Reviews & Ratings for
"Stargate: Atlantis" The Return: Part 1 (2006)

« Prev | 49 of 99 Episodes | Next »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

How the Atlanteans lost the Wraith War

10/10
Author: XweAponX from United States
7 September 2015

This episode introduced an important gimmick that we would see used and abused through Season 4: The Mackay/Carter Gate Bridge that connected the Pegasus galaxy to the Milky Way and allowed Gate travel directly to SGU in 30 minutes.

Basically, it's a bunch of what are called SpaceGates in SGA, Gates floating in Space, which were dropped in place at various intervals between the Pegasus Galaxy and the Milky way, in the middle the last gate from Pegasus faces the first gate from the Milky Way, and that can be used as a buffer zone. Enough of that, though... I don't wanna end up sounding like David Hewlett.

But while Mackay is showing off he and Carter's innovation, he detects an odd sensor blip, which turns out to be an Atlantean ship traveling to Earth at 0.99999 times the speed of light, making it a bear to catch up with!

The captain of this ship is "Helia" (Megan Leitch aka Samantha Mulder), and if she is a common Atlantean, it explains why the race of Ancients who were technologically superior were defeated - They were also stupid! Basically, Helia takes over Atlantis, kicking out all of those who had been running the place and protecting it for them and allowing only two people to stay: Richard Woolsey (Robert "The Doctor" Picardo) and one Jack O'Neill (two l's).

These Atlanteans make assumptions about the state of the universe that maybe were correct 10,000 years ago, but are just not true now. And they pay for it when Replicators invade. Fortunately, Jack O'Neill and Woolsey have the sense to run and hide, while Helia used her last breath to protect them, to her final credit.

But John Sheppard is on Earth, trapped while Tayla and Ronon are on some butt-planet in the Pegasus Galaxy being wooed by the new leader of The Genii.

So the conundrum is how to get the main Stargate Atlantis team (and Weir) back to Atlantis - Without SGC's permission or help. But that solution was in my first paragraph, or, "How to Hijack a Bridge".

And of course, Rodney has an idea on how to deal with Replicators, unless it all goes sideways as usual. But it was great to see Richard Dean Anderson bounce off Robert Picardo, two great actors amusing us and themselves. Of course there are goofs and scientific inaccuracies, but that's TV for ya- It does not deter from a great set of "sweeps week" episodes.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 25 people found the following review useful:

Goofs Wow

8/10
Author: Japie Krekel from Netherlands
23 September 2006

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

The crew is back in S.G.C because Atlanteans have taken over command in Atlantis. The replicators come attacking the base, and due to some rewriting of their code, they can now attack atlanteans. The Atlantis team (le doctor, Sheppard, McKay and the woman) want to return to Atlantis to stop the replicator invasion.

To get there they need to use the star gate, and to use it, they need access. So to distract the scientist guarding the access list, McKay has Elisabeth pose as a wow player.

In this episode the scientist in sgc mentiones he has a level 75 mage in world of warcraft, coz he has an expansion already. (that expansion is not out yet, but being in the position he is in, that actually is remotely possible.) However, the expansion from world of warcraft only let's players extend their characters to level 70. As in goof. Zest.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history