- Detective Jake Berkeley: [seeing Jeff Murdock being brought into an interrogation room] Why is he in here?
- Lieutenant Horatio Caine: We caught him with the weapon that killed Nick Townsend.
- Detective Jake Berkeley: Why'd you find that?
- Lieutenant Horatio Caine: I followed the evidence, Jake.
- Detective Jake Berkeley: So did I.
- Lieutenant Horatio Caine: Yes, but in your case, you allowed the evidence to fit your theory, Jake, instead of the other way around.
- Phillip Craven: I want a lawyer.
- Lieutenant Horatio Caine: Spoken like the last request of a guilty man.