Eli's latest vision - with an assist from his dad's diary - causes him to abandon Jordan's competency hearing and focus on a case he believes will take him to the supreme court, ultimately forcing him to choose between knowing his own future and living his life.
Martin Posner makes tempting offers to everyone at the firm, and Taylor asks Eli to work with Matt, hoping to influence his decision. Meanwhile, Eli's visions involving Maggie are disturbing on more than one level, and he faces some tough decisions as the firm transitions to its new mission.
Eli's vision contradicts the evidence when Patti's daughter is arrested, and he struggles with the effect his gift has on those with whom he's close. Matt's proclamation leaves him feeling unfulfilled.
Eli defends a young woman he believes will save humanity, Taylor learns some uncomfortable truths when she insists on being part of Jordan's divorce team, and Eli's insistence on a risky procedure reveals a future for which he's not prepared.
Taylor, Maggie, Matt and Eli go to Sonoma when it turns out both firms are after the same witness, Patti makes amends, Jordan finds socializing difficult, and an unexpected turn to a work meeting will change Maggie and Eli's relationship.
Still estranged from his brother and Chen, Eli struggles to understand his visions of gladiator-era and present-day Rome as the Sam Russell trial moves forward. Meanwhile, Maggie maneuvers a little revenge into the proceedings, Jordan has news about the firm, and Taylor challenges Matt about what kind of father he's going to be.
The firm tries to force devout parents to donate their daughter's heart to an atheist, and Eli's vision of another plane crash causes him to risk the Dark Truth again, but the death he sees is unexpected.