Russell gives Liz a makeover to impress his dad, Jeff's "guys weekend" is ruined because Audrey is worried about her medical test results, and Adam is infatuated with his new friend, actor Curtis "Booger" Armstrong.
Jeff celebrates Audrey's inability to talk after her node removal surgery, Russell gets Timmy to fire an employee for him, and Adam discovers that he's only getting free stuff because of his good looks.
Everyone spends a weekend in Vermont to watch the leaves change. During the trip, Adam gets poison ivy on his hands, Jeff has an embarrassing experience on the inn's computer, and Liz begins to realize that her marriage is a sham.
Unwilling to admit to Jeff (Patrick Warburton) that she made a mistake, Audrey (Megyn Price) reluctantly keeps a hideous chair she purchased. Timmy (Adhir Kalyan) suspects Russell (David Spade) has ulterior motives when he asks him out to a fancy lunch.
Jeff has a unique way of showing Audrey that he is putting some effort into improving their relationship by sending his wife on a scavenger hunt that may not have the results that Jeff intended the hunt to have.
Audrey believes her maid needs an operation to correct the limp she has to be able to walk better, thinking she is doing the right thing Audrey asks her neighbors to contribute to the cause not having any idea what the money is really intended for.
Frustrated by his boss blaming him for burning his mouth on hot soup, Timmy (Adhir Kalyan) has a special spoon created for Russell (David Spade). Audrey's (Megyn Price) plan backfires when she tries to seduce Jeff (Patrick Warburton) in the bedroom in order to get him to complete household tasks.
Timmy (Adhir Kalyn) has a "missed connection with a beautiful woman while on the subway with Russell (David Spade). Adam's (Oliver Hudson) anniversary gift for Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) leads him to a drum circle. Audrey (Megyn Price) and Jeff (Patrick Warburton) meet a new couple in the building and are confused when they cancel plans to get together and later see them out.
Jeff can't come up with five things that he likes about Audrey, Russell teaches Timmy guitar in his latest effort to humiliate him, and Adam becomes upset when he discovers the truth about Jeff and Audrey's finances.
Audrey and Jennifer decide to attend a Bon Jovi concert together. Jeff decides to have a roof-top barbecue, and hurts Adams feelings when he doesn't invite him. Meanwhile Russell sends Timmy on a mission to find out who is the face behind an old phone number he finds in one of his old jackets.
Audrey takes a neighbor's doll to the "doll hospital" after she breaks it, Jeff accompanies his child's surrogate mother on a date, Russell is lost in a cab after oral surgery, and Adam gets a temporary tattoo.
Jennifer may regret deciding to throw Audrey's shower after she puts the wrong date of the shower on the invitation. Jeff takes an instant liking to Brenda's clothes for some reason. Russell does something drastic by giving up on dating women hoping to accomplish things.