"Gilligan's Island" Mine Hero (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Gilligan catches something ironic for dinner.
Ralphkram30 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Here is another formulaic, by-the-numbers second season episode where you have to suspend disbelief all the way through. It has no great surprises or twists, but at least it's fast paced and contains some genuine laughs.

The cold open starts with the overly familiar scene of Gilligan fishing something valuable out of the lagoon. Disbelief is shortly suspended as our scrawny lead is somehow able to single-handedly haul a giant iron mine that weighs a ton or two onto the beach. In his haste to tell the others, he carelessly leaves his fishing pole beside it, and the pole falls and activates the mine.

As usual, no one listens to Gilligan. The Skipper humorously orders him to fillet whatever he caught. Opportunistic Mr. Howell also misunderstands and, in a faint echo of The Big Gold Strike, makes Gilligan his (very) silent partner and swears him to secrecy. But Gilligan can't keep his mouth shut, and the men hit the beach to investigate his find.

To their horror, they discover that the mine is ticking. In a nice gag to close out the first act, the others scramble up the beach and leave our lead plastered to the sand.

The Professor warns that if the mine detonates, the gaseous fumes from the caves underneath the island would cause it to explode. The girls, who've done little up to this point, are shuttled over to the other side of the island to wait things out.

The ridiculous meter then gets dialed up all the way to eleven.

Suspension of disbelief really gets stretched in the next series of goofy scenes. The mine remembers it's magnetic by zapping Gilligan and Mr. Howell by their lucky charm and watch, respectively. The Professor gets them loose by pointing the transistor radio at them and hitting them with high frequency waves. His plan to place an SOS message on a raft involves a metal rudder. No problem. The castaways have enough metal odds and ends just lying around the island to fashion one. Lastly, in a gag as old as the hills, Gilligan tries to deactivate the mine with his head.

The one scene that does work amid this mishmash is when our lead outwits Ginger, who tries to seduce him out of his metal charm and fails.

Out of options, the Professor and Skipper conclude one of them has to tow the mine out to sea in a heroic sacrifice. They still can't decide who should sacrifice himself any more than they could in Hi Fi Gilligan, so they plan to cut cards to see who'll do the towing. Gilligan inserts himself into the drama when he overhears their plan and takes matters in to his own hands. As usual, any tension is undercut by more cartoonish slapstick, sped-up camera work, and overly cute musical beats.

In the overly cute epilogue, Gilligan loses his mine but gains a plastic swordfish.

COCONOTES:

The Howells have a badmitton net and shuttlecocks in this one, which go the way of their pool table, barbeque pit, roulette wheel, palm-frond fan, et al.

Jim Backus keeps this episode afloat. Love his competitiveness in the badmitton match and his line to the Professor about insurance.

Mary Ann does little in this one other than collect metal. Her outfit when she visits Gilligan is what dreams are made of, however.

Why on earth did Gilligan take the wheels to his skateboard with him on a three hour tour? Hmm? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
WHEN ALL ELSE FAILS, ASK THE PROFESSOR.
tcchelsey2 July 2023
Another "poetic license" episode, also dependent on the professor for first hand knowledge. Of course. The professor has been gathering pieces of metal on the island to make an anchor --which attracts a very real WWII mine. The mine just floats into the lagoon, and naturally Gilligan has his hands all over it, or its all over him.

This is also another "family show", cast only (no guest stars), all going nuts and asking the professor for help. There's a fun scene where Gilligan's silver neck chain and Mr. Howell's gold watch drag and attach both of them to the mine. Naturally, the professor's scientific deductions are always welcome and fun to listen to. To note, this episode is not that far from the truth as WWII mines --to this day-- are still being located and deactivated. They are a dangerous bunch.

Just plain goofy stuff, and Gilligan is the whole show, toss in some neat one liners. For all those who nitpick at this episode, I think they're missing the point. This is all fluff and campy stuff we grew up on, and still loving it. I took off one star ONLY because there's no guest star, but overall it's good with lots of memories. And the remastered color is fabulous. GILLIGANS ISLAND may be one of the best restored shows from the 60s, as color generally fades and shows its age. Another prime example are the color SUPERMAN episodes from the 50s, beautifully remastered.

SEASON 2 dvd box set.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mine shafted
kevinolzak18 June 2016
A throwback to the seriousness of the first season, "Mine Hero" begins with Gilligan reeling in a WW2 mine that remains active, and can explode at any time. Mr. Howell naturally assumes that Gilligan's mine is gold or diamonds, only to be disappointed by what he calls an 'overgrown pin cushion.' The Professor has been gathering metal to make an anchor for a raft intended to enter the shipping lanes, which the magnetized mine follows out of the lagoon. When the Skipper again advises Gilligan to catch something big for dinner, the mine's unexpected return accomplishes just that. Not as good as it could have been, but still amusing.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Mine Disaster, that's for sure...
kmcelhaney0054 April 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Gilligan manages to catch more than he bargained for when he pulls a World War II mine up from the lagoon while fishing. After some misconceptions, the others discover the mine and try to disarm it. However, Gilligan naturally fouls it all up and then heroically decides to get rid of the mine himself...or does he.

Highlights include the Skipper restraining himself after hitting his thumb with the hammer, the design of the mine itself which is quite impressive, so kudos to the props department on that one, Mrs. Howell beating Mr. Howell at badminton and letting him know it, the Howells discussing the "iron mine" with Gilligan, Gilligan getting his lucky charm back from Ginger, the men running over Gilligan to get away from the mine, Mr. Howell explaining the insurance options for the Professor, and Gilligan towing the mine out into the lagoon.

Another middling episode that doesn't get much farther than it's idea, what if Gilligan brought a WW2 mine ashore. While there are a few laughs and some nice sight gags, the whole episode feels stretched as if they had 10 minutes of ideas and packed in about 15 minutes of filler.

Tidbits & Trivia

  • We start the episode at the lagoon and the large rock formation last seen in "The Chain of Command" has made a return. Those rocks sure do get around.


  • The buoyancy of the mine is not consistent. When Gilligan first pulls it from the lagoon, it's almost fully underwater with some seaweed on it. Later, when it goes back into the lagoon it's almost too buoyant, floating up really high on water.


  • I know one thing, I want some of Gilligan's fishing line that enabled him to pull a mine weighing hundreds of pounds. Of course, just how did skinny Gilligan manage to pull the mine up onto the beach, anyway? - When the Skipper is explaining to Gilligan that he should fillet whatever it is he caught, he's clearly hold a rope that is trying to pass for a vine.


  • You know, the Professor's idea of a floating SOS in the shipping lanes is a good one. Strange he dropped the idea after this episode. Still, with so little metal on the island it would seem that rocks would be a better solution to act as the anchor.


  • Mr. Howell's statement, "Your serve, Pancho" to Mrs. Howell is probably a reference to Pancho Gonzales, one of the greatest tennis players of any era who dominated the sport for most of the 1950s and early 1960s.


  • Mary Ann's jewelry box is the "Jewel" cracker box which made its debut in the 1st season episode, "New Neighbor Sam".


  • The Professor's idea to short circuit the magnetism is just plain goofy as the radio doesn't broadcast, it only receives.


  • So, if they were so short of metal, why is there a metal rudder on the raft?
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed