Very good moral tale, mostly well realised. A strong but sad farewell for Steven.
Christopher Evans from South Wales, UK
19 August 2014
Review of all 4 episodes:
This very strong 4 part story is set on an apparently idyllic world
where all is not as it seems.
The adventure brings the TARDIS crew into a moral stand against a
system which exploits one group for the furtherment of the other. It is
not the first or last time such issues arise in the long running series
but the ideas are well enough written and presented here to make this a
very successful and entertaining story overall.
It is not necessarily 100 percent perfect but the story is interesting
and well scripted by Ian Stuart Black. There is action, intelligent
themes, good dialogue and some fine acting. The leader of the Elders,
Jano (Frederick Jaeger), is an especially good character. William
Hartnell and Peter Purves deliver great performances as usual and the
fact it is the last story for Peter Purves as Steven is very sad. He
was one of the best companions in my opinion but at least he had a
I think this story perhaps is the first sign of producer Innes Lloyd
and story editor Gerry Davis, who both took over their roles mid
season, beginning to put their stamp on the show. They apparently
wanted the show to be less whimsical and more 'gutsy' with more action
and seriousness in the scientific themes. This ticks those boxes.
My Ratings: Episode 1 - 8/10, Episode 2 - 9.5/10, Episode 3 - 8.5/10,
Episode 4 - 9.5/10
Add another review