Randy has a crush on the the next woman on Earl's list, so he pretends to be a cat lover. But based on Randy's past experiences as a poser, Earl knows that this one will end badly.



(created by) (as Greg Garcia),

Watch Now

From $0.99 (HD) on Amazon Video



1 video »


Episode cast overview:
Catalina (credit only)
Bill Suplee ...
William Newman
Kevin Farrell ...


Joy and her cat once entered a contest for cats and because she wanted to be sure she'd win, Earl stole the prize winning kitty that would probably win the contest and took it to an old, constantly sleeping cat lady's place. Now, he wants to make up for stealing the feline and when he goes to previous owner Judy to tell her what he did, Randy falls in love with her. The fact that Randy hates cats and is allergic to them doesn't help though and neither does Randy's habit to pretend to be someone he's not in order to be appreciated by a girl he likes. Meanwhile, Earl gets the cat back and gives it to Judy. When Randy finally tells Judy he hates cats she decides to get rid of the cat. Everybody is happy now and Earl is ready to cross this misstep off his list until Darnell tells him the feline doesn't look very happy. According to Darnell, the former prize winner doesn't like being a fat cat instead of a beautiful champ. Earl decides he can't cross 'larceny of a cat' off his list until ... Written by Marco van Hoof <k_luifje7@hotmail.com>

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis







Release Date:

12 October 2006 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


Among the town residents at the cat show is Pete the one-eyed mailman, who had a chance to grab Earl's lucky ticket as it blew through the town on its way back to Earl. Pete wears an eye patch and his cat sports one as well. Pete is played by Ethan Suplee's real life father--Bill Suplee See more »


Earl Hickey: Randy, I'm not gonna stand here forever just 'cause you're superstitious.
Randy Hickey: Why? Every day of my life revolves around you believing in karma. Plus, we always buy the kind of cereal you like.
See more »


True Colors
Written by Tom Kelly and Billy Steinberg
Performed by Cyndi Lauper
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Message Boards

Recent Posts
Where is Camden supposed to be located? rbf08
How could they afford all the copyrighted music? ecmelton-186-105049
Best. Line. Ever! jumaward
List of Canceled Shows that never got a real ending cheeeeseman4
What state is this supposed to be set? Thindy_Brady
Jason Lee wants to give it a proper ending Fingaroo
Discuss Larceny of a Kitty Cat (2006) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page