The team travels to Manhattan to work with the NYPD in tracking and apprehending a serial killer who is intent on dispensing his own style of vigilante justice.



(created by), | 1 more credit »

Watch Now

From $1.99 (SD) on Amazon Video



1 video »


Episode credited cast:
Det. Nora Bennett
Lance Wagner
Will Sykes
Rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Pat Connolly ...
Natalie Graziano ...
Woman on the Street #2


In New York a hooded serial killer blindfolds and shoots, then stabs victims which seem to have nothing in common. The profiling team concludes that the cab driver could only be killed after thorough preparation. His latest attack is a priest, accused but cleared in court of child abuse. After this incident he lets a female witness escape to a church, suggesting that the setting is essential to his ritual. It turns out all the victims were acquitted or got the charges dropped. The killer turns out to be a vigilante who stabs his guilty victims in a 'poetically just' organ, probably continuing on the theme of a first crime against a perpetrator whose victim he once was. Gideon thinks it may be a cop, but can't scare off the NYPD from collaborating, and indeed the next victim is a double cop-killer. All victims have been on trial in one single court-house. Crime newspaper reporter Lance Wagner gets incredibly precise scoops every time. After shooting in panic an undercover cop in the ... Written by KGF Vissers

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis





Release Date:

22 March 2006 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


Gideon hands Hotch a newspaper in the lobby of the courthouse. When Hotch turns it over to read the headline, the viewer can briefly see the title of the paper - "New York Quest," not New York Ledger, which is the fictional NY newspaper of choice for most shows set in NYC. The format and design of both fictional papers is meant to emulate a real newspaper, the New York Post. See more »


As Gideon is preparing to enter the building and confront the unsub, he puts on his bulletproof vest and starts toward the building. The camera changes angles and we see him briefly pass by with his vest in his hand. Then a third shot shows him putting on his vest again. See more »


[last lines]
Woman on the Street #4: They only killed him cause they were afraid no jury would convict him.
See more »


References Taxi Driver (1976) See more »


Composed by Leonard Cohen
Performed by Jeff Buckley
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Good, But Could Have Been Much Better
27 January 2007 | by (United States) – See all my reviews

New York City is the scene where the BAU travels after a third person is killed the same way as two others. The victims are shot, then stabbed with a flint-type knife and then blindfolded. After a fourth murder, the team has a new profile: a vigilante serial killer. All the victims are people who walked after being charged with serious crimes. The blindfold supposedly represents the blindfolded lady justice figure you see on scales.

There were a lot of interesting profiling details about vigilantes. It seems these BAU guys can't stop talking about criminals, even at dinner out at a Chinese restaurant. Sometimes I wonder if the TV writers don't add to the profiling truths that are spoken, just to embellish and dramatize, but I don't know that for sure.

Anyway, the episode was interesting but not as suspenseful in the last 10 minutes as I would have expected since they were hunting a killer about to claim another victim. It almost was anti-climactic the way they portrayed it.

I detected a bit of elitism on the part of Gideon and his group who see themselves and knowing and being a lot wiser than the this case with their thoughts about vigilantes and justice. That was brought out a few times, especially at the very end with "the man on the street interviews."

12 of 15 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
I am sorry but I have to defend Thomas Gibson... Josabeli
Who should they get for unsubs/victims? kzaatar
Does anyone know about the 75th army thing? shealaghbright
Prentiss + new guy johanna-81800
Quality dropping remarkable. Josabeli
What a shame they. .... toonbabe09
Discuss A Real Rain (2006) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: