"Maigret" The Experts (TV Episode 1961) Poster

(TV Series)

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Maigret with a comedy angle?!
Tony-Holmes21 March 2022
I see yet another ill-informed comment from Sir-Oblong about this Maigret series, about "Simenon, laughing to the bank, rubbish" -- which ignores the countless tributes to the author from other acclaimed crime writers, and reviewers?! This one was aired in Jan 61, a time when BBC had been going for a few yrs, ITV not that long, there was really not that much drama on TV, and the schedules only ran in the evenings, for adults.

'Classic' shows like Z Cars from that era had shaky sets and some occasionally dodgy acting, and yes some occasionally weird stunt scenes.

This Maigret episode had a few comedy touches in it, as such series sometimes do have a few lighter moments. Hence the bits about Lognon's (awful) wife, and Torrence doing some unusually close surveillance with an 'actress' who'd been involved with the baddies. Even shows like Morse, Hill St Blues (& many more) had the occasional joke.

And yes, this Maigret was done on a low budget (like most things back then!) and the hour runtime was plenty short enough for many Simenon stories, hence the rushed explanation at the end of this one. Maybe people are unfamiliar with Agatha Christie (pretty well known in the genre?!!!) who specialised in giant coincidences, many suspects, and usually a gigantic explanation at the end!! Perhaps our 'crime' expert Sir Ob should have a look at those for his pet hates?!

As for the "I don't think many 1961 licence payers did" (for foreign readers, the UK pays for TV via a licence fee) in fact Maigret was ENORMOUSLY popular back then, pretty much a must-see show every week. So that's more ill-informed tosh!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Experts
Prismark1019 March 2022
The episode introduces Inspector Lognon. Dogged but prone to bad luck and despondency. The latter due to his wife.

Lognon witnesses a hit taking place. The culprits are gunmen sent over by American gangsters.

Maigret is drawn into the case. Luckily he once spent time in America and made contacts over there.

It looks like an informant came to France and the hitmen were quickly on his tail.

There seems to be lot less location shooting in this story. It was a murky story and I would had been none the wiser until the plot was explained at the end.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
As dire as The Liberty Bar
Sir_Oblong_Fitzoblong28 February 2022
Cartoon-style gangsters; a plot that is barely worthy of the name and which is impossible to deduce or fathom until recounted at the end; an embarrassingly contrived and inept fight scene; and an all pervading air of "have we filled up the 50 minutes yet?"

No doubt Simenon laughed all the way to the bank after dashing off this rubbish but I don't think many 1961 licence-fee payers did.
1 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed