IMDb > Men in White (2007) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Men in White More at IMDbPro »Gui a! Gui a! (original title)

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 reviews in total 

13 out of 16 people found the following review useful:

Uh oh.

Author: loccomotive2000 from Singapore
18 June 2007

Director Kelvin Tong had said that Men in White was made in a way that would appeal to young people. I'm sad to say that he's quite off the mark.

The film's plot is already weak to begin with, and to make things worse, it becomes more and more obscure towards the end. We're not looking for an Academy-award winner here, but how are we supposed to watch a movie when there is no storyline to follow? The entire movie just tossed five ghosts together, and that's it, we get to see them 'live' their 'dead lifestyles'.

Tong tries to recreate the 'Mo-Lei-Tau' impression here, a 'pseudo genre' of HK comedy movies made famous by the great Stephen Chow. However, he's missing all the key ingredients here; none of the actors are close to being as energetic and charismatic as Chow, and most of the gags are unoriginal and continuously reused within the film. I felt like walking out of the theater whenever the rap segments came on.

I've heard Tong's The Maid was quite a good film, but he really needs to stay off comedies. From mo lei tau, at least.

Was the above review useful to you?

17 out of 25 people found the following review useful:

Extremely Bad!!!

Author: Chucky from Singapore
23 July 2007

This is one of the worst film I have seen in my entire life! A piece of trash and completely no story telling at all. It is pretty obvious the one and only commentator is the writer and director's best friend or insider trying to salvage the situation. See it for yourself and you'll know why! Vommited... ;-(

Firstly there is no structure. The film is completely going nowhere and I think the director is lost too. Wonder who invested in the film, must be fools...

Secondly the actors are a bunch of fools. Acting was not only bad, but f**king bad! Benjamin is the mother of all fools in the film.

Thirdly the film will bring a bad reputation to the Singapore film industry. We are already lagging behind Thailand and some neighbouring countries, which is a big shame as a first world country. So such filming standards must be stop at all cost!

Was the above review useful to you?

6 out of 17 people found the following review useful:

A Nutshell Review: Men in White

Author: DICK STEEL from Singapore
5 June 2007

Then again, it's a comedy, and the whole intention of Tong was to try and emulate the classical 80s comedies from Hong Kong, especially those Stephen Chow "mo lei tau" (nonsensical) movies, which Tong confessed this evening to being probably his #1 fan in Singapore. Unfortunately those movies are in a class of its own, and the actors in MiW are certainly not in the same league too. But you can't fault Tong for trying, as MiW was more like a shotgun firing its rounds - some pellets hit the mark, while some others totally miss the target.

Technically, Tong has shown that he understood the elements of suspense - the prologue showed that he is more than capable to helm another horror movie though he overdid this bit to achieve some comedic effect, a subtle prod on those horror movies with extremely closeups of facial expressions, especially that of Asian horror favourite - the widening eyeball.

Alas, in treading onto comedy in almost Jack Neo fashion, MiW too felt like little skits pieced together to make a feature length film. And Neo's style of meshing songs into the narrative, became no less than 3 musical pieces popping up as music videos, complete with sing along lyrics, karaoke style. But I like these songs - they are fun, at times nonsensical, and are in dialect with no English subtitles, which to some, might have been lost in translation (*ahem* I'm multi-lingual, so no problem lah).

The music comes courtesy of Joe Ng (Mee Pok Man), and the sound effects and design is probably one of the best in a local movie, especially since it was relied on heavily to deliver those cartoonish effects with aplomb, and you definitely must keep your ears peeled to appreciate this. One such scene involves Benjamin Heng, who has appeared in 3 out of 4 Kelvin Tong movies, and whose character here, if I were to romanticize it further, could have seemed like a (logical though more fantastical since it's in the spiritual realm) continuation of the one in Eating Air, as they share similar mannerisms, or could actually seem more of a spoof of his earlier Ah-Beng gangster character.

Heng has a supporting role here though. The other main characters are Shaun Chen as Ah Boon, an ex-national reserve badminton player, Alice Lim as Madam Wong, an elderly lady, Ling Lee as Wan Yi, a lady who choked to death, and the Hip Hop duo of err Hip (Xavier Teo) and Hop (Ben Yeung), whom I swear are more irritating as time goes by, until they break into song and dance in those music videos. They are all ghostly pals living in an unused HDB apartment unit, and whine for the most parts about how difficult life is for a ghost in Singapore. Not to forget, a bit part for Sunny the cameraman, another ghostly pal who's filming the chronicles of these friends.

No prizes for acting skills over here, as Shaun Chen does look a little wooden, Xavier and Ben like I mentioned, and chewing up too much screen with their over the top performances, and Ling Lee, well I'm not sure why, but certain angles did make her look rather unappealing. Maybe they are playing to their one-dimensional characters, but the character which stole the show, hands down, is the gambler-contractor. Now he IS the star of MiW with his perfect delivery of some of the best lines and situations in the movie. David Aw had a bit role in the movie as an instigator of change, and he got that role as a result of a MiW Talent Search Contest, which I thought didn't require much talent actually, given the screen time.

The narrative played out chapter-like, each self contained as an answer to commonly asked ghostly questions, which is why it resembled skits, though it does have a romantic thread that slowly runs and gets developed in the 2nd half of the movie. In true local movie fashion, it used multiple languages again to highlight our multi-lingual society, though some might find fault with its politically incorrect racist jokes and stereotyping (OK so I am now feeling guilty at laughing out loud at these). Some of the other jokes might seem a bit too localized for them to be effective to a more international audience, but I guess the sight gags (at times quite juvenile) will always be able to transcend language barriers. An irk I had though, there were noticeable typos in the English subtitles. Probably next time I can proofread for anyone out there!

With a title like that (the original Chinese title of "Ghost ah! Ghost ah!"), this film doesn't take itself seriously, and neither should you. Just kick back and relax, enjoy some of the pluses this movie has to offer, wince at the minuses, and remember, it's "mo lei tau" no-brainer entertainment, so don't fret too much over it.

Was the above review useful to you?

Add another review

Related Links

Ratings External reviews Official site
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history