Tia's supposed to interview the star dancer of a dance company about maleficence in the company. When she goes there, she's gone and her room is wrecked. She goes to Toby and tells him about her disappearance. Becker is not exactly willing to investigate but they find signs of a struggle in the room. They talk to her husband who is the company's artistic director and Toby senses he's having an affair and is abusive to his wife.
At a magic club, a magician who is performing asks a member of the audience to come on stage and help him with his next trick. But something goes wrong and the man is killed. The team is sent to investigate because the man who was killed is a multi millionaire and part owner of the club. When they examine the apparatus that was used in the trick, they see it was tampered with. So they try to find out who wanted the man dead. And Becker learns about Toby's ability.
Dev learns that an old friend who is a game designer was killed. So the team investigates. When talking to his people, they say he was a good guy but Toby senses that they are keeping things. Like he was having a disagreement with some associates and he was having an affair.
Becker wants Toby to help him prove that a man who is running for mayor, killed a woman who worked on his last campaign. She went missing and her body was never found. Everyone thinks Becker is obsessed because the man is supposedly an honest man. They talk to the girl's friend who said on the day she went missing it seems like she had something on her mind and may have had something to do with the man. Toby confronts the man who said he was at home and his wife confirms it which Toby saw which doesn't make Becker happy. But they get some other leads that they pursue.
The father of a girl Oz likes is killed. He asks Toby to look into it. They check the man out and find out, he's a fugitive. It seems like he and a couple of other guys hijacked a plane and made of with millions of dollars of valuable coins. His daughter is unaware of his past. They think one of his partners may have been looking for him because he is the one who has the coins.
When a member of a wealthy and affluent family is killed, the team investigates. Toby talks to one of staff who says the man had a visitor, a girl. while he was unaware what they were talking about but Toby sees her and gives a description of the girl and they find her. When they question her, she denies knowing him or being at his place. And when Toby reads her he sees no signs that she's lying. He wonders why is that. But more evidence turns up that leads them to her. And Tia wants to know about Toby's past even though he doesn't want to.
A criminal is on trial and Becker is elated that they finally got him. But Michelle reminds him that this isn't the first time they thought they got him but he always seems to get off. And a man comes forth claiming to be the actual killer. Becker thinks the criminal somehow made the man come forth and confess. While he and Michelle try to find out how the criminal got him to come forth and confess, Toby is sent to the prison where the man to find out. And Toby senses that the man's wife may have been threatened. But the wife denies it.