Pagliacci (TV Movie 1954) Poster

(1954 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Add a Review
2 ReviewsOrdered By: Helpfulness
Very fine singing in this version of Pagliacci
lora646 August 2007
This DVD presentation of "Pagliacci" (1954) with Tito Gobbi as Tonio, Franco Corelli as Canio, and Mafalda Micheluzzi as Nedda, is the best version musically in my opinion and much more integrated.

Personally I think the Prologue as sung by Gobbi is a marvellous gift from heaven! Unforgettable and simply superb. In this wonderful solo he tells us that the drama, although performed by actors, is about real human beings who like everyone else have ordinary human feelings. This is opera solo music at its finest.

In Act 1, the travelling players arrive at a small village and are greeted enthusiastically by the crowds, then soon move off to the local tavern leaving Nedda alone at homebase. She daydreams of being freed from her life there, free as the birds in the sky, and sings a wonderfully inspired aria filled with joy. To me it is a special musical moment to be remembered. Present only is Tonio, the simpleminded member of the group, who has a crush on Nedda but of course she is married to Canio, the leader. Tonio forces his attentions on her, moved by the love that stirs in his heart, but she scorns him, strikes him with a whip, and he backs away humiliated, vowing vengeance. This sets the tone for much of what follows as one feels a tension in the air whenever he's around.

Silvio (Lino Puglisi) is Nedda's lover and he next appears after Tonio has left the scene. He'd like to take Nedda away with him, wanting her to leave the group, and questioning her again what her feelings are for her older husband, Canio. Surely if she doesn't love him she shouldn't stay. She hesitates then reluctantly agrees to meet Silvio after that night's performance, to run off together, and they finish the scene with exquisite singing of their love and future life together. Such beautiful music.

Canio (Franco Corelli) is the jealous husband and now arrives, but he returns only to find Nedda with Silvio so he frantically chases after him but Silvio manages to escape and not be recognized. Not knowing exactly who it is Canio roughly demands that Nedda reveal his name. She doesn't give in to him however. The day moves on and it's time to prepare for the evening's performance.

We find in Act 2 that the play onstage begins with a Serenade sung by Beppe, very nicely performed by Mario Carlin. He plays Harlequin who sings to his ladylove, Columbine (Nedda). Canio has to play the part of Pagliaccio who suddenly bursts upon the stage and Harlequin runs away. This role playing is too close to home for Canio who lapses into the real life drama that started off stage. Now he demands from Columbine (his wife Nedda) the name of her lover and there is no pretending anymore. Thereafter is the denouement to follow.

When the opera was first performed it was not highly regarded by the critics but the major tenors of the time enjoyed the Pagliacci role and that helped to keep it popular. In modern times the opinion has mellowed and it's considered a very good example of expressive artistry, a nice compliment given that it's rather a short opera compared to most others. One gets to appreciate this music more and more after some serious listening. Well recommended.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this
One of my all time favourite Pagliaccis, perhaps even my favourite
TheLittleSongbird11 February 2012
Pagliacci is a very special opera to me, then again I'd probably say that for any of the operas that I sang in the chorus in. While I also highly recommend the 1968 and 1982 versions, I think after seeing this I have found the best Pagliacci I have seen. The picture quality is a little grainy, but the camera work is generally fine even with a couple of extreme close ups.

The sound is decent also, with all the crucial scenes having the right impact, some of the softer moments may sound a tad monophonic but compared to other opera productions/films before or during this time I was impressed. Visually this Pagliacci is impressive. The sets may not be the most beautiful I've seen but they are very effective and manage to look more than sets constructed for the stage, likewise with the costumes, especially Tonio's and Canio in his Pagliaccio guise.

Musically, this is outstanding, doing justice to such an amazing work. I just prefer Karajan's marginally more romantic approach, but the conducting is more sensitive and less broad(in a good way) than Levine's reading. The chorus play powerfully and beautifully, Vesti La Guibba is very poignant, the prologue is nuanced and Non Pagliaccio Non Son is second only to Karajan for the 1968 version as the most dramatic reading of that particular scene.

When it comes to the staging, it is compelling throughout and true to the action involved in the story. The chorus numbers are not too chaotic and they are sung with attention to balance, pitch and diction, and Corelli and Gobbi especially live their respective arias. My favourites though are in the final scene, and they are Corelli throwing his wig at Micheluzzi's Nedda and the most painful and most honest uttering of "La Commedia E Finita" I have ever heard.

The principal performances are among the best I've seen in these roles. Mafalda Micheluzzi is an excellent Nedda, the singing is radiant especially in her song to the birds and her acting especially in Act 2 is riveting, she is vulnerable and bitchy, but she is also witty and excels even more so at the increasing panic in Non Pagliaccio Non Son. Lino Puglosi is a sympathetic Silvio, a role like I have said in previous reviews of Pagliacci that contrasts ideally with the more brutish role of Canio, and Mario Carlin is a charming Beppe with his serenade in Act 2 him at his best here.

However, there are two performances that stand out. One is Tito Gobbi, for me one of the finest Tonios there ever was. Although it was still a good voice, I can perhaps think of baritones with more beautiful voices than Gobbi's, like Merrill or Ruffo, and the baritone with the best high A flat in the prologue is between Milnes and Warren. What makes Gobbi stand out is how he interprets the role, Milnes and especially Tibbett were very exciting actors but Gobbi was unique, right now I can think of few baritones who match his musicianship or his ability to not just embody the role but also make it three dimensional. Gobbi does do that, and in his nuanced performance of the prologue alone.

Especially good is Franco Corelli. Some may say he is not quite their idea of a middle-aged brute that Canio is in a way, Corelli being very tall and one of the handsomest men on an opera stage, but you forget that because Corelli is the most thrilling Canio I've seen. I am not disputing Vickers and Domingo in any way as they are incredible in this difficult role too, just that Corelli's voice is so beautiful with such a ringing, dark quality to it, his musicality is superb and the poignancy of Vesti La Guibba and brimming intensity of Non Pagliaccio Non Son show him at his very best dramatically.

Overall, a must see, it really does give definition to the phrase opera at its finest. 10/10 Bethany Cox
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews