The gang admit to Robin that they have never watched her on "Come On, Wake Up New York". So they agree that they will all go over to Marshall and Lily's on Friday, get dressed in their pajamas, and watch the show together. Marshall and Barney have polar opposite views on what constitutes appropriate bedtime attire. By the end of the night, one will have converted the other. Meanwhile, Ted's newest relationship with his old girlfriend Karen - who Marshall and Lily in particular hate - has just ended when Karen found one of Robin's earrings in Ted's bed, despite Ted vowing to her that he knows nothing about how it got there. When Ted finds the other earring in Marshall and Lily's bedroom, Lily confesses that she is the one who placed the earring in Ted's bed, thus orchestrating the break-up with Karen. Ted's anger with Lily increases when Lily admits that she has orchestrated more than one of his break-ups, she doing so whenever the girlfriend in question didn't meet what Lily calls her... Written by
Did You Know?
Alyson Hannigan is wearing a robe in this episode to cover her pregnancy. See more
And I realized maybe it doesn't matter what my friends think of my girlfriend, but it sure as hell matters what my girlfriend thinks of my friends.
Wow. So you ended it?
Yeah. So if you wanna be my plus one, Lily's a damn good cook.
[they walk over to the dinner table Lily set up for Ted and Karen
Mm. Beef pot pie, mac and cheese, homemade buttermilk biscuits...
Well. No wonder why Marshall dies at 68.
Spoofs A Few Good Men
The Man in Me
Written by Bob Dylan
Performed by Bob Dylan See more