"CSI: NY" The Box (TV Episode 2008) Poster

(TV Series)

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Officially one of my favorite episodes...
cmc479427 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I don't really watch any show every week in a row, but CSI:NY is one that I think is interesting and funny while dealing with serious subject matter. I particularly enjoy when they lead a little bit into the personal lives of the CSIs. However, most of the time, the teasers for the episodes are cliché and typical. So, I usually don't expect much unless the teaser gets me hooked.

I'll admit, it was a cheap trick for the teaser to have Lindsay say "I'm pregnant," because the episode, to me, was much deeper than that. Basically, I was waiting through every commercial break to see what was going to happen with Lindsay Monroe and Danny Messer. It showed the internal struggle of Danny's character, how this entire ordeal sent him into a whirlpool of emotions.

The camera deliberately panned to show him expressing his anxiety. For example, he cups his hands a lot. Danny also stares at a picture of the growing baby in various areas of the episode. This was a very beautiful way to convey such emotion, in my opinion.

Overall, the murder subplot wasn't as strong as it could've been, and I still can't figure out how a baby could've lived after being cut messily from its dead mother's stomach. I was thoroughly creeped out. Plus, the baby did not look like it was only a few weeks old, which also bothered me. Ah, technicalities, technicalities! One thing I did like was that Anna Belknap, who plays Lindsay, is visibly pregnant. It was a nice change from those stick thin girls who say their pregnant and then all you can do is assume that the baby is the size of a peanut...

Anyway, at the end of the episode, Danny is riding on his motorcycle (which was a really cool shot, plus the music in the background was amazing for the scene). You can see how troubled he is in his expression. Will he assume responsibility for his unborn child? If so, will he be a good father? The viewer can tell that these things are running through his mind.

To me, the defining parts of the episode are that he actually cares about Lindsay, shown by his concern for what is going on with her, why she won't talk to him, why she's at the doctor, etc.

But, my absolute favorite part of the episode was the very end. You see that Danny is unloading his anxiety and nervousness on the parents of the victim while they are waiting for Child Services. The mother asks him:"What happens now?" (or something like that) and Danny answers "I don't know." (What a great actor!) Then Stella, Lindsay, and Flack (or either it was Adam, I wasn't paying attention) show up with the baby in tote. Lindsay hands them the baby, then the parents, knowing who she is now that Danny has told them all about her, wish her and Danny luck. Lindsay looks a little dumbstruck, like "What's going on?" You see the grandparents cuddling the baby, then Danny and Lindsay stand next to one another. Their hands are by their sides; the camera focuses on their hands, so ready to touch, to say "Everything is going to be okay." You can tell that they just want to hold each others hand. It was such a sweet, genuine, heartfelt shot.

Then the credits roll. And I'm left feeling "Wow." Because I know that Danny cares.

It was the deepest, most meaningful episode I've watched yet.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A second chance needs to be earned
brueggemanntami20 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I don't think the parents who kicked their teenage daughter out for getting pregnant and had no contact with her during that most difficult time period earned a free pass into their grandson's life. There had better be a lot of counseling going on in this situation. Social Services should be involved and keep a close eye on them. They failed their own child when she needed them the most.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Crushing Blow To A Few People
ccthemovieman-128 January 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Here's another original story; a corpse being found inside a crushed car at the junkyard. What's more, the dead body, which had been there about three weeks, had contained a baby at one point, but where was it? I was sorry to see IMDb here say in the storyline about "shocking news about Lyndsay," because it gave it away. It wasn't divulged until the last part of the show. At the start of the show, we see a distraught Danny telling unknown people in an unknown place about his history and it's very dramatic. Something else has just happened that could alter his life (Lyndsay being pregnant) but we don't know that until much later and then we also find out who Danny was talking to.

Whatever, the show focuses more on the crime. Who killed the young woman in the car and what happened to her baby? That's the main story. In the storyline we see parents who are unforgiving and we see a nasty "health care worker" who was in on the crime along with a woman who is too desperate in her search to have a baby.

In all, kind of soap opera-type story which is not the usual for CSI-NY but it was still interesting and Carmine Giovinazzo is great as always as "Danny Messer." I've always thought he was the best character on this show.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed