The Boys from Baghdad High (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
How to smile and laugh in the face of violence
larry-41110 May 2008
Four high school students are handed digital cameras with which they will record their senior year of high school. This documentary sounds pretty familiar, on the face of it. It's been done many times before. The twist here is that the high school is in Baghdad, one of the most violent and war-ravaged cities in the world, and the four (all boys) would appear to be enemies to the outside world -- they and their classmates are Muslims, Christians, Sunnis, Shiites, and Kurds. What they have in common, though, is that they are all teenagers, and we know where this is going right from the start -- the message here is that kids are the same all over the world.

The premise of "Baghdad High" is not a novel idea by any means. In fact, I saw two similar films at the previous festival I attended. The challenge here is to make it work in an original way, not just to pick four cool kids who can make the viewer laugh and cry, but to touch the heart by showing the adult world just how immune "ordinary" teens can be in the face of war. They have the same desires, hopes, and dreams as high school kids everywhere -- they just want to get good grades and have fun. The difference here is that they might be blown up by a roadside bomb on the way home from school.

One of the biggest surprises of "Baghdad High" is that the boys are more curiously endearing and their friendships much sweeter than similar documentaries shot in U.S. high schools. Their displays of affection for each other and absence of talk about girls and sex is probably a bit more accurate than what American teenage boys would like others to believe about themselves, especially when cameras are pointed at them. There is little of the typical bravado and macho posturing we see with teens in America.

Another surprise is how little discussion of politics takes place in these homes (or in the film itself). Even then, the kids never mention it at all. When the subject is brought up, it's the parents who are asked how they feel about the U.S. presence there. With a shrug, they actually blame both governments. They don't even take sides. They just want the violence to end.
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Excellent behind-the-scenes look at Iraqi high school students
Turfseer4 May 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this the other day at the Tribeca Film Festival. It's scheduled to be on HBO in August. The directors found the headmaster of a high school in Baghdad who aided them in selecting four students who were given video cameras and then asked to chronicle their lives during the school year. As it turned out, the students were of different tribal affiliations: Kurdish, Sunni, Christian and Shite/Sunni. The real star of the film is Mohammed Rael and his mother. Half of the footage focuses on Mohammed and his family. The kid is a natural born actor and has a great sense of humour. A professional cinematographer was employed to shoot some of the non-family scenes, mainly at the high school. The documentary is a fascinating glimpse of what it's like being a teenager in Baghdad. During the evening, people don't go out much because of constant gunfire. At one point during the film, one of the kids, "Ali", leaves Baghdad with his family and moves to a Kurdish city which is much quieter. The contrast between the two cities is quite illuminating. When Sadaam Hussein is executed, two of the kids have quite different reactions. Mohammed (and his mother) talk about how some of their relatives met a cruel fate at the hands of Sadaam; but the Sunni kid is offended that a man of Sadaam's 'stature', should be put to death in such an offensive, public spectacle. At a few points during the documentary, the editing could have been a little tighter and the action seems to slow down. For the most part, however, 'Baghdad High' is a highly entertaining and riveting look at a different culture told through the eyes of a group of Baghdad High School students with a lot of potential.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Important!!!!!!!
Christopher-Peznola16 August 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I am really just one of those spoiled North Americans who loves to sit and watch movies. This documentary definitely woke me up from my over-fed, happy life. The importance of documentaries like this cannot be calculated. These 4 terrific kids from Baghdad could just as easily have been one of my nephews. Complicated, smart, but incredibly sweet teenagers trying to get through High School, without being killed, or having someone they love killed.

This film helps more in allowing westerners to identify with people from Iraq than any other documentary I have seen so far. There is something about the honesty of kids that really drives home the ideal that we are all, pretty much, the same. We may pray to a different god, speak a different language, but we all are trying hard to get through life (graduate from high school), have a girlfriend, make our families happy, and generally laugh.

>>>>Potential Spoiler>>>>>>>>>>>> I thought Mohammad was amazing, what a great kid, honest, with a big smile, and a sincere love of film. The end where he apologizes for boring us, and complains that he won't be able to use the camera, nearly made me weep. I want to send this kid a camera.

Please watch this documentary. It's not complicated, nor is it a masterpiece, but it's incredibly important.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Illuminating
luckydan9910 August 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this for the first time on HBO this morning. This documentary is a great window into the life of Iraqi kids and family. They try to go on with their life, even with the threat of death everyday. Even going to school every morning is a chance they have to take. While watching the program, I contrasted what it was like for me in my Senior year of high school. It seemed every night when the boys were trying to study, the power would be cut off, or they had to endure nearby shooting.

The star of the show is Mohammed. I don't know anybody who would not like this kid to be their brother or son. He is so full of life and is so caring. Even to the point of crying when he adoptive 'pet' mouse is killed, or concern of the lack of his own facial hair compared to that of his friends. Scenes like those remind you that people are people, no matter where they are. Kids like to have fun, and are worried about many of the same things that other kids worry about. But these kids have to worry about so much more.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed