IMDb > Ein Lied für Argyris (2006) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Ein Lied für Argyris More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

8 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

A powerful documentary that every German (and all of us) ought to see

8/10
Author: Jugu Abraham (jugu_abraham@yahoo.co.uk) from Trivandrum, Kerala, India
8 December 2007

While most of the world believes that the horrors of the Nazis targeted only Jews, this documentary provides the viewer first hand narration from Greeks, some who now have Swiss citizenship, of the incredible sadistic acts of the German army as they mutilated and tortured hundreds living in a Greek village called Distomo before killing them. None of those killed were Jews, they were all Greek Orthodox Christians. Swiss director Stefan Haupt proves the incredible power of documentary cinema, with the use of old photographs, music, fine narration and seamless editing.

The main narrator is Argyris Sfountouris, who was a Greek child orphaned in the brutal massacre. His house was set on fire. Overnight he lost all. As he was found to be intelligent among the hundreds of other orphans he was picked by the Swiss Government along with few others to grow up in Switzerland. Today he is an astronomer and a scientist. One of his statements is "When will reconciliation begin and hate end? How can one forget what we experienced and forget those who died? When will we learn to forget our memories and move on?" The strength of the pivotal narration is its low-key account, honest but sad. Argyris is confounded that a country that produced the soothing music of Beethoven could centuries later produce savage brutes.

Another narrator is the famous Greek composer Mikis Theodorakis of "Zorba the Greek" fame. He recalls the German soldiers were interested in art and Parthenon. Yet the same soldiers would break the arms of hungry Greek children stealing bread. These are some of the contradictions in human behavior, the Swiss director Stefan Haupt highlights with remarkable effect.

Theodorakis also recounts a horrible account of the Greek Orthodox Priest and his family being stripped naked, mutilated in a horrible manner, forced to do unthinkable acts and then killed.

The more jarring facet is that when the Greek village survivors appealed for compensation from Germany, the German government refused to acknowledge guilt until a few years ago when the German Ambassador to Greece finally visited the village and apologized. Even today the German official stance is that Germany and Greece are now NATO allies and compensation is therefore ruled out. To compensate Distomo victims would mean compensating many others...

Argyris tries to forget his loss and hate by working for the underprivileged in Somalia, Nepal and Indonesia. But can one forget what one remembers in childhood?

This film is powerful—only Hans-Jurgen Syberberg's "Hitler-A film from Germany" was superior to this on a linked subject. The award winning film was screened at the 12th International Film Festival of Kerala. More people need to see the film so that similar horrors are not perpetrated elsewhere in the world. The film also offers open-ended solutions to deal with personal grief.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Remarkably moving and historically sound

10/10
Author: Danae Artemide from Italy
30 October 2009

This is an excellent documentary. Impressive in all its technical details, it evades sentimentalism but powerfully conveys the historical reality of the Distomo massacre leaving the conclusions to the audience. Argyris Sfountouris is an amazingly courageous and valiant individual who has transformed his personal tragedy in constructive ways. This film ought to be seen by everyone and all. Similar massacres are still going on in our world, in different parts of the world, and we must move to stop them.

Indeed Jews were not the only ones massacred by the Nazis, and this film makes the point with overwhelming clarity.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Awards External reviews
Official site Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history