay, and basically altering the plot so much yes, it's still Christie, the murderer is the same but... the essence is gone. Larosière is well cast, big husky voice, screen presence, but he's made to act foolish scenes, like when he's drunk or chasing women (very much unlike him :)). Lampion is a bit of a teenager and clumsy to my taste, like if it were an Eddie Murphy buddy cop film. André Custe, the main character, is really perfect, he's what has to be. A soul in pain. Chloé Stefani's Lili Daste, from "Jeanne Poisson, Marquise de Pompadour", is too nice for Custe, but well, we can assume she was chosen like that for counter balancing all the hideousness and making sure we empathized a bit with him. Mme Daste is fun in her small character of the grouchy uncouth mum :). Duval's brazenness and bravado come off naturally. The well known Jean-François Garreaud, from many TV series like "Plus belle la vie" and also acting in "Jeanne Poisson", is there for a reason, although his character is rather silent. And yes, Sophie is beautiful. The rest of the cast is fine, and it's interesting to see how crime investigations were not so far in the past, before CSI and the like made us forget.

Can be missed without loosing much. Maybe the beautiful scenery, which really looks like if time hadn't passed, and Christie were still Christie :).
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed