13 user 9 critic

Into Temptation (2009)

R | | Drama | 26 April 2009 (USA)
A prostitute plans to end her life on her birthday, but her priest attempts to stop her from doing so.




Watch Now

From $2.99 (SD) on Amazon Video

1 win. See more awards »


Cast overview, first billed only:
Father John Buerlein
Fr. Ralph O'Brien
Lloyd Montag
Amy Matthews ...
Nadine Brennan
Tony Papenfuss ...
Greta Oglesby ...
Ansa Akyea ...
James St. Clair
Isabell O'Connor ...
Tessie Thomas (as Isabell Monk O'Connor)
Steven Miller
Corrine Buerlein
Lola Lesheim ...
Gene Larche ...
Marion Markham ...
Ann Milligan ...


A call girl goes to a priest to confess a sin she hasn't committed yet: she plans to kill herself on her next birthday. Then she disappears and he goes looking for her, enlisting the help of an ad hoc congregation of troubled souls along the way. A story about forgiveness. Written by Anonymous

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Plot Keywords:

catholic priest | See All (1) »



Motion Picture Rating (MPAA)

Rated R for language and some sexual content

Parents Guide:



Official Sites:



Release Date:

26 April 2009 (USA)  »

Filming Locations:


Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs

See  »

Did You Know?


There are two slightly different versions of the Lord's Prayer. The "Catholic version" has some different wording and a different ending than the "Protestant version". In the scene where Fr. Brulein is saying mass, he and the congregation recite the "Protestant version" and not the "Catholic version". See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Sisto is terrific in a strained movie with religious overtones and undertones
17 October 2010 | by (United States) – See all my reviews

Into Temptation (2009)

This is a religious film, really, in street clothes. And in the end it's about how being good is really good.

It's also a lesson in how you have to bend the rules to actually do the right thing--even if you fail. And that sometimes you do the right thing and succeed--without even knowing it.

Clearly a low budget movie, and a fairly simple one, in filmmaking terms (the sets, the light, the presence of the camera, the side characterizations, and the music, all these key elements, are unremarkable). But the plot itself, with its twists, is enough to make you at least curious. Yes, you wonder why it has to go tawdry at times, why there has to be some sexed up stuff for the viewer (it doesn't advance the plot, in the one egregious case). And there is a tidy solution to the central problem that will seem cheap to nonbelievers and magical to believers.

Most of all is a great performance by the lead, the priest, played by Jeremy Sisto. I knew him best from his role as Billy in Six Feet Under, and loved him there, and he is if anything more subtle and interesting (if less outrageous) here. It's a careful, felt performance in a movie that should have supported him better. Other aspects may jump out. His ex-girlfriend, whatever her role, is utterly believable, as much as the prostitute in question is not. The other priest is a caricature who overplays his part but has some great dialog with Sisto. There is the key flashback, which adds yet another layer of meaning, of cause and effect, and though it moved me somehow, I felt manipulated by it, and it was another case where the movie showed its seams.

So it may try too hard and strain within its resources (and with the director's reach--he has one other film to his credit, and famous as the voice in a Hamburger Helper t.v. ad), but it has moments that are right on. With Sisto's help. For those inclined toward religious sentimentality.

10 of 14 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: