IMDb > The Nautical Chart (2007) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Nautical Chart More at IMDbPro »La carta esférica (original title)

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

10 out of 11 people found the following review useful:

Sailor and siren

6/10
Author: rogornmoradan from León, Spain
18 October 2007

In the twenty years since he became a published writer in 1986, former Spanish war correspondent Arturo Pérez-Reverte has seen his name credited in ten films or TV series, the best-known among them being 'The ninth gate'. And almost each time the response has been disappointment for fans of his books and casual viewers alike. Most times, either the book or the hype promised more than the screen finally delivered. 'La carta esférica' is not an exception to this rule.

Pérez-Reverte's stories of his trademark tired heroes aim to be adventure tales with canonical presentation, plot and denouément, and at the same time heavy in characterisation effort, with detailed descriptions of what goes through the mind of the leading character before he acts next. Typically, a book needs to be found, or a map, or a painting, or a crime needs to be solved, and there we go, following our grizzled hero in the adventure.

Basque director Imanol Uribe was attracted precisely to this type of classic adventure yarn when reading the novel: a sailor anxious to get back on a ship after a forced spell on land because of a legal problem finds the chance to do it, with a twist: there's a map (the nautical chart of the title), a beautiful and determined woman, a discovery to be made and a couple of bad guys. Obviously he reacts like 'gimme a break, this type of thing just doesn't happen any more...', but of course, there wouldn't be a story if that was the whole story. Classic Saturday-in-November, rain-outside, after-lunch-film fare.

And that's all there is, as far as the film is concerned. The characters then go from A to B to C etc, as the discoveries in the script dictate, but at the end of it all, the result is not terribly interesting. For starters, the aim of the search is nothing Earth-shattering, like the Holy Grail or the Ark of the Alliance, and to continue, the glue that holds the tale together, which is the obsession of Coy, the sailor, with Tánger, the woman, is largely lost and diluted.

One of the main criticisms made about this film is that it is dragged down by the use of voice-over (a resource which, if well used, produces marvellous results -witness Martin Scorsese's 'Casino' or 'Goodfellas', for example-, but if not well handled becomes a burden on the picture). Its use was an attempt to include that other driving theme of the novel, (apart from the voyage-and-discovery element), which is the age-old motif of the sailor tempted by the voice of a siren, a woman wiser than him who becomes to the mariner 'all women who ever lived'. Pérez-Reverte is a keen sailor himself, frequently going solo on his sailboat along the Mediterranean sea by whose shores he, and his character, Coy, were born. So, the sea, 'old and wise', the women who live by it, also growing wise after frequently waiting for their men gone to war since the times of the Odyssey, and the sailor who is brave when faced with danger and battle but often lost and rudderless in dealing with women, all form a part of the same canvas in which the story is set. Of course, this is quite interesting when read, but difficult to work into a basic film of X marks the spot, in particular when the original story tends to be a slow-burner to start with.

Carmelo Gómez is quite good as Coy the sailor, but Aitana Sánchez-Gijón had a tall order to serve, playing a woman who, without being extremely beautiful, toys with men more or less as she wishes. You do need to believe she's one to be able to pull that off for the script to work. The rest of the very short cast (pilot and two bad guys) are adequate.

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 4 people found the following review useful:

The nautical chart

6/10
Author: jotix100 from New York
4 June 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Eighteenth century Spanish cartographer Urrutia Salcedo was a man ahead of his times. He was responsible for producing nautical charts that were revered by intelligent men that loved the sea; they felt guided by a master that put into paper maps that still today are considered unique documents, produced at a time where primitive techniques still were the norm. When one of his original works come into a Barcelona auction house, there is a bidding war among what appear three serious buyers. The book goes to Tanger, a representative of the national maritime museum located in Madrid.

The auction is seen through Coy's eyes, a man that loves old charts as well as has a passion for the sea. He cannot help himself in following Tanger to the museum to check on a particular detail of the Spanish Mediterranean coast. What he discovers is a difference of a nautical mile in the Urrutia Salcedo's map of the region that might shed light on the mystery of the lost brigantine Dei Gloria, which sank off the coast of Spain on a return trip from Cuba, a couple of centuries ago.

What follows is Coy's quest to find out the sunken ship, but he is not prepared to deal with the two men that are also interested in finding the ship. Add that to his involvement with Tanger, who is more ways than one, has not completely let Coy know what her real intentions are.

Imanol Uribe, the director of this film, who adapted the Arturo Perez Reverte bestseller, has an eye for detail, placing his movie in different points of Spain. He was lucky in finding Javier Aguirresarobe to do the splendid cinematography for the movie.

Carmelo Lopez does an excellent job as Coy. With his handsome dark looks, he makes the best of his character. In some ways his work in this film is a joy to watch. The only weak element is Aitana Sanchez Gijon, who doesn't bring a menacing touch to her Tanger, a duplicitous woman, if ever there was one. Enrico Loverso, a good Italian actor seems out of his element as Palermo.

The film is somewhat predictable because we realize where it's going from the start, but it offers a tale of adventure in incredible locales that is its best asset.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot synopsis Ratings Awards
External reviews Parents Guide Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history