Ricky Gervais Meets... Garry Shandling (2006) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Two brilliant people doing things they are not brilliant at.
cannotlogon1032 May 2007
Perhaps the degree to which one enjoys or dislikes this particular programme depends greatly on what he or she expects from the interview format. The simple fact is that Ricky Gervais is not a skilled interviewer and Garry Shandling is not a skilled interviewee. As others have noted here, they both come off extremely uncomfortable and awkward. Gervais is obviously hindered by the fact that he idolizes Shandling, and, as a result, at times tries too hard to connect with Shandling and to make Shandling laugh.

It is not until the last 15 minutes or so that Gervais calms down and actual conducts a proper interview. Shandling, likewise, seems extremely ill-at-ease with the entire idea of sharing himself with the public, and one can only wonder why he agreed to do the show in the first place -- though, it is clear that Shandling admires Gervais and thinks very highly of "The Office" and "Extras".

(Having seen Shandling interviewed by the dreadful Charlie Rose -- an interview that made this one seem positively free-flowing -- one can see that Shandling just doesn't seem comfortable being interviewed, period. The best interview I have ever seen of Shandling was the one conducted by Washington Post TV critic, Tom Shales, and is an extra on the DVD of the first season of "The Larry Sanders Show"; but even still, Shandling still comes off as uncomfortable talking about himself and his creations.)

Nevertheless, this programme is still worth watching, just so long as you are not too rigid in your perception of how structured an interview should be and how cogent and forthright the interviewee should be fielding the questions. Gervais and Shandling have created two of the greatest comedies ever to be broadcast, namely "The Office" and "The Larry Sanders Show" -- programmes which share a similar tone and style, in that they both explore human frailties and their primary characters, Gervais' David Brent and Shandling's Larry Sanders, are, at times, obtuse people who have a deep-seated need to be loved and respected. If we are to assume that the characters are psychological manifestations of their creators, than the interview takes on a much more interesting and illuminating dynamic.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great interview
MissSummers29 April 2007
This interview was an excellent exhibition of the comedy of awkwardness that both comedians are famous for. Both men have tried to blur the lines of reality, moving their characters into the "real world". Gervais, for example, has often put on his obnoxious act when going on chat shows or doing charity work. This interview with Shandling was just the next step and it was made successful because Gervais had an excellent partner to work with. The fact that they fooled so many people into thinking their awkwardness was real is a testament to that. If you didn't get it the first time, watch it again with this in mind. There are quite a few moments where Ricky can barely suppress his laughter at what Gary is doing.
9 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Fascinating Viewing - if only for its awkwardness
Dibby7 March 2007
Just to clear things up. Some have suggested that this documentary is in fact staged, and that, as both comedians are adept and familiar with the comedy of awkwardness, they have created a fictional interview. This, however, is not the case.

People see it as naive to think this is real, but from what we know about Gervais' persona and comments made afterwards from other writers, friends, comedians (Gervais nor Shandling have yet commented on this interview), it becomes more apparent that what was taking place was 'car crash TV. Combined with simple understandings of body language, linguistics, conversation analysis and basic social conduct, it is obvious Shandling's guard is up from the start.

Knowledge of Shandling suggests he is notoriously difficult to get along with, and rarely does TV interviews. Gervais on the other hand, is more loquacious and comfortable in front of the camera as 'himself' - he appears frequently on chat shows, interviews, etc. It would not be too unthinkable therefore, that Shandling mistakes Gervais' over confidence with a superiority thing, and instead goes on the attack. It has been argues that Shandling genuinely suffers from a superiority complex, and this would go quite far in explaining his reaction to Gervais manner of interviewing.

Compared to the interviews Gervais did with Christopher Guest and Larry David, it is strikingly obvious that the tone of the whole interview is different, more edgy and uncomfortable. At one point, in discussing taboo subjects of comedy, Shandling accuses Gervais of being anti-Semitic, and told Gervais he looked like a naughty school boy, knowing he was being mischievous. Gervais seems genuinely perplexed by this and then has to explain the nuances of awkward comedy to Shandling (Shandling - the godfather of awkward comedy).

To me, this is engaging viewing. Channel four nearly pulled the plug on airing (instead it was delayed 6 months, then aired at an impossible viewing time) a\and the reasons are clear why. Shandling comes across pompous, egotistical and totally unwilling to engage with Gervais at any other level than his own.

It is a real privilege to get to hear so much from Ricky Gervais, and it is a rare thing from most other comedians. Be it his stand-up tours, DVD extras, pod casts, interviews - I feel I have an understanding of his humour, better than most. So to see this humour go above Shandlings head - for it to even be challenged as politically incorrect - makes Shandling guilty of being out of touch with modern comedy.
26 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worth seeing because Shandling is very smart and funny but also because he doesn't allow Gervais to be the show in the way the latter often can be
bob the moo8 January 2007
Ricky Gervais has had one of the most successful and highest selling BBC comedies ever with The Office and with Extras was able to engage Hollywood stars not normally found on television. However he has turned down Hollywood roles and million dollar endorsements so how does he benefit from his success? He meets his idols – on this occasion Garry Shandling.

After meeting Christopher Guest, Ricky Gervais goes back to LA to meet up with Shandling and during the interview he declares that he is not a real interviewer. He says this but then annoyingly continues to make himself the centre of the film rather than using restraint and working with Shandling. This has been a common problem with all of the "Meets…" films is that Gervais has to say whatever comes to his mind. With Larry David it seemed to work because that suited David, whereas with Guest it didn't quite work because he wasn't like this. With Shandling it is immediately evident that this approach won't work with Shandling because he's not really having any of it.

And it is tremendous to see Gervais put on the back foot for the majority of the film. For some reason Gervais doesn't quite get it and gradually gets his confidence back and starts blurting things out but it doesn't seem to phase Shandling. So for the most part then this "Meets…" is better than the first two because Shandling does not allow Gervais to dominate him and it is much better for it. It helps that he is a difficult person to interview and makes it clear that he won't be making it an easy ride. He can be funny as a result but when he is given room his chat is actually pretty good with plenty of personal insight and comment into his work. Keeping Gervais down also stops it becoming a love-in as some of the other films do, although it does get a bit like that here and there.

Overall then this is actually a pretty interesting and funny chat. There is no chemistry between the two men but the controlling patience and difficult nature of Shandling puts Gervais on the back foot and sees him sit back and allow Shandling to flow (for a while, then he forgets again). Worth seeing because Shandling is very smart and funny but also because he doesn't allow Gervais to be the show in the way the latter often can be.
11 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What???
royorourke7 February 2007
Nobody can seriously tell me that Garry Shandling came off good in this fiasco? He struck me as an arrogant, selfish, self obsessed weirdo creep. He has all the personality of my dogs water-bowl with a couple of raw potatoes thrown in. I thought Gervais handled himself quite well given the circumstances he was forced into and to say that the interview was becoming all about him is a non argument. What was he supposed to when his interviewee turned out to be an amalgamation of Count Dracula and a giant moist toilet roll. I thought the part where Shandling made himself a cup of coffee to be particularly revealing. It spoke volumes about what kind of man he is or has become through fame, bitterness and a charm to match any oozing scab.
7 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed