"Doctor Who" The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Eight (TV Episode 1986) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"Must you say such nauseating things?" Not bad but not great.
poolandrews20 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Eight starts as scientist Crozier (Patrick Ryecart) desperately searches for an appropriate body to transfer Kiv's (Christopher Ryan) mind into permanently & chooses Peri (Nicola Bryant) as a perfect candidate. Meanwhile the Doctor (Colin Baker) manages to free King Yrcanos (Brian Blessed) & disable the slave mind control device to start a rebellion but is it too late to save Peri...

Episode 8 from season 23 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during October 1986, the fourth & final part of Mindwarp the second mini four part story in The Trial of a Time Lord season after The Mysterious Planet this was directed by Ron Jones & I have to say that it's maybe a slight improvement on The Mysterious Planet that came before it but is still not much better than average. The script by Philip Martin has been a pretty standard tale that has used various influences from Frankenstein (which I thought the Doctor Who story The Brain of Morbius (1976) with Tom Baker did a much better job of using & expanding upon it's literary source), The Island of Doctor Moreau & any prisoner escape to lead a rebellion against their captor's type flick you care to mention. In my opinion Mindwarp hasn't been that bad but at the same time it just hasn't been that great either, most the character's have been bland, it's been ponderous at times, there's been lots of wandering around in identical looking corridors & there's even a tacky speech by Peri on the meaning of love. The Doctor finally starts acting like the hero again but before he can save the day he is taken out of time to stand trial. Mindwarp is also notable for the apparent death of Peri in her last story, well all I'll say is you don't actually see her die & only the Valeyard suggests that she was killed & I wouldn't believe everything he says if I were you...

Despite some impressive monsters Mindwarp hasn't been scary or frightening, there's not been too much humour & the action scenes were forgettable. This episode also sees Peri with a shaved head, sorry but I think Peri looks awful with no hair & is just another reason not to get excited by this. Around the time Mindwarp went into production producer John Nathan-Turner decided to call the entire season under the umbrella title The Trial of a Time Lord rather than the individual stories specific names as in the Key to Time season, also around this time script editor Eric Saward's much publicised resignation & infamously scathing interview in Starburst happened as he left his position with a lot of bad feeling since he wasn't getting along with producer Nathan-Turner or upper BBC management amongst other issues like disagreements about the scripts & the casting. Outraged by Saward's actions producer Nathan-Turner acted uncredited as script editor during production of Mindwarp & the subsequent two remaining The Trial of a Time Lord stories Terror of the Vervoids & The Ultimate Foe.

The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Eight, or Mindwarp Part Four, is an OK way to end an OK four parter I suppose, while Mindwarp hasn't exactly knocked my socks off it's been watchable with some decent special effects & monsters. Overall I'll give Mindwarp a respectable 6 stars out of 10 across it's four episodes, good but not great.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Eight
Prismark1028 July 2019
The problem with the cliffhanger for Part 7 was that it was manipulated by the Valeyard. A cheap trick.

By the time this story, Mindwarp concludes it is the Time Lords who might be manipulating events and the Doctor's movements. It seems to indicate that they really have something to hide and the trial is a travesty.

Kiv's new body is rejecting his mind. Crozier has perfected his experiments and reckons he can transfer Kiv's mind into Peri's body.

The Doctor has freed King Yrcanos but is then taken out of the loop when trying to get to Peri.

The episode does end with confusion and disappointment. A bald Peri who has now been inhabited by Kiv. It is a fate worse than death.

It is a cerebral episode by writer Philip Martin. It gets a grip on the emerging greed is good culture of the 1980s. There are some good production design of the monsters Sil and Kiv. There is a large black cast in this story but some of the muscular black men who guard Sil and Kiv look like they belong to some dance music video. It looks rather campy.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This is an impressive final segment of Mindwarp, shocking.
Sleepin_Dragon27 December 2019
Crozier successfully transfers Kiv into the body of one of his own kind, but the transfer is a failure, a new body is required...

I have thoroughly enjoyed Mindwarp, way more than The Mysterious Planet, the story has been more cohesive, more interesting, and much darker in tone, verging on sci fi horror. This final part was the best yet, because they pushed the boundaries, in a way I've not seen done before, the fate of Peri in particular, a totally shocking scene, I admire them for having the bottle to do what they did, although events would be changed later on. We also get the scene which sees The Doctor taken out of space and time.

Blessed was terrific, yes loud, and that's joked about several times, all a bit tongue in cheek, but he is marvellous. It's also about the best of Bryant as Peri, she should have stayed on a bit longer, she shone here.

Bleak, dark, chilling and shocking, this is 1980's Doctor Who at its best. 9/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed